News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Baltimore Cops Kept Toy Guns to Plant Just in Case They S... by pornel on Thursday February 01, 2018 @06:44AM (#16281147)
The article is about people literally trying to get away with murder. The last two sentences are references to well-documented cases of police officers killing non-dangerous citizens. There's no reason to be polite about this.
Re:Baltimore Cops Kept Toy Guns to Plant Just in Case They S... by krapp on Thursday February 01, 2018 @08:23AM (#16281649)
>There's no reason to be polite about this.

There is - the tone of the article affects the tone of the thread. Hacker News is supposed to be about intellectually gratifying discussion, but an article whose purpose is to spark outrage results in comments full of invective and tedious boilerplate. Cathartic for people who want to rant about Americans and guns and ACAB... but we've already been there and done that and read that a hundred times.

Re:Baltimore Cops Kept Toy Guns to Plant Just in Case They S... by mcphage on Thursday February 01, 2018 @09:20AM (#16281971)
> Hacker News is supposed to be about intellectually gratifying discussion

You're confusing "intellectually gratifying" with "apathy".

Re:Baltimore Cops Kept Toy Guns to Plant Just in Case They S... by krapp on Thursday February 01, 2018 @12:12PM (#16283575)
>You're confusing "intellectually gratifying" with "apathy".

You're confusing endorphin hooks and virtue signalling with action. Being outraged on an internet forum doesn't lead to progress against police corruption.

Re:Baltimore Cops Kept Toy Guns to Plant Just in Case They S... by musage on Thursday February 01, 2018 @09:02AM (#16281867)
> Cathartic for people who want to rant about Americans and guns and ACAB

How are such straw men intellectually gratifying? How is that not tedious boilerplate? How is you reading something a hundred times even a factor compared to hundreds of murders swept under the rug? Don't wanna read about it, put an end to it.

Re:Baltimore Cops Kept Toy Guns to Plant Just in Case They S... by guildwriter on Thursday February 01, 2018 @09:28AM (#16282028)
I'd love to hear a discussion of methods to solve the issues with our police and the despair of the inner city that were comprehensive. In the case of Baltimore, these are massive systemic problems that involve not just the police, but also the community as a whole and forces outside the community as well. How can you discuss the problems with police misconduct without talking about the drug war, inner city poverty, stat based policing and the poisonous incentives they create, the lack of stable homes, and so on and so on and so on.

Yes you might be able to solve police misconduct by forcing them to turn on each other and report and aggressively as possible. You probably will utterly destroy any semblance of morale and group cohesion and won't have a functioning police force at the end. Yes, we could ban guns from the population. Except that would not only require a constitutional amendment, but also solve the logistical issues of tracking down guns while simultaneously solving the problem of an armed criminal element who now has a helpless population in a massive country where response times can be 20 mins or longer. Body cams will help, but even if people trust police, how does that solve the problem where being a drug dealer is probably the best opportunity you have in the inner city? And it goes on and on.

It's a similar issue to homelessness. It's a multivariate problem that requires many different targeted approaches to deal with the entire thing. People unfortunately tend to focus on their pet issue of choice and ignore the others. Worse yet, political interests often will try to shut down each other from getting funding in order to push their own cause du jour.

Re:Baltimore Cops Kept Toy Guns to Plant Just in Case They S... by krapp on Thursday February 01, 2018 @09:10AM (#16281921)
I never said I didn't want to read about it - only that the bar should be higher than the bottom of the barrel. A subject like this can be discussed without resorting to polemics.

> How is you reading something a hundred times even a factor compared to hundreds of murders swept under the rug?

You have provided a perfect example of what this discussion does not need, and what articles like the above lead to, thank you.

Re:Baltimore Cops Kept Toy Guns to Plant Just in Case They S... by weberc2 on Thursday February 01, 2018 @07:54AM (#16281496)
It's not about being polite, it's about coming to absurd conclusions that generalize a million people based on a handful of carefully selected malefactors. We can say, "we want to reduce police corruption" without peddling or subscribing to this complete nonsense (which is unfortunately The Root's wheelhouse).
Re:Baltimore Cops Kept Toy Guns to Plant Just in Case They S... by bjl on Thursday February 01, 2018 @08:21AM (#16281630)
If it was only a handful of malefactors, then the rest of them should be forcing the bad apples out quickly, and calling for justice. The fact that the vast majority of police officers remain silent lends some credence to the generalisation.
Re:Baltimore Cops Kept Toy Guns to Plant Just in Case They S... by talmand on Thursday February 01, 2018 @10:01AM (#16282263)
The difference is that bad cops are a minor percentage, the fact that the rest protect their own is the generalization you are looking for. The other comment proposes the generalization that all cops will shoot you in the face, which is comically wrong on many levels.
Re:Baltimore Cops Kept Toy Guns to Plant Just in Case They S... by ckastner on Thursday February 01, 2018 @06:55AM (#16281200)
The article is about a sub-group of these people, but the tone to me as well was one of sweeping generalizations.

Edit (instead of replying to all of the individual replies):

I'll be the first to acknowledge that there are systemic problems in police forces worldwide, just like there are systemic problems in any large organization, especially one endowed which so much executive power.

However, any argument that paints a picture of "uniform equals bad" is, in my opinion, not only delusional, but is also a severe injustice to the good apples in public service, that is: in service to the public.

Re:Baltimore Cops Kept Toy Guns to Plant Just in Case They S... by piva00 on Thursday February 01, 2018 @07:12AM (#16281274)
I'm originally from Brazil and I hear that same argument about cops over there, that bad ones are a minority, that we shouldn't generalise.

I don't buy it, the system itself enables this, if it didn't then those bad apples would have been detected and expelled before they could cause so much damage. It can be a minority doing that but they have affected so much that the whole itself is no longer trustworthy and requires reconstruction from the ground up, the foundations themselves have been damaged and as it would be for a structure or a car, when the base structure that supports everything else cannot be repaired you need a new one.

That's what should happen in Baltimore, that's what should happen with the Brazilian military and civilian police, their foundations aren't good enough to be trusted anymore.

Re:Baltimore Cops Kept Toy Guns to Plant Just in Case They S... by alphabettsy on Thursday February 01, 2018 @10:12AM (#16282344)
Well the saying is bad apples spoil the bunch, and obviously in some cases the whole bunch is spoiled but we refuse to believe it, and instead still think we’re at the few bad apples part.
Re:Baltimore Cops Kept Toy Guns to Plant Just in Case They S... by mikepurvis on Thursday February 01, 2018 @07:00AM (#16281223)
Any member of the force, its leadership, or the surrounding politicians who is not 100% supporting the investigation and calling for heads to roll, is complicit. If that's a large enough group, then a sweeping generalization is absolutely warranted.

"Bad apple" arguments only work if there's actual evidence of "good apples" working to expel the bad ones.

Re:Baltimore Cops Kept Toy Guns to Plant Just in Case They S... by weberc2 on Thursday February 01, 2018 @07:56AM (#16281505)
There's no evidence that even 1% of all police are complicit. What is your standard for "large enough"?
Re:Baltimore Cops Kept Toy Guns to Plant Just in Case They S... by mikepurvis on Thursday February 01, 2018 @08:09AM (#16281576)
Is there evidence of 99% of supposedly non-complicit officers standing with victims, insisting on justice for those guilty?

Because that's the standard I'm calling for.

Re:Baltimore Cops Kept Toy Guns to Plant Just in Case They S... by weberc2 on Thursday February 01, 2018 @01:24PM (#16284300)
"Is there evidence of 99% of supposedly non-complicit muslims standing with victims of terrorism, insisting on justice for those guilty?"

"Is there evidence of 99% of supposedly non-complicit blacks standing with victims of black crime, insisting on justice for those guilty?"

If you assume that everyone in a group is guilty of some crime committed by a tiny fraction because there isn't evidence that 99% of them condemn the guilty, then you're participating in a conspiracy and you're validating a dangerous line of reasoning that can be weaponized against anyone, including groups that you care about and/or belong to.

Re:Baltimore Cops Kept Toy Guns to Plant Just in Case They S... by mikepurvis on Thursday February 01, 2018 @01:34PM (#16284413)
But police _as an institution_ are entrusted with the public safety. The relationships between the officers and the institution and the institution and the public are both totally different than for the other groups you named.

It's not the same at all.

Re:Baltimore Cops Kept Toy Guns to Plant Just in Case They S... by weberc2 on Thursday February 01, 2018 @03:29PM (#16285561)
First of all, police in the U.S. aren't an institution--they're beholden to local governments (and state governments in the case of state patrol). Ergo you can't [reasonably] generalize about police nationally based on a handful of malfeasants.

The idea that police nationally get together and conspire violence against the public or even a particular racial group is beyond absurd. This is among the most dubious of conspiracy theories, and I don't know how such theorists can hope to be regarded as credible, reasonable people.

Re:Baltimore Cops Kept Toy Guns to Plant Just in Case They S... by Pharylon on Thursday February 01, 2018 @07:01AM (#16281225)
As long as police unions fight reform it's the institution as a whole that's the problem, not a small sub-group.
[dead]
Re:Baltimore Cops Kept Toy Guns to Plant Just in Case They S... by yters on Thursday February 01, 2018 @08:01AM (#16281539)
So apparently our police force is equivalent to ISIS. I guess it would be better if gangs ruled the streets. At least they don't do as many bad things as the cops do.
Re:Baltimore Cops Kept Toy Guns to Plant Just in Case They S... by Clubber on Thursday February 01, 2018 @08:28AM (#16281670)
It's not either or. The Marines have much better trigger discipline that many cops that make the headlines lately.