You can certainly argue that the defendant didn't intend to defame someone and included a statement that the image was fake. But as I said, that statement would not eliminate your liability for the tort; it would merely mitigate the damages.
Tort law is complicated and isn't something you can just pick up by browsing the internet for a few minuets. I've handled these types of cases before. Have you?
Of course. OTOH, if you build it into the image/video, that's trivial to assure for each publication you are involved in, and subsequent publication by some other third party of some subsequent modified image that removed the statement of falsity is no different than if someone republishes a modified version for your statement that someone is not a child molester which omits the “not”.
> Tort law is complicated
(9_9)
> and isn't something you can just pick up by browsing the internet for a few minuets.
Yeah, I've never really questioned the decision I made to actually buy and study the required texts, etc., when I took Torts, rather than just spending a few minutes studying on the internet, so I really don't need anyone to validate that for me.
(Now, if we were talking about false light, in the jurisdictions which recognize it, rather than defamation, this would be a trickier issue, I think.)
That's not what I was referring to.
People who are publishing these videos are at the same time publicly say that these are works of fiction and fake. Not sometime later; right at the same time. They publish it in the reddit that has "fake" in the name. They often put "fake" in the title. They sometimes watermark it with a word "fake".
How can this be defamation or libel?
By posting it to reddit or online, the deepfaker should have expected that it would be further disseminated (and that is the standard they will be held to, even if they didn't actually expect that). In order for statement of falsity to be a defense to defamtion, they would have to take steps to reasonably ensure that the statement accompanies the further dissemination of the video/image. This means intrinsically tying it to the fake content. A filename wouldn't be enough; they would need to embed it into the video itself, at the points where the images are faked, into order to avoid liability for defamation. Anything less than that and every jury in the country would find them liable for defamation.
Tort law is complicated. The deepfaker of Daisy Ridley is in for a world of hurt if she chooses to pursue a defamation claim. On the other hand, the news sites that posted clips from the deepfake are not.That's an entirely separate discussion...
Would a good watermark suffice, for example?
What if the statement or image was labeled as a fake from its inception, not just "after the fact"?
By your logic, this statement is defamatory/libel:
"This statement is false: Barack Obama killed a man just to watch him die and also cheats at cards."
The apple is the original scenario: a deep fake with an accompanying and severable statement, not part of the deep fake, that the image/video is fake. (The severability of the statement matters. If you want to know why, get a Westlaw subscription and spend a few weeks reading defamation case law.)
The orange is the statement about BO. The claim of falsity is intrinsically tied (structurally and contextually) to the false statement accompanying it; they are a single contextual unit. Moreover, the claim of falsity precedes the allegedly defamatory statement to which it is unseverably tied so it is clear at the time of publication that the statement is intended to be false. And let's not even get into the heightened standard that applies defamation claims for public figures...
> The claim of falsity is intrinsically tied (structurally and contextually) to the false statement accompanying it; they are a single contextual unit.
I don't see how that can't or couldn't apply to a deepfake: the creator could name the file making clear it was a fake, or put a caption in corner of the video stating so.
The "this statement is false" in my example seems just as separable as that. Someone could edit it out or fail to quote it, etc.
Some of your other comments are about trivial issues: the grammar could be trivially changed to put the clause noting falsity at the end. I also used a public figure as an example, because the name came to mind quickly, but you might as well substitute a normal person's name for Obama's.