I wouldn’t be surprised if a lot of, or all of the “legit” ICO’s are similarly removed from play.
Just because you ICO'd before today doesn't mean you are safe at all, in fact I'd argue the opposite-you've opened up yourself to unknown regulatory liabilities.
And we should be grateful. Prejudicial judgements banning entire categories of economic collaboration are destructive to humanity.
Mark Vilardo ended up calling me, the same guy I read about here: https://hackernoon.com/the-sec-called-about-our-ico-i-answer...
He was super friendly but basically left no window open for a legal ICO in the US outside of somehow ensuring that your token will never go up or down in price.
EDIT: No option for a legal ICO... UNLESS you register with the SEC as a security, which is very expensive and subjects you to strict regulations.
This is at odds with Andrew Chapin's description of his call with Vilardo, where he understood him to be saying:
> "the SEC recognizes that not all ICO events or token issuances are securities."[1]
It seems like the SEC can't reasonably hold both positions, unless one means literally the only legal ICOs guarantee no change in token value.
Having said that, it does seem like the more restricted interpretation is more in line with the Howey test.
[1] https://hackernoon.com/the-sec-called-about-our-ico-i-answer...
It's a legal minefield and unfortunately those brave enough to cross it and slip through will get a lot of money and those that try and get caught will get stiff penalties. It really would help to get more clarity in the SEC's public comments.
The SEC will take the position that the vast majority of ICOs were unregistered offering of securities. Just because they don't act today, doesn't mean they're not actively investigating. And they will go after the ICO offerers.
Some people are attempting to con investors into believing they are, but they do not represent equity, or legal rights of any kind.
You get into trouble if you market your ICO as a security, or promise capital gains. Issuing tokens by itself is not subject to SEC scrutiny.
It's been well known since early-December when the SEC shut down the Munchee ICO that ICOs that function as securities will not be allowed. There are many ICOs that are still fine.
> "The ICO is an illegal offering of securities because there is no registration filed or in effect with the SEC, nor is there an applicable exemption from registration," the complaint said.
The complaint was filed by the SEC in Dallas and the court ordered an emergency asset freeze of the company and it's two co-founders.
If you're considering an ICO, please attempt to understand your legal obligations and risks. The window of ICO free for alls looks like it's ending.