News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is It Legal to Swap Someone’s Face into Porn Without Cons... by gamblor956 on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @12:42PM (#16275709)
In the US, it is a well-settled point of law that the defamatory act is the publication of the false image. The statement that the image is fake is not a defense unless it accompanies every publication of the image and identifies the fake aspects of it at every occurrence.

You can certainly argue that the defendant didn't intend to defame someone and included a statement that the image was fake. But as I said, that statement would not eliminate your liability for the tort; it would merely mitigate the damages.

Tort law is complicated and isn't something you can just pick up by browsing the internet for a few minuets. I've handled these types of cases before. Have you?

Re:Is It Legal to Swap Someone’s Face into Porn Without Cons... by dragonwriter on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @01:05PM (#16275951)
> The statement that the image is fake is not a defense unless it accompanies every publication

Of course. OTOH, if you build it into the image/video, that's trivial to assure for each publication you are involved in, and subsequent publication by some other third party of some subsequent modified image that removed the statement of falsity is no different than if someone republishes a modified version for your statement that someone is not a child molester which omits the “not”.

> Tort law is complicated

(9_9)

> and isn't something you can just pick up by browsing the internet for a few minuets.

Yeah, I've never really questioned the decision I made to actually buy and study the required texts, etc., when I took Torts, rather than just spending a few minutes studying on the internet, so I really don't need anyone to validate that for me.

(Now, if we were talking about false light, in the jurisdictions which recognize it, rather than defamation, this would be a trickier issue, I think.)