News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by nikanj on Saturday February 03, 2018 @02:31PM (#16299103)
They raised quarter a billion(!) last summer.

What on earth are they doing with that money. Building web-based chat apps should not be that capital intensive

https://techcrunch.com/2017/07/26/slack-is-raising-a-250-mil...

Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by mping on Saturday February 03, 2018 @03:00PM (#16299264)
I bet they are using the money to strengthen their position, with marketing and enterprise penetration through integrations, etc. screenhero acquisition is an example.
Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by ch4s3 on Saturday February 03, 2018 @03:02PM (#16299280)
If their screenhero acquisition and subsequent integration is any indication of how they're spending their money, color me unimpressed.

edit What I mean is Slack ruined screenhero, which was amazing before they bought it. Slack's screen sharing is among the worst screen sharing tools I've ever used. It is beyond broken. It uses a massive amount of memory and cpu cycles while being too laggy to use for basic text editing. I actively hate it.

Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by t0mbstone on Saturday February 03, 2018 @04:29PM (#16299767)
Yep. It is literally the worst screen sharing tool I've ever used. Screenhero used to be amazing. My whole team would use it for pair programming.

Now, we've literally had to resort to using Teamviewer, because Slack is so bad.

Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by jamie_ca on Saturday February 03, 2018 @10:49PM (#16301216)
Yeah, we pay for Slack for chat and 1:1 voice/video, but all our group meetings at work are using Zoom. Far better experience, and the video quality has been great. Have had a few instances recently where people couldn't join the call and had to re-create the meeting, though.
Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by mping on Monday February 05, 2018 @03:59AM (#16307557)
I concur, SH used to be so much better; I think they acquired them to get a foot on the screenshare thing. Took them long enough, by the way.
Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by ch4s3 on Tuesday February 06, 2018 @03:19PM (#16319222)
Yeah, over a year and they really fumble the opportunity. I'm still looking for a good SH replacement.
Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by tejasmanohar on Saturday February 03, 2018 @04:04PM (#16299639)
Building an ecosystem. Slack's a business-- not some initiative to build cross-browser web apps. There's a lot to prioritize. When is the last time you've heard a company avoid Slack due to poor browser support?
Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by hkmurakami on Saturday February 03, 2018 @02:49PM (#16299206)
Reinvesting into ecosystem startups is one.

Salesofrce does this too fwiw.

Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by weberc2 on Saturday February 03, 2018 @02:44PM (#16299178)
Making web-based chat apps isn't an end to itself. If the company can't profit from a FF chat app then they won't make one.
Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by product50 on Saturday February 03, 2018 @02:52PM (#16299227)
Contrary to popular expectations not everything is about profits. Better user experience trumps $$ since once users are there, money will come in - it is literally Slack's business model where they charge for each new user.

Also, while people may feel frustrated about Firefox, I bet they have data showing that users are willing to switch to Chrome for Slack chat or calls when push comes to shove. Otherwise, you bet they would have prioritized this. Data driven development is all about making these kind of tradeoffs.

Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by weberc2 on Saturday February 03, 2018 @03:01PM (#16299274)
What is the difference is between "profits" and "money coming in"?
Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by product50 on Saturday February 03, 2018 @03:52PM (#16299572)
Don't go on a tangent.

The main point which I am making is that better user experience trumps everything. As we have seen time and again, once users love your product money will get figured out.

This is starkly different from your opinion above where all you care about is money and why ff doesn't fit into that narrative. Strong companies don't operate or think like that.

Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by weberc2 on Saturday February 03, 2018 @05:34PM (#16300077)
The tangent was yours. You set "profit" against "UX" and used "the ability of UX to generate money" as the rationale. From a corporate perspective, "UX" is a tool to generate profit, nothing more.

To get things back on track, Slack feels that supporting video chat for FF is not the most profitable thing it could do with its money factoring in the profit derived from the improved UX. This is different than "they have a quarter of a billion of dollars in investment and they think that's not enough to build voice chat for FF", which is the implication of the post to which I originally responded. Slack's purpose is to make money, not to "build as many video chat apps for as many platforms as possible"--modulo corruption or incompetence, it will only build clients for new platforms if the opportunity value is higher than the value of other opportunities.

Now, if you think that Slack's assessment is wrong and building a FF video chat app is the most profitable thing they could possibly do with their investment, then that's another conversation. I'm going to assume the people who operate the business, who have troves of information about the company and its opportunities, and who are deeply invested in its success are many times more likely than you or I (random Internet strangers) to know where the best opportunities lie, but that's still a separate conversation.

Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by solarkraft on Saturday February 03, 2018 @03:05PM (#16299302)
The money you spend in the process.
Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by weberc2 on Saturday February 03, 2018 @03:22PM (#16299409)
Presumably the OP meant something else or he is contradicting himself.
Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by rorykoehler on Sunday February 04, 2018 @05:04AM (#16302152)
Video chat doesn't even work in their installed app
Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by Afforess on Saturday February 03, 2018 @02:51PM (#16299225)
I'm curious why more money equals faster or better software engineering. Didn't we collectively learn from the Mythical Man Month and others that throwing people at a software problem doesn't scale? More engineers on a project increases communication and administrative overhead; the additional overhead and context costs quickly exceeds any productivity gained.

Given this: Why would more money scale, when people - presumably the thing the money would pay for - has already been shown not to scale?

Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by BoorishBears on Saturday February 03, 2018 @02:58PM (#16299255)
That applies to a single project and a single team.

With much less than a quarter billion dollars you could spin off new companies, "Slack Calls For Firefox Inc." and "Slack Calls For Edge Inc." each with it's own development team dedicated to supporting a given browser, and still not break the bank.

It's just a business choice. It's not they can't, do just don't feel it's worth it.

Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by godzillabrennus on Saturday February 03, 2018 @03:01PM (#16299275)
It shouldn’t be hard to document their API’s and then build a unique team to develop a front end for each browser. With $250M in funding and three major browsers I think it’s reasonable they could support them all that way.
Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by solarkraft on Saturday February 03, 2018 @03:04PM (#16299290)
Apparently they have a really good communications tool.
Re:Slack: Other browsers require significant effort so we're... by convolvatron on Saturday February 03, 2018 @03:10PM (#16299333)
one would hope that if you had skilled upper management sitting on 1B they would be able to invest that in both good engineers, and good builders of teams. and if those people weren't able to be effective to be able to track that and take appropriate action (again, with that giant financial lever).

the screwy part is that effective upper manager needs to have a deep and intuitive notion about software development organizations in order to be able to evaluate statements coming out of software effectively. but thats alot to ask, so they hire a vp eng with a nice sounding resume. that person turns out to not be very effective, and they translate their lack of discernment into a tier of equally useless middle managers. and if by accident a effective engineer gets hired they are completely unable to change things for the better because all the useless padding drowns out their voice.

everyone big company says that they have the resources of a big company but the tactical flexibility and empowerment of a small one. imagine what would you could accomplish were that to be true.