It is worth noting though, that ICOs are primarily a problem because there are a lot of hungry investors looking to 100x their returns, and don't have the tech background required to dissect a whitepaper. Protecting the gullible and uninformed from the manipulative is one of hardest tasks of any society, and the fight is never ending.
Take wash trading. How can you possibly ban wash trading? To do this you need to verify that identity of seller X != identity of seller Y. Even dismissing currencies that actively prohibit this verification (Monero), how do you possibly accomplish this in a decentralized currency?
Even without the identities issue, who is looking at bitcoin governance and thinking that deciding protocol changes with a decentralized electoral system is going to produce anything but gamesmanship and paralysis. Promising newcomer coins Abc will have the same issues once there's real money at stake.
And yes. Manipulation exist in the traditional monetary system. However, regulations raise the cost of manipulation to prohibitively high levels for most people. And yes, congress is dysfunctional. But underneath the chaos we have a set of fairly well established rules, and changing those rules didn't require forking the currency.
The problems with our economic system are political, not technological. What crypto brings to money is superfluous technology and even worse politics than we already have.
What crypto does to finance is eliminate more middle men than ever before and bring more transparency than ever before. The majority of people would consider that a good thing.
It doesn't mean the poor get wealthier or the rich get poorer, it just means things are more transparent, which creates a more level playing field.
Billions of dollars can't just go 'missing' like it can in the traditional fiat system for a variety of reasons - mainly because we're relying on humans to (a) be honest and (b) remember to manually file paperwork.
Crypto brings its own set of problems but like any form of technology, it will evolve over time so long as there are advantages to using it. And so long as it evolves, there'll always be new opportunities along with new casualties.
So we have more transparency with these completely opaque ICO situations where the company name and country of operation isn't even clear? Versus the highly regulated filing requirements and GAAP independent audit requirements of a public company? Huh?
No more than repeat offenders remind you of why Gulags exist. In your mind the hypothetical libertarian just doesn't want any regulation because he forgets that regulations have any good impact.
It's simply tone deaf.
> In the end you may end up with something very much looking like a government, where people with connections and leverage in the governing structures get to decide the evolution of the rules, where a few players with disproportionate wealth or hashing power, help elect those people to committee positions. And once again, people will be looking to create systems to escape the defacto control and cronyism imposed on the system.
There are 'good governments' and 'bad governments'. The rich and powerful try to game the system in both of them but there are much more effective in bad govts than in good govts.
So the question is, what separates a society which ends up with good governments (for example western societies) than societies which end up with bad governments (pretty much all the non-western societies).
This is precisely where the argument breaks down. According to libertarians, there is a reason X (whatever that might be) which separates good from bad governments. According to libertarians, that reason is 'economic freedom', the places where good govt exists, there is economic freedom, and places with bad government lacks economic freedom (even dictatorship like Singapore, UAE, or ex-dictatorships like S Korea are far better off than their non-economic free counterparts).
You may disagree what the cause 'X' is (according to alt-right that cause X is genetic-cultural environment, as places with good govt tend to be white westerners and places with bad govt tend to be non-white non-westerners).
But a plain denial of differences between good govts and bad govts is insane.
The difference with cryptocurrencies, and the part I find particularly exciting, is this time the structure is independent of nation states. Conceptually this is a big leap forward. I do agree with "meet the new boss, same as the old boss", that is likely the scenario. But even incremental improvements in objective rule of law have improved the human condition, and if cryptocurrencies can improve this in the financial realm that is a good thing.
Also not to imply that the whole space isn't rife with scams and foolish ideas at the moment, nor to imply nation states aren't going to plant a boot firmly on the head of the entire program as that well could happen. Because at the end of the day it sits on a platform that is ultimately controlled by nation states.
This is the real impact they will have in the long run: the technology will greatly expand the set of people and organizations who can issue a currency. Fiat will have a lot of competition that it didn't have before. Competition is bad for incumbents, but good for the rest of us.
So the libertarian dream will probably still be realized, just in a more measured manner than some frenzied speculators and early adopters would have you believe (which shouldn't come as a surprise at all).
At that time it'll gain momentum and thwart the current system.
Also, facebook had a huge amount of money to throw at marketing. That shouldn't be forgotten. They essentially bought success by spending that money, when lots of other social networks never were able to do so.
Cryptocurrencies created a completely anarchic monetary system, which people have used to layer investment systems on top of. Naturally, low hanging fruit scams and cons have arisen, and some form of governing structure will eventually be imposed, if not by actual governments, then by the community. Then more sophisticated abuses and negative externalities will arise, and ever more sophisticated regulations will be imposed by the community to thwart them.
In the end you may end up with something very much looking like a government, where people with connections and leverage in the governing structures get to decide the evolution of the rules, where a few players with disproportionate wealth or hashing power, help elect those people to committee positions. And once again, people will be looking to create systems to escape the defacto control and cronyism imposed on the system.
I guess what I'm saying is, nature abhors a vacuum, and given human nature, most systems will evolve to thwart the worse tendencies of the worst people, opening opportunities for others to capture power. So in the end, rather than seek to bring down our democratically elected government monetary systems via technology, we should seek to evolve them with ideas from technology.
Because booting out fiat currency and rebooting with crypto really just forces a painful relearning of all of the lessons we've learned in the last century of modern finance.