News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by jacques_chester on Tuesday January 30, 2018 @07:21PM (#16270313)
This is a good move for CoreOS and Red Hat, I think.

I've thought for a while that the platform market would shake out and be left with one and at most two winners. Previously we saw Deis fold into Microsoft and now CoreOS into Red Hat.

I expect that Docker will run independently for another few years before their investors realise it's time to push for an acquisition exit, but it's unclear by whom. I figure Heptio will go to one of Red Hat, Google or Microsoft.

As for CoreOS's technologies, my guess is that Red Hat will be gently herding Tectonic and Container Linux users to OpenShift and RHEL respectively. About the only products I expect to survive fully intact would be Quay and etcd.

Disclosure: I work for Pivotal, we compete with Red Hat and Docker. So read my remarks with whatever mix of skepticism and mirth you think is appropriate.

Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by politician on Tuesday January 30, 2018 @09:53PM (#16270953)
I agree that this is a good move by Red Hat to position themselves with rkt and Quay ahead of Docker going to Microsoft (who will pay a premium to try to put this genie back into the bottle)

Given their self-inflicted XHR debacle that dethroned Office, I just don't see Microsoft passing up this opportunity.

Google, on the other hand, doesn't need Docker to plug any holes in their go to market unless it's a blocking play. However, Docker is already cozy with Microsoft, so I don't see a Google acquisition going anywhere.

Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by zapita on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @02:37AM (#16272204)
> this is a good move by Red Hat to position themselves with rkt

Red Hat does not give a damn about rkt. They care about Kubernetes, specifically establishing and consolidating a dominant position in upstream kubernetes development. CoreOS helps them do that.

rkt on the other hand is a dead project and completely useless to Red Hat.

> Google, on the other hand, doesn't need Docker to plug any holes in their go to market unless it's a blocking play.

Google has a massive hole in their go to market. They have no clue how to sell to enterprises, and because of that they are falling behind AWS and Microsoft in the cloud market. However you're right that it would take much more than a Docker to plug that hole.

Honestly if I were Google I would try to buy Red Hat, or an even larger enterprise vendor like SAP or Oracle. Not only would they be buying the enterprise distribution they lack, but they would also secure a major customer for their own infrastructure and keep up with the economies of scale AMZN and MSFT are building up. But I don't know that they will develop the humility to admit that they need that - and even if they do there's no guarantee that the integration would work... Culturally they are worlds apart.

EDIT: another interesting acquisition target for Google Cloud would be Vmware. Diane Greene founded it, then got fired by EMC post-acquisition, something I am betting she still holds a grudge over. Now she runs Google Cloud. If I'm her, I like the idea of buying the place and savoring a triumphal Steve Jobs takeover moment. I don't know to what extent this is complicated by this week's announcement of a Vmware/Dell reverse merger. Maybe they buy the whole thing? But then would Michael Dell want to run this new mega-Cloud group? And how does that play with Diane's ambitions? This might bool down to whether Diane likes the idea of working for Michael Dell. He has vastly more go-to-market experience which is what matters most in their position.

I really think there should be an HBO Silicon Valley - Enterprise spinoff :-)

Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by kakwa_ on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @03:41AM (#16272437)
Frankly, I'm not sure why Google would acquire RedHat, SAP or Oracle.

I'm not sure what will be gain from that. Google probably doesn't care about the softwares these companies provides as it has its own internal alternatives/derivative and Google is not really a software vendor, so it's a bit outside of their core business.

What would make more sense in my opinion would be for Google to have a partnership with a big Enterprise player (or several in fact) and promote it loudly.

Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by zapita on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @03:53AM (#16272482)
> Frankly, I'm not sure why Google would acquire RedHat, SAP or Oracle.

Enterprise distribution. Without significant enterprise revenue, Google Cloud will never catch up to AWS and Azure. Nobody can beat Google on technology, but technology alone cannot solve this.

> I'm not sure what will be gain from that. Google probably doesn't care about the softwares these companies provides as it has its own internal alternatives/derivative and Google is not really a software vendor, so it's a bit outside of their core business.

Google Cloud absolutely is a software vendor. They sell cloud services which compete directly with traditional enterprise software. Their services are superior in many ways, but enterprise adoption is definitely not one of them. That is the problem they could solve by buying an enterprise-savvy competitor.

As a bonus, these traditional software vendors are all racing to deploy cloud versions of their software. Because they have massive install bases, they can drive enterprise workloads to the cloud of their choice.

What would make more sense in my opinion would be for Google to have a partnership with a big Enterprise player (or several in fact) and promote it loudly.

They are already partnering aggressively, just like their competitors. I think they announced exactly this with SAP recently.

But partnerships have their limits. Most vendors will not allow themselves to grow too dependent on their main competitors. If they did, they would lose all leverage in the deal, and slowly starve as Big Cloud grabs all the margins. And then we're back to the acquisition scenario.

Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by sah2ed on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @08:43AM (#16273733)
> What would make more sense in my opinion would be for Google to have a partnership with a big Enterprise player (or several in fact) and promote it loudly.

They do: they have a Cisco partnership for Google Cloud.

https://cloud.google.com/cisco/

Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by moderation on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @03:06PM (#16277070)
Cisco's reach beyond the network silo is very small.
Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by AndyNemmity on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @10:56AM (#16274777)
SAP and Google do partner, exactly what you mentioned

https://news.sap.com/flexibility-scalability-speed-sap-googl...

Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by qubex on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @03:42PM (#16277366)
My company uses SAP as an ERP. They’ve been trying to push HANA on us for ages, promoting their cloud service as a manner of lessening the sticker-shock.

When news came through of Google and SAP ‘partnering’, upper management saw the writing on the way and went into full money-is-no-object mode and mandated the firm have a plan to switch away from SAP to alternative solutions (that I am not at liberty to discuss) within twelve months, with and that this plan must involve switching over within no more than ninety days including integration tests. Much preliminary work and change requests have been formulated and even implemented not even knowing if they will ever be needed (i.e. if data-sharing policies change and/or an actual acquisition becomes a real prospect).

Why? The reason is simple: the last thing a company that values its IT and operational profiles wants is to find itself in a situation where it can be data-mined by a publicity-driven juggernaut such as Google. Any expense is suitable to head off that threat.

No major corporation would be willing to shoulder this risk. It's the stuff upper-management's nightmare are made of. And decision-makers in positions of power within SAP and to a lesser extent Google are well aware of this. They won't precipitate a nuclear war with their own clients.

Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by jacksmith21006 on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @08:22PM (#16279043)
What in the world are you talking about? Who is going to data mine?

Google is not going to access corporate cloud customer data no more than IBM, Amazon or Microsoft.

Plus Google already has the data if they want as the executives at all these companies use Google search and other services.

Google could inow what decision makers search in before a sales call but obviously are not going to be doing that.

Is your post suppose to be serious?

Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by qubex on Thursday February 01, 2018 @01:41AM (#16280020)
Dead honest.
Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by AndyNemmity on Friday February 02, 2018 @01:54PM (#16293143)
The data mining concept, it's just inconceivable to me. I wonder how your management drew that conclusion.

I guess the specter of google just draws out assumptions.

Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by qubex on Saturday February 03, 2018 @02:31AM (#16296664)
How could this be inconceivable to you? With all supplier and customer data codified into a standardised structured format, you’d instantly have a ”social network”of all the firms operating at various stages in a value chain, and probably the best model ever of how the whole economy is composed in detail. You’d get the bills of materials, ’recipes’ for just about anything anybody produces; you’d get their profit margins from the controlling modules, you’d be able to estimate the risk banks are exposed to by aggregating the loans they give out to companies and estimating the default risks of each and tot the up.

Forget knowing what executives google... you’d have a real-time fingerprint of the whole economy, ready to be explored and monetized.

This would be... terrifying. Imagine if google discovered that (oh, I don’t know) some firm supplying parts into the Pixel product line had high margins on one of those items, and decided to play hardball to push it down. Suppose Google discovered that one small firm competing with it depend ended on another customer for most of its current revenue, and Google decided to focus its ’competition’ on changing that key client’s idea?

It would be a nightmare.

Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by parasubvert on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @12:07PM (#16275386)
> They have no clue how to sell to enterprises, and because of that they are falling behind AWS and Microsoft in the cloud market.

One could argue the same about AWS for a long time. They’re still lumpy depending on the region. Google has gotten way better in this regard, and are hiring like mad. I wouldn’t presume the above is true any longer.

Microsoft on the other hand can sell, but Azure is flaky.

Google’s main limitation is they don’t have the breadth of offerings of AWS or Azure. That will change with time...

Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by zapita on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @01:48PM (#16276386)
> One could argue the same about AWS for a long time

Yes, and it took them years to get it right. Which means Google is years behind, and doesn't have the benefit of a forgiving early market.

> Google has gotten way better in this regard, and are hiring like mad. I wouldn’t presume the above is true any longer.

Let's hope so for their sake. Personally I'll believe it when I see it. You can hire all the sales reps you want... If your top leadership doesn't understand or respect enterprise buyers, or know how to scale the entreprise distribution "machine", then it won't matter.

I've spoken to several enterprise IT buyers - commanding billions of dollars in aggregate budget - comparing the benefits of AWS and Azure. When I asked them "what about Google Cloud", the room burst out laughing. This happened several times.

Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by parasubvert on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @05:08PM (#16277994)
> Let's hope so for their sake. Personally I'll believe it when I see it. You can hire all the sales reps you want... If your top leadership doesn't understand or respect enterprise buyers, or know how to scale the entreprise distribution "machine", then it won't matter.

Diane Greene knows the enterprise... she has hired an experienced team on the product, sales, and marketing side.

> I've spoken to several enterprise IT buyers - commanding billions of dollars in aggregate budget - comparing the benefits of AWS and Azure. When I asked them "what about Google Cloud", the room burst out laughing. This happened several times.

I too can play the anecdote game - I have senior relationships with at least a few major international banks with aggregate budgets in the billions, and they are betting on GCP. I also know a very large bank betting on AWS, and a couple are straddling the fence with multi-cloud between their on-prem, Azure, and GCP. I see Azure commitments in a big way in insurance.

Of course, it depends what you're trying to do as to which cloud is the better fit. We saved a pile of money moving our AWS workloads to GCP and got better performance for it. I think laughing at Google is a mistake, but clearly they have work to do.

Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by zapita on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @05:28PM (#16278111)
> I have senior relationships with at least a few major international banks with aggregate budgets in the billions, and they are betting on GCP

If several banks are in fact betting on GCP as a primary provider, that would be encouraging news. I will believe it when I see it! Do you expect any of them to be referenceable anytime soon?

By the way: I myself think GCP is great, and I use it for various non-enterprise projects.

It looks like we agree that they have a lot of work to do.

Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by parasubvert on Thursday February 01, 2018 @11:10AM (#16282925)
There are a couple that are public (ie. conference talks and/or tweets) about their use I believe but likely aren’t references... only one I see on GCP’s website is a subsidiary of BNP Paribas. That said, take a look at Google Summit Toronto’s schedule, or a glance on YouTube for google cloud banking for another.
Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by user5994461 on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @05:23PM (#16278094)
They are on-par on all the IaaS offerings. The Amazon has more products is an outdated meme, they have lots of renamed and minor products.

Big companies might not adopt Google Cloud for a variety of reasons. Small and medium companies should have a look, it can be easier to manage and much cheaper.

Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by lima on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @05:33AM (#16272889)
Red Hat cares a lot about getting rid of Docker. They're a major contributor to CRI-O [1], which is very similar to rkt.

[1]: http://cri-o.io/

Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by le-mark on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @09:37AM (#16274118)
I really think there should be an HBO Silicon Valley - Enterprise spinoff :-)

Interesting thought, although these merger/acquisitions play out over quarters and years. Not really conducive to a 12 episode season every year. And seems Silicon Valley has already had a touch of this type of narrative :)

Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by zaphar on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @02:53PM (#16276969)

    rkt on the other hand is a dead project and completely 
    useless to Red Hat.
What support do you have for this statement? The github project is still pretty active. The architecture appears to be far more sane. k8s supports it as well as docker for the runtime piece.

And just anecdotally docker hasn't been the greatest experience for me running in production. So much so that I've considered exploring rkt as a replacement. I would not at all be surprised if RedHat was hedging their bets re: docker with this coreos acquisition.

Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by zapita on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @03:25PM (#16277230)
I'm sure rkt is well engineered (overall CoreOS has good open-source engineering). It just doesn't have much usage, and whatever advantages it has, evidently it wasn't enough to convince a meaningful number of Docker users to switch. I use Docker intensively and, like you, I've had my share of frustrating issues with it over the years. But at the end of the day, the bugs get fixed reasonably quickly, and Docker just gets the job done. Their code has so much mileage at this point, I just don't see the point in starting over with a competitor. Evidently I'm not the only one who feels that way.
Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by zaphar on Thursday February 01, 2018 @12:42AM (#16279841)
I don't know. I wouldn't say my experience has been that the bugs get fixed reasonably quickly. It's more like they make several attempts to fix the bugs reasonably quickly and then eventually figure it out.

I'm not sure their code has enough mileage to paper over their quality issues. At this point the only reason I'm not switching over is that I've written enough shims and code to paper over dockers problems that I have it somewhat stable and the switch cost is just barely high enough to make sticking with it the right choice for now. But it won't take too many more problems to make me reevaluate that decision.

Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by zapita on Sunday February 04, 2018 @04:02AM (#16301989)
It's surprising that our experiences were so different. Are you using CE or EE? And if it's CE, is it the upstream-supplied package or the distro-supplied one? In my experience those things can make a big difference.
Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by zaphar on Wednesday February 07, 2018 @10:21AM (#16324959)
It's the distro supplied CE package.
Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by jbronn on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @03:39PM (#16277335)
I think it’s because RedHat has thrown its weight behind CRI-O instead of rkt:

https://www.redhat.com/en/blog/introducing-cri-o-10

Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by r0fls on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @03:03AM (#16272281)
I think Google being able to buy Oracle is a bit of a stretch at this point. Oracle is 1/4 the market cap of Google. So, it seems unlikely they would have the capital available.
Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by zapita on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @03:21AM (#16272354)
You are right. I was extrapolating future scenarios where Oracle or SAP trip up in their race to the Cloud, causing a major drop in their stock. Honestly it's a pretty realistic scenario, it's not a secret that the Dell, HPE, SAP and Oracles of the world have serious challenges ahead of them. One of them is bound to hit an attractive price, and for a bold and deep-pocketed suitor to act on it. The question is when?
Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by manishjhawar on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @04:37AM (#16272674)
And Who?
Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by timlyo on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @06:14AM (#16273033)
>rkt on the other hand is a dead project

Why is this? I've only recently started looking at it.

Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by nailer on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @10:41AM (#16274663)
> Red Hat does not give a damn about rkt. They care about Kubernetes, specifically establishing and consolidating a dominant position in upstream kubernetes development.

Yep. Even technical people are used to referring to Linux container tech as 'Docker' so when you ask them what technology they use, they'll mention Kubernetes.

Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by AndyNemmity on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @10:55AM (#16274775)
Google already partners with SAP to bring larger enterprise customers to their cloud.
Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by tripzilch on Tuesday February 06, 2018 @07:08AM (#16315732)
Google should buy Oracle, fire all the employees[0] except Larry Ellison and have him mow their lawns.

[0] or reassign to better projects

Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by acoard on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @02:26PM (#16276738)
>Given their self-inflicted XHR debacle that dethroned Office,

Do you mean how Google used XHR (ajax) for Google Docs to dethrone Microsoft Office? Or something else I'm missing?

Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by smoyer on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @06:11AM (#16273023)
This sounds pretty logical ... the other big player is probably Oracle who will end up purchasing Pivotal, Rackspace, ...
Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by thedevopsguy on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @01:10PM (#16276007)
Hadn't thought of it from this angle. Docker's only chance of survival is to have a cross platform container. Something that works on Windows and Linux.

Perhaps Docker's only play is to fold into Microsoft to achieve a cross platform solution. Microsoft does have Brendan Burns now.

Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by zapita on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @02:05PM (#16276538)
Didn't Docker announce Windows support years ago?
Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by abakker on Wednesday January 31, 2018 @04:56PM (#16277903)
Re:Red Hat to Acquire CoreOS by thedevopsguy on Thursday February 01, 2018 @06:17AM (#16281027)
My comment wasn't too clear. I'm not talking about just running docker cli on Windows or using windows 10 containers. Am yet to see a coherent story on how to write say a Java application containerize it, deploy it on Windows and Linux without having dealing with differences in each OS container solution.

If there is, I'd like to learn about it.