News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by mful on Saturday February 03, 2018 @03:23PM (#16299411)
I'm getting a little sick of the level of entitlement in tech conversations — every firm must adhere perfectly to some set ideals or else the most vocal members in the community turn the conversation into an end-of-the-internet melodrama.

We laud companies that start by doing something small well, yet the second they don't support our platform of choice, it's time to banish them to the hills. (In this case, clearly there are material differences in video chat performance across browsers, or else why would Slack force Chrome support?)

We preach focus, then act appalled when customization feature X stagnates on the backlog.

We castigate businesses that spend investor dollars frivolously, and are then furious when well-funded companies act frugally and choose to make tradeoffs (like, say, only supporting one browser for a feature that doesn't work the same on all browsers, until they can achieve a certain quality threshold.)

I look forward to the day when we collectively accept that companies are groups of humans generally working in earnest to do their best, not some faceless behemoth that responds only to screaming "you're awful, do my feature or I'm leaving and tweeting about it" like some petulant child. Maybe there are cases where that is a reasonable response, but when the volume is always turned up to 11 it's hard to tell the real crises from distractions.

Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by dictum on Saturday February 03, 2018 @03:52PM (#16299576)
Without the heated tone ("entitlement in tech conversations") there's often no response to a valid complaint.

We only get clear explanations from a company's engineers after a discussion is raised.

> In this case, clearly there are material differences in video chat performance across browsers, or else why would Slack force Chrome support?

I look forward to a post on https://slack.engineering detailing the challenges. I'm not demanding a response, it's just a wish.

My decision to use a product takes certain principles into account; Slack is the kind of product that is often chosen for you by your company/open source project/community. A bit of "entitlement" — not meant as scare quotes, I just don't share the viewpoint – makes sense here, because sometimes you can't just choose not to use it.

Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by zkomp on Saturday February 03, 2018 @04:53PM (#16299889)
This exactly!

The error message say "Please switch to chrome"

It is clumsy. They probably ment to say: use Chrome for voice support.

Anyway: if it is entitlement to choose your own browser? Then I say: "switch to Internet Explorer 6"...

Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by nfm on Saturday February 03, 2018 @03:44PM (#16299532)
In principal, I agree. I'm certain Slack has run the numbers and decided the ROI of implementing cross-browser video calling is lower than whatever else they're investing engineering time into. Sure, they have a lot of capital, but it's a large undertaking. A vocal minority of Twitter users shouldn't sway this.

In practice, it's pretty lame that they've had voice calling for almost two years, and this has never been available in Firefox. We're not talking about old IE here. A basic implementation of voice only calling is not hard to do.

Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by gumby on Saturday February 03, 2018 @03:35PM (#16299492)
I disagree. If we let little monocultures exist they grow into big monocultures (Windows "monopoly", Facebook "monopoly" etc). I put "monopoly" in scare quotes because they had the de facto high ground rather than being monopolies in the Standard Oil sense.
Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by qbaqbaqba on Sunday February 04, 2018 @03:37AM (#16301937)
What about Slack "monopoly"?
Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by gumby on Sunday February 04, 2018 @03:31PM (#16304738)
A good example of what could happen, though hasn’t yet
Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by qbaqbaqba on Sunday February 04, 2018 @04:09PM (#16304943)
Yeah, current situation is more like oligopoly.
Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by mattst88 on Saturday February 03, 2018 @03:41PM (#16299517)
I've noticed the same thing -- often people refer to the "hive mind" feeling one way or another.

Rather than assuming individuals are just fickle, I think it makes much more sense that individuals are often only vocal about things they disagree with. We as readers don't know those individuals and lump them into our "hive mind" concept, as mistakenly assume that people's minds have changed.

Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by lousken on Saturday February 03, 2018 @07:20PM (#16300502)
They already made a choice to use non-native approach, so making one browser requirement is just laziness at this point.
Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by AndrewKemendo on Saturday February 03, 2018 @03:31PM (#16299466)
I'm getting a little sick of the level of entitlement in tech conversations

I'd argue it's gotten worse over the last few years, to the point that even questioning the attitude or bringing it up in conversation is frowned upon and heavily argued against.