News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:BMW's Apple CarPlay annual fee is next-level gouging by skywhopper on Saturday January 20, 2018 @07:19PM (#16196204)
It's so bizarre. There's no reasonable fiscal reason for BMW to require this. The only reason to implement something like this would be just to establish the precedent of paying a subscription to the carmaker so they can add on easy-to-pay-for additional features and one-time expenses later. Micropayments and loot boxes for your car.
Re:BMW's Apple CarPlay annual fee is next-level gouging by jeffwilcox on Saturday January 20, 2018 @10:40PM (#16196759)
BMW already has a major precedent here... after 3 years of owning one today, you pay:

$100/year for real-time advanced traffic in the nav system $100/year for BMW Connected (send addresses and info to your car, unlock, locate etc. from your phone)

Sadly this feels like the latest attempt to increase subscription service revenue to help justify those network access fees and monetize in the serviceworld. :/

Re:BMW's Apple CarPlay annual fee is next-level gouging by huhtenberg on Sunday January 21, 2018 @10:49AM (#16198467)
This has a clear purpose though - it exists to push people to change to a new BMW every 3 years. This is an open secret and salespeople like bringing it up.
Re:BMW's Apple CarPlay annual fee is next-level gouging by netsharc on Saturday January 20, 2018 @08:03PM (#16196329)
Porsche already has an idea of temporarily more horsepower for money, not even permanently.
Re:BMW's Apple CarPlay annual fee is next-level gouging by Jeremy1026 on Saturday January 20, 2018 @09:44PM (#16196611)
And Tesla lets you access the rest of your battery pack by paying more.
Re:BMW's Apple CarPlay annual fee is next-level gouging by Baeocystin on Saturday January 20, 2018 @10:01PM (#16196668)
To be fair, that that is even possible is because they installed better, larger battery packs than were initially promised in the first place. Even if the buyer never pays for the 'extra' miles, they still get the benefit of improved responsiveness and less wear and tear on the cells that the larger pack brings.
Re:BMW's Apple CarPlay annual fee is next-level gouging by nolok on Sunday January 21, 2018 @04:36AM (#16197439)
What a weird conter argument. Can be used for porsche too !

> To be fair, that that is even possible is because they installed better, larger engine than were initially promised in the first place.

Re:BMW's Apple CarPlay annual fee is next-level gouging by Baeocystin on Sunday January 21, 2018 @06:07AM (#16197622)
Are you telling me you wouldn't be happy to get a better engine, for the same price, than what you originally agreed to pay for?

Because to complete the analogy, the new engine would have to have better acceleration and superior durability than what you thought you were going to get, even if you never once paid for any additional performance unlocks.

Re:BMW's Apple CarPlay annual fee is next-level gouging by SturgeonsLaw on Sunday January 21, 2018 @06:46AM (#16197725)
But is that really what it is, or is it a case of not getting all of the engine that you did pay for?
Re:BMW's Apple CarPlay annual fee is next-level gouging by ssheth on Sunday January 21, 2018 @09:16AM (#16198110)
They are delivering a superior battery with more capacity and performance than what you actually ordered. The only difference is that they figure to make up the difference when eventually the car is sold back to tesla and then they can "activate" the extra part of the battery of the owner didn't already pay for the extra upgrade somewhere along the way and then resell the car for much more than what they paid since the car is now a couple models better.
Re:BMW's Apple CarPlay annual fee is next-level gouging by davrosthedalek on Sunday January 21, 2018 @09:47AM (#16198215)
But maybe I didn't want to the bigger battery in my car? Maybe I would have preferred a lighter car? Or I have some other reason I wanted specifically the small battery? Do I have the option to not have the optional-upgrade-enabled battery? Do I have the option to give the car back because it's not what I ordered?
Re:BMW's Apple CarPlay annual fee is next-level gouging by davrosthedalek on Sunday January 21, 2018 @09:49AM (#16198222)
It also means that it is heavier than it needed to be to have the bought and paid for attributes. So I use more gas. This is wasteful.
Re:BMW's Apple CarPlay annual fee is next-level gouging by prepend on Sunday January 21, 2018 @10:11AM (#16198314)
I wouldn’t be happy if I had to pay more to use it.

Logically, bigger engine means higher costs. Maybe indirect costs.

Re:BMW's Apple CarPlay annual fee is next-level gouging by icebraining on Sunday January 21, 2018 @11:02AM (#16198517)
The buyers also get more weight to pull around.
Re:BMW's Apple CarPlay annual fee is next-level gouging by celim307 on Saturday January 20, 2018 @08:12PM (#16196351)
Link? That's disgusting
Re:BMW's Apple CarPlay annual fee is next-level gouging by netsharc on Sunday January 21, 2018 @01:36PM (#16199293)
I can only find one German article about it, maybe they were just throwing ideas to see how the public would react: http://winfuture.de/news,100802.html

Ah I found the interview:

https://newsroom.porsche.com/en/company/porsche-digitalizati...

> Which solutions are relevant for a brand like Porsche?

> We will increasingly offer functions “on demand”. That means that the costumer can buy new functions at any time if needed – including long after buying the car and, where applicable, only temporarily. Be it as a one-off for a fee, as a flat rate or as a subscription.

> Which functions do you offer on demand?

> For example, it would be possible to combine modules from the area of autonomous driving individually. Imagine that you could use a software update to download a few more PS over-the-air at short notice if you want to head to the racetrack on the weekend – or dynamic headlights if you are headed for a long night drive.

Re:BMW's Apple CarPlay annual fee is next-level gouging by sk5t on Saturday January 20, 2018 @11:16PM (#16196825)
To what specifically do you refer?
Re:BMW's Apple CarPlay annual fee is next-level gouging by netsharc on Sunday January 21, 2018 @01:38PM (#16199301)
I read it on German news, and found the original quote, in a what looks like an internal interview of Lutz Meschke, Vice President of the Executive Board and Member of the Executive Board, Finance and IT. From their own website:

https://newsroom.porsche.com/en/company/porsche-digitalizati...

> Which solutions are relevant for a brand like Porsche?

> We will increasingly offer functions “on demand”. That means that the costumer can buy new functions at any time if needed – including long after buying the car and, where applicable, only temporarily. Be it as a one-off for a fee, as a flat rate or as a subscription.

> Which functions do you offer on demand?

> For example, it would be possible to combine modules from the area of autonomous driving individually. Imagine that you could use a software update to download a few more PS over-the-air at short notice if you want to head to the racetrack on the weekend – or dynamic headlights if you are headed for a long night drive.

Re:BMW's Apple CarPlay annual fee is next-level gouging by acdha on Saturday January 20, 2018 @08:24PM (#16196386)
I could buy something for ongoing software and security support but this is steep for something designed to reduce the amount of work they have to do in that regard.
Re:BMW's Apple CarPlay annual fee is next-level gouging by merb on Sunday January 21, 2018 @06:36AM (#16197696)
well you know... german car manufcaturers are just ignorant and greedy. they also use big subsidizes for "EV"s/car batteries which they never really delivered. the german governement is so deeply involved with the manufcaturers that nothing really would change anything. they basically have their marionettes to do whatever they want. I mean just look at VW. no high level executive got any charges up until now. the latest news were around november 2017 were the "searched" for stuff, but I doubt that they will ever put anybody to jail in germany. i mean changes are high that inside the "diesel-gate", some local german governement was directly involved. I mean "Niedersachsen" (the county) actually helds at least 20% of the Volkswagen AG. so they probably knew that something is fishy. I mean it was already pretty fishy that cars would've been emission checked with only software instead of the working old methods.