But that aside, saying "its everywhere" is in my opinion the /poorest/ argument in favor of anything technical.
MySQL has their slogan as being the "Most popular Open Source database", which, by comparison to PostgreSQL's slogan "The most advanced Open Source database", awful.
If you're popular AND good, thats fine, but being popular alone is a poor metric.
PHP offers that, and I don't think I can name anything else that I can say that about.
On vaguely which subject, is there some documentation of the protocols anywhere? I had a quick look on the site and couldn't see anything like that.
Look at the number of horrific security holes in phpBB and Wordpress. Every other release or so fixes some new flaw.
Note: I'm holding back a lot of language nerd rage, so I'm keeping this post very short.
Easy to deploy, but hard to find skilled hackers who will voluntarily work in it.
I tell everyone working on GNU social that we're going it for the betterment of the world, not their own personal situation. That means running it everywhere.
Why are you using PHP? Ruby/Python/Perl/A GUI in Visual Basic would be better!
Better for who? Look at the success of phpBB and Wordpress -- PHP is pretty much everywhere, and while maybe your favourite language is more elegant, PHP is largely ubiquitous.