News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask PG: Essay Editing? by pg on Saturday April 12, 2008 @10:44AM (#161848)
A few years ago I looked at an early draft of an essay to see which text made it into the final version. I never published it at the time, because it seemed presumptuous to think anyone else would be interested. But since you ask,

http://paulgraham.com/laundry.html

Re:Ask PG: Essay Editing? by cousin_it on Saturday April 12, 2008 @01:28PM (#161923)
Good read, thanks! The draft seemed to me more living and personal, while the finished version is pure idea. I wonder if it's possible to keep the intimate tone when you're editing for clarity.
Re:Ask PG: Essay Editing? by pg on Saturday April 12, 2008 @08:20PM (#162132)
Interesting question. I think it would be hard. Maybe you could leave in occasional chatty bits to preserve that tone, at the cost of only a little extra length.
Re:Ask PG: Essay Editing? by as on Saturday April 12, 2008 @09:21PM (#162147)
I think that intimacy is the awkwardness that's natural to real time conversation. Like where he knocks passion fruit. I laughed because of how out of tone it seemed.
Re:Ask PG: Essay Editing? by iamwil on Saturday April 12, 2008 @12:22PM (#161895)
Do you find that you get better and faster at editing the essays, comparing the first essay to the most recent one? (I imagine so) Or it is something like a constant, but you just find ways to work around it?

I find that writing is good practice to to get my thoughts down coherently. And with a blogging habit, I find I can do it with much more ease, but it still takes a long while to re-edit something.

Re:Ask PG: Essay Editing? by pg on Saturday April 12, 2008 @08:26PM (#162134)
You get better at deletion. When you first start writing, it's hard to delete stuff because it cost you a lot of effort to write it. As you get more confident, you get more ruthless in that respect: "This is crap. Out with it."

Editing is writing, however, and the hardest part of writing is thinking. I don't feel I've gotten much better at that.

Re:Ask PG: Essay Editing? by adammichaelc on Saturday April 12, 2008 @03:41PM (#162017)
Wow! Talk about surprises. I've never thought about writing in that way. I think if I had I might have really enjoyed it. Hey, I think I might go write something that I've been thinking a lot about lately... now I just need to find out what I've been thinking about. haha Thanks for the insights.
Re:Ask PG: Essay Editing? by sayrer on Saturday April 12, 2008 @08:34PM (#162136)
I usually learn from these essays, but I've always found them somewhat grating. Some perceive the style as confrontational, but I think that's unreasonable intellectual defensiveness that pg so often picks apart.

These deletions have helped me realize why these essays bother me, on a stylistic level. The cadence is very regular and robotic. It's easy to anticipate the switches from descriptions of conventional wisdom to a different way of framing the problem, and easy to anticipate that there will be a conventional wisdom to roast.

Re:Ask PG: Essay Editing? by pg on Sunday April 13, 2008 @12:57AM (#162225)
Is the draft less grating?
Re:Ask PG: Essay Editing? by sayrer on Tuesday April 15, 2008 @03:11AM (#163914)
I haven't reread the edited version, but the draft is less grating to me than most of these essays (I read every essay). I can see why you deleted much of it, but the draft has some interesting detail that got cut.

The essays do have a lot of telling vs. showing, and maybe that gives them the feel of over-produced music. For instance, the paragraph about VC reactions to your suggestions in Why There Aren't More Googles would be way better as an anecdote with specific detail, imho.

Re:Ask PG: Essay Editing? by kirubakaran on Saturday April 12, 2008 @03:36PM (#162014)
I asked first!

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=152335

Anyway, thanks :-)