Re:C as an intermediate language (2012)
by MaxBarraclough on Saturday January 20, 2018 @05:02AM
(#16192819)
Vala seems to be doing ok targeting C. I'd hardly say it's just for toys.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:C as an intermediate language (2012)
by mirekrusin on Saturday January 20, 2018 @12:04PM
(#16194092)
Nim does it as well, but in case of Vala it's a bit different case as it emits glib based code with GObject and friends - basically whole OO system with containers, event loop and what not. The idea of Vala is that if you're using glib then using Vala will generate glib code as if you'd write it by hand, but much easier. The rationale is much stronger to emit C as you can mix it with existing code etc.
There certainly is a grey area. For example, there are esoteric architectures which LLVM does not support but a C compiler exists. Emitting C is probably easier than developing a few LLVM backends.
Still, my simple opinion is: If you are serious, use LLVM. It is not that much harder than outputting C and has clear advantages like debug information.
Re:C as an intermediate language (2012)
by MaxBarraclough on Saturday January 20, 2018 @10:21AM
(#16193626)
As I mention below, Vala debugging isn't the catastrophe you think: https://wiki.gnome.org/Projects/Vala/Tutorial#Debugging
I believe it's based on #pragmas that tell the C compiler (and/or GDB, presumably) which line of which file to blame.
Serious work has been done in Vala. It's not fair to dismiss the language as a quaint toy.
Preprocessor directives are not powerful enough [0], imho.
Re:C as an intermediate language (2012)
by MaxBarraclough on Sunday January 21, 2018 @02:56PM
(#16199638)
That isn't an attribute of using C as an IR, it's an attribute of optimising compilers.
The solution is to disable optimisation for debug builds, not to avoid C.
From the gnome.org page:
> The -g command line option tells the Vala compiler to include Vala source code line information in the compiled binary
Re:C as an intermediate language (2012)
by humanrebar on Saturday January 20, 2018 @07:21AM
(#16193108)
How does Vala handle debugging info and compiler diagnostics? Do the end users have to analyze the emitted C when something goes wrong?
Re:C as an intermediate language (2012)
by MaxBarraclough on Saturday January 20, 2018 @10:18AM
(#16193614)
Annoyingly Vala is extremely shy about the generated C, but I believe it uses #pragmas to map the generated C back to the Vala source.
I've only dabbled in Vala, but apparently its "-g" flag lets you debug with GDB. https://wiki.gnome.org/Projects/Vala/Tutorial#Debugging