Re:The Follower Factory
by dredmorbius on Saturday January 27, 2018 @09:26PM
(#16249396)
That's where various fingerprints (the sort of thing, incidentally, AI/ML should be pretty good at sorting out) should come in to play.
Spammers, ultimately, act like spammers, and bots like bots. Unlike legitimate accounts, which typically either a) follow a small number of related accounts or b) are fairly-well-known high-profile accounts (and yes, pseudonymous accounts may be high-profile), bots either need to act within specific networks or be very indiscriminate in whom they follow / link with. And they're tremendously active.
Whilst Google+ is not Facebook, Stone Temple Consulting ran an analysis of 500,000 profiles in 2015 to see what posting activity looked like.[1] I'm fairly familiar with the methods used as I'd pioneered most of them on a smaller, 50k sample.
Looking at public posts only (not private posts, and not comments), there are roughly 53,000 G+ users posting 100+ times monthly, and 106,000 posting 50+ times monthly.
From an independent analysis, I've estimated that Facebook traffic is, very roughly, 10x greater than G+ (as of August, 2015). So you might bump these values up by an order of magnitude to get Facebook-level scales of operation. Twitter is actually far closer to G+ in scale.[2]
That is, the search space for bots is roughly 500k - 1m accounts of major active players. And it should be possible, even with only computer-assisted human intervention, to make a pretty good cut through that space.
Spammers, ultimately, act like spammers, and bots like bots. Unlike legitimate accounts, which typically either a) follow a small number of related accounts or b) are fairly-well-known high-profile accounts (and yes, pseudonymous accounts may be high-profile), bots either need to act within specific networks or be very indiscriminate in whom they follow / link with. And they're tremendously active.
Whilst Google+ is not Facebook, Stone Temple Consulting ran an analysis of 500,000 profiles in 2015 to see what posting activity looked like.[1] I'm fairly familiar with the methods used as I'd pioneered most of them on a smaller, 50k sample.
Looking at public posts only (not private posts, and not comments), there are roughly 53,000 G+ users posting 100+ times monthly, and 106,000 posting 50+ times monthly.
From an independent analysis, I've estimated that Facebook traffic is, very roughly, 10x greater than G+ (as of August, 2015). So you might bump these values up by an order of magnitude to get Facebook-level scales of operation. Twitter is actually far closer to G+ in scale.[2]
That is, the search space for bots is roughly 500k - 1m accounts of major active players. And it should be possible, even with only computer-assisted human intervention, to make a pretty good cut through that space.
So the problem is not all that intractable.
________________________________
Notes:
1. https://www.stonetemple.com/real-numbers-for-the-activity-on... STC's Eric Enge credits me on that page.
2. https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/3hp41w/trackin...