News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Buzz Kill by m0nty on Sunday August 22, 2010 @10:21AM (#1624635)
I've never understood the appeal of Twitter and I think it would help if more "social media people" (and web app developers) could try to understand why. They are obscure little techie tools that a huge percentage of the population will never use. When Leo says "I was shouting into a vast echo chamber" what he really should say is "I was shouting into a miniscule echo chamber". And nobody was really listening because it's not really a conversation, it's all about self-promotion and that tends to be a very one-sided activity.

Buzz and Wave will never take off with the people I work with, or my friends, because we're all a bit old-fashioned and I doubt any one of us would sooner "tweet" a message than phone someone up and talk to them directly. Sure, I realise it's a one-to-many operation (unlike a phone-call) but honestly, what do I have that's worth actually broadcasting?

Re:Buzz Kill by muhfuhkuh on Sunday August 22, 2010 @02:02PM (#1624960)
"what do I have that's worth actually broadcasting?"

It's an ego-driven medium. All of it: YouTube (when actually done for its intended purpose and not flagrant copyright flouting); facebook/myspace, foursquare, getglue. It's all about what you're doing and more recently _where_ you are when you're doing it. It's about the inherent need for self-fulfillment.

Let's say you have great taste in music. Just by someone noticing your daily playlist, you have an admirer. That admirer might want to know more about you based on that superficial quality, and follow you on your social update tool of choice. It's a tool of communication, much like a phone (actually more like a partyline, but I digress).

When it boils down to it, people need people, and as social creatures, we find every convenient avenue of acquiring and managing our social sphere as we can without expending too much energy. If we didn't care about any of that, hell, we wouldn't ever even comment in HN, right m0nty?

Re:Buzz Kill by m0nty on Sunday August 22, 2010 @05:33PM (#1625319)
"we wouldn't ever even comment in HN, right m0nty?"

I guessed someone would try to make that point :) You'll notice I rarely do comment here, and I don't on reddit, youtube, Digg, etc. At least here, there is something approaching a conversation. But, Golden Rule: if I have nothing to say, I don't.

Re:Buzz Kill by heinel on Monday August 23, 2010 @09:55AM (#1626754)
But you do acknowledge that you are a user in those networks, correct? You check those sites, and by reading (even without active commenting) you are a participant. Some people project themselves, others observe, that was how social interactions had always been.
Re:Buzz Kill by m0nty on Monday August 23, 2010 @01:15PM (#1627328)
> You check those sites

My apologies if I was unclear: I don't check those sites. Also, this insight you have that people are basically social animals, that's not exactly a revelation. But I would contend, along with OP, that our natural sociability is not best served by social networking.

Re:Buzz Kill by delackner on Sunday August 22, 2010 @11:15PM (#1625751)
Certainly the ego-driven component you describe is there, but as with group events, there is a balanced version, and then there are the networking whores that don't understand the difference between having a natural connection with someone and "hi my name is X, here's my card, let's have lunch!"

You don't have to post navel-gazing facebook status updates. It is also a very elegant way to share family and friend group photos and plan events.

Do you even remember how hard it was to plan events with Evite? That was incredibly horrible, and yet people were thrilled because it was better than nothing.

Re:Buzz Kill by Tichy on Monday August 23, 2010 @05:24AM (#1626251)
I often get good information on Twitter, for example about events happening in my city. I am thankful that some people share the information. Ego driven, I don't know - obviously there are "egos" behind the keyboard, but sharing can be a win for everyone.

Maybe it is just hard to grasp for people who don't understand the concept of "pay forward"?

Re:Buzz Kill by m0nty on Monday August 23, 2010 @01:18PM (#1627337)
> Maybe it is just hard to grasp for people who don't understand the concept of "pay forward"?

So ... so I'm a bad person if I don't use Twitter? Seriously?

Re:Buzz Kill by Tichy on Monday August 23, 2010 @01:20PM (#1627339)
No, but maybe for not tolerating people who do use it.
Re:Buzz Kill by Hagelin on Sunday August 22, 2010 @01:46PM (#1624935)
Isn’t Facebook pretty much the same thing, though? I’d say it’s taken off with quite a few people?
Re:Buzz Kill by joezydeco on Sunday August 22, 2010 @09:56PM (#1625638)
And quite a few people, one generation from now, will look back and go "I wasted thousands of hours on that?"

What will we have to show for Facebook other than a bunch of divorces and bad memories from resurfaced high school acquaintances? I guess another guilt-ridden billionaire charity fund but not much more.

Re:Buzz Kill by Tichy on Sunday August 22, 2010 @01:32PM (#1624910)
In what way would it help to understand why?
Re:Buzz Kill by m0nty on Sunday August 22, 2010 @05:35PM (#1625325)
Because you'd actually end up writing web apps with real value rather than just the next killer "social media app"?
Re:Buzz Kill by Tichy on Sunday August 22, 2010 @07:42PM (#1625496)
What if Twitter actually has value even though you don't understand it?
Re:Buzz Kill by marknutter on Sunday August 22, 2010 @11:27PM (#1625762)
> but honestly, what do I have that's worth actually broadcasting?

Um.. how about your Hacker News comments?

Re:Buzz Kill by elblanco on Monday August 23, 2010 @12:25AM (#1625846)
Unfortunately, most of the HN comments < 140 characters are so content free as to basically violate the site's guidelines.

(and yes, the above would fit into a tweet, but it would be so devoid of context as to be absolutely meaningless to people who weren't already reading this same thread)