That line is probably labelled 'symbiotic' on one side and 'parasitic' on the other.
I think it's the user's choice. People installing ad blockers, and in some cases re-using their space for another purposes, is the market sending a signal to Google. Google and other ad hosts can get cranky as much as they want, but it's my browser on my computer and my browsing experience.
If they offered an ad-free for-pay version, I'm sure they'll get many customers. Heck, they would make money off of me when I am not giving them any right now.
Never mind that the user owns the browser, the whole principle of gmail being free is that it is ad supported and this project was launched in the hope that as large a number of people as they can attract would adopt it.
So at some point it will start to affect googles bottom line. Is that ok?
Of course it is the browser on your computer, that's fine. But this is not you doing this, it's rapportive doing it, setting up shop inside googles pages displayed on your computer.
I think in this analogy, he'd be right outside my window, not in my store. As you say, I'm not selling whipped cream to begin with.
> after all, none of the ones buying ice-cream were buying chocolate anyway?
If my customers weren't buying the chocolate then why am I stocking it? Clearly, there's something for me to learn here from the guy outside my window. Perhaps I should have a chat with him and see what we can do together. After all, the more people that come by my shop, the more opportunities I have to sell them ice lollies.
Indeed, so the right conclusion is that chocolate probably was being sold, in spite of what you might theorize about it.
That's the user's choice. For me as an ice cream vendor it would suck. For me as a user, it's a more yummy cone.
Now in the case of google that's a stretch, but this is not 'ok because it is google', neither would it be 'illegal because the party it is done to is small and vulnerable'.
It's either 'ok' or it is 'not ok' not taking in to account the size of the party it is done to.
Also, can any HN Adwords users comment on their experiences using Adwords to advertise to Gmail in terms of effectiveness?
It seems to me that a large portion of the ads (gmail) are from unsophisticated Adwords advertisers that have not configured their campaigns properly.
Besides, how is this different than ad blocking? I install in my browser plugins that improve my browsing experience. That includes flashblock, adblock plus, pop-up blockers (a feature historically so popular that it is now built-in the major browsers), and other addons that alter the content I see on the web page.
Another example: People share hosts files that block different annoying services like intellitxt and Snap Shots. This is no different in this regard.
Rapportive is actually better because the space previously used by ads that I would never click is now actually useful. It's a step forward from simple ad blocking.
Edit: various grammar/clarity fixes.