I like the dialer. I wish you could cut-n-paste the phone number from the missed calls window, though. But perhaps I will add that feature tonight!
Other than the gmail app (which I think is pretty decent), decent mail apps are still a wide open opportunity (IMHO) for Android developers.
The thing that nails Sense for me is that the calendar app requires you to spin digits around (11:01, 11:02, 11:03, ... for your 11:45 appointment), whereas the stock Android app lets you just type them in or press a button. Not as OMG AWESOME, but much easier to actually use.
Anyway, Sense only lasted a few days on my phone, so I am not experienced. I just know that the stock AOSP lock screen, dialer, calendar, and browser all work better.
They just work better despite that you admit you don't have much experience with Sense?
I can understand not liking the spinning digits thing if you're a major calendar user, but I'm not so it doesn't really bother me. Seems like user preference on most of those things, not anything that makes one definitively better than the other. My phone is fast and responsive, so I don't really have any impetus to go around unlocking stuff when I don't need to (yet).
(Also, the default build on my EVO ate battery like crazy, the number one complaint by reviewers. Install CM, the battery lasts all day, even with heavy Kindle and Browser use.)
It's a shame that "normal users" don't get to decide whether or not they want Sense.