News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:There is no nanotech, stop talking about it and start lau... by tocomment on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @08:23AM (#1629551)
Why don't we have anything that can manipulate objects at the nano-scale? Couldn't we use atomic force microscopes to push some atoms together and at least make some interesting molecules (even if this process couldn't be scaled up)?

Also what ever happened to Feynman's idea of building half size remote controlled arms, which we then use to build half sized of that remote controlled arms, all the way down to a very small scale? Has anyone ever tried that?

Re:There is no nanotech, stop talking about it and start lau... by mechanical_fish on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @09:18AM (#1629663)
We do have things that can manipulate objects at the nano-scale. They're called catalysts, and when they're made out of amino acids they're called enzymes, and you and I are built out of them.

Yes, you can assemble molecules with AFM. The problem with this idea is that either (a) the molecules don't stick together at temperatures much above absolute zero, or (b) they do, in which case they might be stable at useful temperatures, in which case it's better to figure out how to get them to self-assemble or to find a catalyst/enzyme that helps them self-assemble. Because your nifty molecule just isn't that nifty if it doesn't exist in quantities of order 1 mole, and 1 mole is... a lot. You just won't believe how vastly mind-bogglingly big 10^23 is.

All of which boils down to this: This essay is great, but the meat of it really is in the first paragraph. Nanotech is a euphemism for chemistry and biochemistry. It is 100% possible -- indeed, nanotech is older than any human-invented technology by many orders of magnitude, by definition, because humans are built out of "nanotech" -- but it's all just chemistry. The real question is why the word nanotechnology is so much more fashionable in grant-writing circles than the old words.

Re:There is no nanotech, stop talking about it and start lau... by henrikschroder on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @09:15AM (#1629660)
That's kind of the point of the article, materials do not behave on a nano scale the same way they behave at our macro scale. You absolutely cannot scale down, you have to design from the bottom up instead.

The author thinks this is impossible because progress is slow. That's not really an argument, but I'll agree that "just you wait and see!" isn't one either.

However, biology shows us that it's not impossible to do self-replicating "machinery" so I think we'll get there one day, but it might probably be a lot more organic and a lot less mechanical than we currently envision when we say nanotech.

Re:There is no nanotech, stop talking about it and start lau... by fragmede on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @09:12AM (#1629647)
Re:There is no nanotech, stop talking about it and start lau... by nivertech on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @11:00AM (#1629964)
When I was a child, I read a SciFi story about one guy, who built such an arm. Then using this arm under the microscope he built a set of microscopic tools, etc.

Later in the story he fighting with bacteria and viruses, but because of the feedback of his microscopic arm, he was injured and almost killed by these tiny creatures.

Re:There is no nanotech, stop talking about it and start lau... by asmithmd1 on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @08:58AM (#1629610)
That is one of the authors points -- no one has done self replication on a macro scale and nanotech just assumes self replication at the molecular level
Re:There is no nanotech, stop talking about it and start lau... by crayz on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @09:34AM (#1629700)
This is really a straw man argument. If you go read Drexler's blog(e.g. this series: http://metamodern.com/2009/12/19/molecular-manufacturing-whe...), he is very explicit that the path forward is studying natural self-assembly from DNA and then tearing that apart, finding how it works, and modularizing/modifying it for our own purposes. None of this appears to be a "crazy idea" or something out of humanity's reach til long after we're all dead, as this author claims

Drexler's egotistical to be sure. It doesn't make him wrong

Re:There is no nanotech, stop talking about it and start lau... by jacquesm on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @01:08PM (#1630384)
That's the main problem with this piece, it attacks a Drexler that no longer exists, his views have shifted quite a bit from back then.
Re:There is no nanotech, stop talking about it and start lau... by abecedarius on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @11:36PM (#1631947)
I think it attacks a Drexler that never existed; the chapter in Nanosystems on ways forward outlined similar ideas to that more recent post. Just because the bulk of Nanosystems explores a class of systems that's easier to analyze and currently impossible to build, he wasn't ever saying "Let's try to build this class of systems! Right now!" The OP was a total caricature.
Re:There is no nanotech, stop talking about it and start lau... by Symmetry on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @09:17AM (#1629662)
That's not really true, we self-replicate all the time (thanks mom and dad). What we don't know how to do is design things that self-replicate from scratch, but we do already have plenty of existence proofs.

Also, self-replication is actually easier at the molecular level because all the parts are perfectly regular.

Re:There is no nanotech, stop talking about it and start lau... by plato on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @09:30AM (#1629692)
And we can think too, and you can see where is AI in that moment. :)

And ducks can fly with flexible wings.

And the Sun is a thermonuclear reactor.

You can find demonstrations of this type of things everywhere, that doesn't means that we can make them work with our materials, techniques and knowledge.

Nanotech seems to my like AI, always there, at just two steps... that's the type of problems that smell to vaporware from miles.

Re:There is no nanotech, stop talking about it and start lau... by billswift on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @02:36PM (#1630675)
Somebody said that the reason there is no progress in AI is that once a problem domain is understood well enough that there are working applications in it, nobody calls it AI any longer.
Re:There is no nanotech, stop talking about it and start lau... by JabavuAdams on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @09:31AM (#1629694)
Yeah, we have nano-forges. They're called wombs.

Now if only we could re-program women to make iPhones. The late-night trips to the gas station and gravel store because wife has another petroleum and sand-craving would totally be worth it.

Re:There is no nanotech, stop talking about it and start lau... by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @09:32AM (#1629696)
Somebody just created artificial DNA, put it in another cell, and it self-replicated. So yes we DO know how to do this now.
Re:There is no nanotech, stop talking about it and start lau... by plato on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @10:04AM (#1629792)
We know how to train the brain of a human being to learn physics (well not always), but that doesn't means that we understand how that brain really works.

The life if full of examples of things we know how to use but that we don't understand. Sometimes it's just impossible to control that things. Think in the stock market or economics. Chemist has been studying this type of things for centuries and you can see the result: there are chemical products everywhere you look.

What the post attack is the concept of creating nanomachines that doesn't degrade (Cosmic rays! oxidation! temperature!!) and do exactly what we want.

And about the "artificial DNA", it's something so simple... Really! the problem is in the emergent properties of DNA, proteins and environmental effects, this is where you loose control. Even nature has problems with that, life forms die, had cancer...

Re:There is no nanotech, stop talking about it and start lau... by Symmetry on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @09:50AM (#1629752)
Yeah, but we were reusing the cell's own molecular machinery there. What I was thinking of, though I wasn't clear, was all new machinery.
Re:There is no nanotech, stop talking about it and start lau... by pjscott on Tuesday August 24, 2010 @12:49PM (#1630337)
Self-replicating nanotech is only one kind. All you really need to be able to do is build nanomachines; whether they're built by identical nanomachines or by some big contraption doesn't matter to the end result.