Why would they need to have those agreements if people were being paid a fair price?
Note that I'm not saying that every software engineer (let alone line cooks) at Google has been paid fairly. But some of us have been fortunate, and I don't think I'm all that atypical.
Your claim that people working at a company with enormous cash reserves cannot possibly have been paid fairly is wrong, and it's condescending to tell people that they are "weird" for understanding their own situation.
I didn't say that it wasn't possible for someone working for a company with huge cash reserves to have been paid fairly.
What does that have to do with anything?
It’s the same thing as poor whites clinging to racism because they think it elevates their class position. False consciousness abounds.
Software and the internet, thankfully, is generally libertarian because thats how the internet generally behaves. Otherwise, the U.S. would bar foreigners from practicing software engineering, and limit the amount of people that can have a software license.
No they are not, for any sense of the word.
> and it is one of the reasons of high cost of health care and under-supply.
No, they are not. Aside from the fact that doctors collectively have about zero control over the total supply, physician earnings account for about 7% of healthcare expenditures. That's a drop in the bucket, even if you reduced that to zero.
> Otherwise, the U.S. would bar foreigners from practicing software engineering, and limit the amount of people that can have a software license.
This much is completely true, and you can look to the incredibly long and xenophobic history of labor unions for evidence of that.
It’s an issue with the tool startups use to run their businesses: either C or S corps.
What if a startup used a DAO instead of a corporation? I’d suspect you’d see the rate paid out by the smart contract would be proportional to an engineer’s contribution.
Measuring the engineer’s contribution is non-obvious though; it’s not a simple metric like LoC, bug reports closed, feature requests completed, etc.
My father went from being a union steward to having grievances filed against him as a member of management during his ~40 years at GE.
I've seen both sides.
imo, unions are best suited for workers who have no leverage: at jobs where the worker is an interchangeable part, or is unspecialized, or where the labor market is flooded, or when they want to minimize changing employers - software development is none of the above.
Personally, I think software developers should be paid 2-4x what they are now - I say that as a developer, and as an employer who cut their checks at a company I helped start. Their value-add is just way higher than the current pay rate reflects.
How to achieve that? Maybe a professional organization is needed - similar to doctors - but a union and all its trappings? Meh.