Re:A.I. Has Arrived in Investing, Humans Are Still Dominating
by Noos on Saturday February 03, 2018 @03:23PM
(#16299418)
I don't agree. I feel that chess engines have killed chess as a pastime that people play. I know growing up in the 80s I played it during lunch at school, and schools had chess clubs which really weren't on the order of forming neophyte pros, but just students who liked the game.
But now it's rather futile to play it, because at some point you'll run up against a machine that can outplay you perfectly. I mean, before you could play a grandmaster or something, but the moment you or someone else for you buys a ten-dollar chess program, you realize that despite improvement, the computer will always defeat you.
I don't really see chess as that big any more in the public eye. The kids might play Minecraft, which rewards human creativity and doesn't really force you to compete against an A.I. optimized to beat 99% of all Minecraft players.
Re:A.I. Has Arrived in Investing, Humans Are Still Dominating
by adw on Monday February 05, 2018 @02:10PM
(#16311153)
As a sport, yes. We do the same with the 100m dash, and there is no-one anywhere who would employ humans based on the business utility of being to run 100 metres fast outside of entertainment. Pro chess is in the entertainment business; the strength of the players isn't really material to that.
You're confusing the economics of recreation and entertainment with the economics of efficiently making things. They both exist, but they're very different.
Re:A.I. Has Arrived in Investing, Humans Are Still Dominating
by robotresearcher on Friday February 02, 2018 @08:29PM
(#16295592)
But the purpose of chess is taking part and having fun. The purpose of finance is making money. The comparison is weird. No one will give their money to someone to manage for fun if an AI could make more money.
It's not like everybody has somehow switched to watching engine games. That is in fact just a niche market of the chess world. We are humans and as such we still enjoy seeing real humans thrive and compete in chess more than we care about machines.
If anything chess is the perfect example that the pessimism is misplaced, chess engines have not killed chess as a human endeavour.