I suspect that he believes that the perpetual funding stream of ever-better patents is needed to fund the research for ever-better codecs (which, as you say, is disputable but not unreasonable). I also suspect that he would argue that some of the problems of the protection racket amounts to a necessary evil (a protection racket does give you a viable means to combat submarine patents). However, the AV1/HEVC situation undermines these arguments, and this is someone who realizes the gravy train is running out of rails and is desperate to keep it from derailing instead of bailing while he still can.
And doesn't Firefox have some special deal with Cisco to use their x264 decoder on the web?
HEVC is currently literally impossible to license. One of the pools hasn't decided on pricing yet. You basically have to set aside some cash and hope it's enough to back-pay once they announce the pricing. But even with the existing ones, you have to pay for encoders, decoders, and videos encoded in it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_Efficiency_Video_Coding#P...
Besides, for a company like Netflix or Youtube, shaving 5% off the file size without a drop in quality can literally mean millions of dollars saved per year.
If you consider compression from an information theory point of view, for any given measure of "quality" there is theoretically a limit to compression. It's not clear where the limit is, or how close we are to it, but because it does exist stagnation is inevitable eventually.
As it gets harder to make gains it will become less of a business proposition and more of a research/academic thing.
Fuck the Fraunhofer Institute.
There have been a lot of mistakes in the growth of the internet, but mpeg... Trying to own an entire space isn’t about making the world a better place. It’s about being in control. Me me me.
Given how big video is now, and the interplay between available bandwidth and video quality, one wonders if certain bumps in the road would have been smoothed out if Netflix or YouTube had ramped up a few years earlier.
I'm convinced many big players wanted people to think mp3 was going away to push newer, patent encumbered formats.
Usually I'd expect someone in this position to toe the party line pretty hard, but he actually sounds reasonably level-headed to me. He even cautions the reader not to get their hopes up that anything will improve.
Or is this guy just an incredibly skilled troll with 30 years of experience in pulling the wool over people's eyes? I don't think so, though. He really seems to think that imposing massive amounts of friction on a system somehow makes it work better.
Wow. Just wow.
I mean, I'm not unsympathetic to the argument that patents can promote advancements by funneling money to inventors, however weak it starts sounding when you look at actual events in certain spheres. But the claim seems to be that nobody is going to bother to research improvements in an interesting, impactful technical area because they'll no longer be able to (1) invent something, (2) hire an army of lawyers, then (3) profit. Er, okay. Let the people who will only work with that sort of path go do their ICOs instead.