Re:Reason ML toolchain
by RubenSandwich on Tuesday February 06, 2018 @08:58AM
(#16316216)
This is a small nitpick but the line: "OCaml's compiler is pretty unique, it's a set of pluggable parts that can be replaced and used together." is inaccurate. Most modern compilers are broken up into backends and frontends now, e.g. LLVM, JVM, .NET, etc.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Is the OCaml compiler really the same as those others though? I'd say it's more complex than that. It has a very large middle-end that most compilers don't. Things that are pluggable so far:
- Lexing/Parsing (ReasonML) - Preprocessing (PPX) - Backend (BuckleScript/js_of_ocaml)
Other parts of the compiler (not as pluggable?):
- Typechecking (which is really what makes it OCaml; TyPpx allows some changes) - Semantics (can be overridden with PPX somewhat) - Optimizations/middle passes (things like Flambda)
As an example of such architecture already in the 70's.
PL/8, used by IBM for doing their RISC research.
An Overview of the PL.8 Compiler (1982)
http://rsim.cs.illinois.edu/arch/qual_papers/compilers/ausla...
Re:Reason ML toolchain
by thangngoc89 on Tuesday February 06, 2018 @09:11AM
(#16316281)
Hey author here,
I'll look into this and update the post accordingly. Thank you
Re:Reason ML toolchain
by RubenSandwich on Tuesday February 06, 2018 @09:18AM
(#16316317)
No problem. Thanks for documenting the ReasonML toolchain and how it relates to OCaml.