News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by sevensor on Thursday January 25, 2018 @09:24AM (#16230904)
> being poor is not a good/bad thing

This is a silly line of reasoning. As more people grow wealthy, we find more ways to systematically mistreat those who have not. It's not just that the poor started poor and stayed that way, it's that the rest of us find ways to make things even harder for them as our comparative wealth grows. Being poor is most definitely a bad thing.

Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by mrweasel on Thursday January 25, 2018 @09:38AM (#16230992)
While I agree that all other things being equal, it's certainly better to not be poor, the reasoning seems pretty clever. It changes to focus, stopping us from looking for events or circumstances that cause a person to be poor and instead tries to identify what it is we as a society can do or provide a person with allowing that person start building wealth.
Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by randomdata on Thursday January 25, 2018 @09:33AM (#16230963)
The fact remains that everyone starts with nothing. The parent questions why some are able to flourish, while others continue with nothing indefinitely.
Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by SauciestGNU on Thursday January 25, 2018 @09:49AM (#16231059)
People start with extremely unequal circumstances. Social mobility is low and those born with wealth will keep it and those born without are unlikely to ever attain it. This platonic ideal where everyone starts on equal footing and some people are just better than others at accumulating wealth is absurd.
Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by thebigspacefuck on Thursday January 25, 2018 @11:01AM (#16231746)
It would be interesting to see a real life Trading Places and see how well the unwealthy do given a wealthy lifestyle. Or can we just look at lottery winners?
Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by tabeth on Thursday January 25, 2018 @09:38AM (#16230993)
The "fact" that everyone starts with nothing is obviously false. Even ignoring opportunity, the fetal health is highly dependent on the environment.
Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by moduspol on Thursday January 25, 2018 @10:28AM (#16231396)
I think the point is being missed here. In an inherent sense, humans start with nothing.

We (as a society) have hospitals available which greatly decrease infant mortality. We have widely available nutrition that keeps people from starving. These are steps that we, as a society, have taken to improve upon the default state (having nothing) of humans--including fetal health. Perhaps rather than focusing on how to make people in poverty more comfortable, we should focus on how to get them out of poverty.

That's not the same as claiming all people start on a level playing field.

Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by tabeth on Thursday January 25, 2018 @10:30AM (#16231414)
In no sense do people start off with nothing. People start off with the abilities or lack thereof possessed at birth. Compare a child with fetal alcohol syndrome with one without it. Do both start off with nothing? No. Clearly one has something the other does not.

Why do people insist on believing nonsense?

Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by moduspol on Thursday January 25, 2018 @10:49AM (#16231617)
Of course individuals have different abilities. You're missing the point.

The claim is societal. We (as humans) started out with nothing. Over thousands of years, we built religions, governments, businesses, laws, science, and everything else, which ultimately resulted in a lot of us having a lot better quality of life. But our default state (as humans) is to have nothing. That some people are still in poverty shouldn't be seen like a disease to be treated--it should be seen as a condition all humans effectively default to. They just haven't benefited from all the systems and processes we've built that the rest of us have, and we should figure out how to get them to (or modify our systems so they do).

Again: This is in no way claiming each person starts on a level playing field.

Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by tabeth on Thursday January 25, 2018 @10:51AM (#16231643)
Yeah, no. How can you claim we started off with nothing yet say over thousands of years we built things? Clearly we started off with something. You should be more precise in your language.

If you change "nothing", with "no possessions, talents, abilities, or skills", which is the same thing, then you'll see why what you're saying is illogical.

Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by moduspol on Thursday January 25, 2018 @11:06AM (#16231788)
> Yeah, no. How can you claim we started off with nothing yet say over thousands of years we built things?

I'm not sure how to respond to this. Have you read a history book? At one point humans were in caves, with effectively no possessions and terrible lives. That was poverty, and it affected everyone. Whether or not one cave man was born smarter than the other is irrelevant.

Over time, we developed all of these systems that made life better for the vast majority of us, yet some of us still live in poverty, because the default human state is to have nothing. That in no way implies a level playing field among two different people born today.

> If you change "nothing", with "no possessions, talents, abilities, or skills", which is the same thing, then you'll see why what you're saying is illogical.

You're still missing the point. I don't know how I can rephrase this in a way that won't be intentionally misinterpreted.

Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by randomdata on Thursday January 25, 2018 @10:37AM (#16231493)
This discussion is specially about wealth. Fetal alcohol syndrome is not usually added as a liability on a balance sheet, even if it is liability to everyday living. Everyone starts with a balance of $0.

> Why do people insist on believing nonsense?

Why are people trying to twist this discussion into things it never was?

Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by tabeth on Thursday January 25, 2018 @10:40AM (#16231516)
Nothing is being twisted. If what you mean is that two babies have the same amount of money in their bank accounts, then that's what you should say. Of course, if one said that they would be ignored as that much is obvious.

What you should not say is that "they both start off with nothing". Wealth is more than money. In fact, wealth literally just means an abundance of possessions; prosperity. What dictionary are you using that says wealth is only measured by dollars in a bank account?

By the way, the article specifically mentions health, so...

Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by randomdata on Thursday January 25, 2018 @10:45AM (#16231584)
> If what you mean is that two babies have the same amount of money in their bank accounts, then that's what you should say.

But wealth isn't an amount in a bank account? Given the earlier context of this thread, I felt my comment should have been clear enough, but granted textual communication can be difficult (especially for emotional topics where many have their response composed well in advance) and clearly I failed. I tried to clarify it on several other occasions before you commented, so any errors in conveying my original message should have been resolved before you posted yours, no?

> Wealth is more than money

Money being only a tool of measurement, I think that is a given. But that is like saying that the weather is more than temperature. Sure, but what are we supposed to take from that?

Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by randomdata on Thursday January 25, 2018 @10:10AM (#16231239)
Given that we're talking about wealth – something that you measure on a balance sheet – is fetal health something that should be included? My experience with accounting says no, but I'm not a professional accountant. Perhaps you have misunderstood this discussion?
Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by tabeth on Thursday January 25, 2018 @10:18AM (#16231316)
If you don't think the health of the fetus, and subsequently the child and adult has anything to do with poverty then I dunno what I tell ya.
Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by randomdata on Thursday January 25, 2018 @10:21AM (#16231331)
While I understand how the health of the fetus relates to poverty, I fail to see how that has anything to do with this particular discussion? We are talking about how everyone starts with nothing. The balance sheet of all brand new people to world always starts empty.
Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by tabeth on Thursday January 25, 2018 @10:23AM (#16231343)
You're missing the point. Saying everyone starts off with a blank slate is like saying everyone born starts off alive. It's a useless statement. The point is that the quality of life upon birth is different. Said qualities result in the discrepancies you see today.

EDIT:

Furthermore, originally you stated:

> The fact remains that everyone starts with nothing

It's already been illustrated this is false. If you believe quality of life at birth is different, then by definition, everyone does not start off with nothing, or zero. People start off with the qualities possessed at birth.

Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by randomdata on Thursday January 25, 2018 @10:26AM (#16231381)
> You're missing the point.

Technically, I made the point. I'm not sure how I can miss my own point? Granted, I may have poorly phrased it leading to others missing the point, which is my bad, but if you're not going to try and let me clarify, I'm not sure what we're doing here?

> The point is that the quality of life upon birth is different.

Sure. I cannot disagree with that, but it's miles away from this conversation.

> It's already been illustrated this is false.

I'm afraid I still don't see it. That point was made in reference to earlier discussion specifically about wealth (again, something you measure on a balance sheet, not factors like fetal health). Their parents might have wealth that can be transferred to the child, but that is not the same as starting with wealth.

Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by grasshopperpurp on Thursday January 25, 2018 @09:37AM (#16230985)
>The fact remains that everyone starts with nothing.

This is clearly wrong.

Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by randomdata on Thursday January 25, 2018 @10:02AM (#16231164)
I struggle to see what is inherently bestowed upon a new born child beyond life itself? The child may eventually be given things, but that's not the same thing as what we are talking about. Some examples of how it is clearly wrong would be useful, because there is nothing clear about it to me.
Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by tangent128 on Thursday January 25, 2018 @10:24AM (#16231363)
If the question is "why some are able to flourish, while others continue with nothing indefinitely", then the fact that some children are given $millions in liquid assets where others are lucky to be given food and clothing would certainly seen germane.
Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by randomdata on Thursday January 25, 2018 @10:35AM (#16231472)
But that is outside what someone starts with. When a child is born, those millions will be originally held in the same of someone else (perhaps the parents, grandparents, whoever). It may be transferred to the child, but it remains that the child started with nothing.

On the question of why some flourish and others do not, I think you're just echoing the point that has persisted through this entire thread.

Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by grasshopperpurp on Thursday January 25, 2018 @11:00AM (#16231740)
>The fact remains that everyone starts with nothing. The parent questions why some are able to flourish, while others continue with nothing indefinitely.

This is your entire statement. If you're wondering why some are able to flourish while others aren't, getting hung up on the technicalities of a pointless statement is a poor start. We know that people are born under various circumstances ranging from remarkably poor to exceptionally rich, and we know that's the best indicator of future wealth. Yes, they have to inherit the money at some point, but they grow up experiencing the benefits (and drawbacks) of that wealth - whether or not it's in their names.

Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by indemnity on Thursday January 25, 2018 @12:58PM (#16232908)
Privilege is invisible to you? Must be nice.

Health of mother - Advantage. Mother being able to take care of child in the early years - Advantage. Dad present - Advantage. Encouraging, safe home environment - Advantage. Parents that expect and encourage excellence (sports, academic) - Advantage. Never going hungry - Advantage. Going to schools with resources and good teachers - Advantage. Going to good college - Advantage. Parents connections (business and academic) - Advantage.

These advantages compound.

There will be outliers with none or only some of this who still happen to make it. They are not common, and not proof that the system works as intended.

Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by zentiggr on Thursday January 25, 2018 @09:46AM (#16231038)
Unless you are asserting that estate taxes are 100% for everyone and no one is allowed any hint of nepotism or gifting, you are wrong. How do the 1% stay the 1% across generations?
Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by beambot on Thursday January 25, 2018 @09:38AM (#16230991)
> The fact remains that everyone starts with nothing.

Not even close to true... Simply look at socioeconomic status across generations.

Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by randomdata on Thursday January 25, 2018 @10:14AM (#16231279)
The transfer of wealth through generations is wealth that is still held in family name until the time that it is given to the child. The child still starts with none. Ownership is not automatic in our society. It has to be transferred.
Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by jokermatt999 on Thursday January 25, 2018 @12:13PM (#16232473)
Ok, fine. They still have to inherit that money. But as they grow up, the rich baby will have access to better nutrition, better education, a less stressful environment, etc compared to the poor baby. That's without considering fetal health/nutrition. There are many known factors that can affect a child's health, growth, and intelligence, and therefore success.

I don't think the distinction of "babies have $0" is relevant when considering all the other potential advantages. What are you getting at with that claim? I don't think it's particularly clear, judging by the other replies.

Re:The U.S. Can No Longer Hide from Its Deep Poverty Problem by indemnity on Thursday January 25, 2018 @01:01PM (#16232936)
He suffers from the affliction, that, having mastered programming, all other domains of human endeavour must be as reducible to simple logical constructs, and the world just needs him, to come and show how simple it really is.

It’s crazy how many think they have a monopoly on intelligence by virtue of being able to tell the machine what to do.

A logical statement in isolation is seen as sufficient to win arguments (like “babies have no money at birth”).

Wow, thanks Socrates, now I see the light. The scales have fallen from my eyes.