I provided two sentences. I'm assuming the second one was unobjectionable to just about everyone:
> Those advertisers weren't affecting your opinion of what your own culture was, they were affecting your opinion of a foreign culture.
The first one
> Maybe if you'd spent longer than a week there you'd have a more informed view of how one or more groups of locals really spent their time?
is overtly insulting inasmuch as it explicitly calls ryankshaw's view of local Hawaiian culture uninformed. But his comment is a story about himself in which he draws the moral that his view of local Hawaiian culture is uninformed. I don't see how my response can avoid referring to him personally, since the only content of his comment is a story about himself, or why it should avoid agreeing with his own assessment of his knowledge of Hawaiian culture.
Do you find the hypothetical
> Maybe the locals have a clearer view of "what the locals do" than tourists who have been there for a week do?
to be less acerbic or more in line with your guidelines?
I think that's a fairly relevant counterpoint to an observation beginning "I just spent a week in Hawaii".
You think it's hitting below the belt to observe that ryankshaw's opinion is based on one week in a culture he's not familiar with, just because "tourist making conclusions after spending one week in an unfamiliar culture" is such a well-known example of terrible reasoning that it's become a stereotype?
I didn't even make that point. I limited myself to observing that a longer-term experience would probably give a more reliable impression.
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html