Re:Ask PG: Essay Editing?
by pg on Sunday April 13, 2008 @12:57AM
(#162225)
Is the draft less grating?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I haven't reread the edited version, but the draft is less grating to me than most of these essays (I read every essay). I can see why you deleted much of it, but the draft has some interesting detail that got cut.
The essays do have a lot of telling vs. showing, and maybe that gives them the feel of over-produced music. For instance, the paragraph about VC reactions to your suggestions in Why There Aren't More Googles would be way better as an anecdote with specific detail, imho.