News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by lionhearted on Thursday August 19, 2010 @03:45PM (#1618367)
It's got some flaws, but it's one of the most pro-individualism, pro-production, pro-creativity, pro-persistence, pro-hard work, anti-politicking, anti-corruption works of all time. Her characterization of the people she's opposed to is a bit juvenile, but there's a lot of really good and valid stuff in there too - it's the only book I know of that acknowledges the phenomenon where a man works really hard to provide for a bunch of people who think he's not doing enough (Hank Rearden). Also, the opening chapter where everyone is looking to cover their ass and Dagny says she'll accept responsibility if something goes wrong introduces a very strong female protagonist who does business, travels, and lives her life in a strong way.

It's not high literature, it's got some flaws, but it's got some great messages - it'd be a shame people who have contradictory politics just throw all those great messages out.

Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by jbooth on Thursday August 19, 2010 @03:50PM (#1618380)
Ecch.

Let's stick with the Lord of the Rings comparison. If Ayn Rand wrote it, Aragorn and Gandalf would have just hopped the first boat west and let the world fend for itself, because hey, what's the world done for them?

If you were born in America with access to a good education, you're in the luckiest 1% of anyone who ever lived anywhere, and that's all before your 10th birthday. The message of Atlas Shrugged, that these people are 100% self-made and the world owes them something for their hard work, is entitled bullshit.

Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by yummyfajitas on Thursday August 19, 2010 @04:00PM (#1618420)
The message of Atlas Shrugged, that these people are 100% self-made and the world owes them something for their hard work...

As I understood it, the message of Atlas Shrugged is that no one owes anyone else anything except by voluntary agreement. The only people who owe Dagny anything are her passengers, and they owe her only train fare.

(The only exception being that everyone owes a small amount of tax money to pay for public goods, e.g. police protection.)

You should really read a book before criticizing it.

Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by jbooth on Thursday August 19, 2010 @04:24PM (#1618508)
Well, first off, yeah, so if you're born into the situation that I described above (which I was and I'm pretty most HNers were), I think it's pretty entitled and childish to pretend that your accomplishments are yours alone and you have no obligation to the society that produced you. But sure, technically, you don't legally owe anybody anything.

Second off -- if you're the boss, you take responsibility. Any CEO who wants to "go galt" can go right ahead -- they'll be replaced easily enough. There's a fundamental misunderstanding about capitalism -- someone's always ready to replace you. If you're the type of guy to whine about not being appreciated and "go galt" to teach people a lesson, you probably didn't deserve responsibility in the first place -- responsibility is all about being under appreciated.

Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by yummyfajitas on Thursday August 19, 2010 @05:08PM (#1618663)
Where did you get the idea that Galt/etc went on strike because they felt underappreciated? They left because they don't want to support a system they believed to be immoral - compare to conscientious objectors to military service.

Any CEO who wants to "go galt" can go right ahead -- they'll be replaced easily enough.

Rand is well aware of this point. You seem unaware that the fundamental conflict in the novel is between strikers (Galt, Wyatt) and scabs (Dagny, Reardon). For the strike to be a complete success, it is necessary for most/all of the high value scabs to go on strike so as to make replacing strikers difficult.

As for whether you owe society anything, I recognize that your moral principles are different from those of Rand. I'm just curious whether your criticisms of her go beyond simple disagreement.

Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by jbooth on Thursday August 19, 2010 @05:27PM (#1618721)
Thanks for the reasonable response regarding the morals.

As far as "beyond simple disagreement", I guess "strenuous disagreement"?

The fans of Rand philosophy seem to hate the idea of union employees striking for dental care for their kids but have no problem attempting to shake down the system if you're already rich. I totally do not understand this.

Similarly, I think the whole "everyone's replaceable" thing is a fundamental part of reality that anyone over the age of 14 should have figured out. I find it ironic when I get told that if I were older and less idealistic, I'd come around to Rand's viewpoint. Seems to me she's the idealist, except it's bizzaro idealism that fetishises selfishness.

Finally, as I said elsewhere in the thread, the novel's viewpoint on leadership clashes pretty strongly with my own viewpoint on leadership. Leadership's not about what's in it for you, it's about what's in it for the group, or else you're a bad leader.

Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by yummyfajitas on Thursday August 19, 2010 @05:53PM (#1618788)
Which "fans of Rand philosophy" are you describing? What you said certainly doesn't apply to Nathaniel Branden, who was her biggest fan [1].

"Needless to say, men have a right to organize into unions, provided they do so voluntarily, that is, provided no one is forced to join."

http://www.nathanielbranden.com/catalog/articles_essays/labo...

Presumably she agreed with him, since she published it in the Objectivist Newsletter.

And yes, you are quite correct that Rand's novels tend to be idealistic and fairly unrealistic. They are merely parables designed to explain/promote her philosophy.

[1] He was her biggest fan when he wrote that. He got kicked out of the cult a few years later, when Rand found out he was banging someone besides her and his wife.

Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by dk on Thursday August 19, 2010 @05:54PM (#1618790)
Rand actually said at one point (sorry I don't remember where) that striking was a legitimate way for workers to correct a situation where they're being paid below market rate -- as long as it was done voluntarily. What Rand opposed was pro-union legislation that coercively stacks the decks in the unions' favor.
Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by grandalf on Thursday August 19, 2010 @04:33PM (#1618543)
You've seriously misunderstood the book if you have actually read it. Before I respond in detail I have to ask you bluntly if you've read Atlas Shrugged in full.
Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by jbooth on Thursday August 19, 2010 @04:44PM (#1618589)
I've only read passages.

I'm mostly concerned with the "Going Galt" bit, which I'm either understanding as originally conveyed or every summary I've read from both ends of the political spectrum was egregiously wrong. So if you'd like to correct me on what "Going Galt" means, please feel free. It looks to me like a total cop-out abdication of responsibility that would change precisely nothing - because everyone's replaceable.

Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by grandalf on Thursday August 19, 2010 @04:54PM (#1618623)
You're taking the "Going Galt" concept out of context. In the context of the book it's at the end of a long dystopian spiral. The significance of it is that the characters have already been broken by the time they arrive there.

Frankly, the ending is a bit unsatisfactory on a few levels. First, it's not a prescription for how to run a society (it's a small utopian community in the mountains) and yet the book ends quickly at that point so we're left wondering how it turned out.

It was necessary as a plot element, but it's really the denouement rather than the climax of the book.

I recommend you buy the unabridged audio version of the book and give it a read while driving, commuting, etc. It has fairly good production quality and is a fairly effortless read on audio.

When I re-read it my reaction was that Rand uses some hyperbole in places where I (if I were the editor) would have recommended a slightly softer touch... but of course she is writing to the first time the reader encounters the story and she wants to be sure to lay down a solid plot foundation early so that the rest of the book can progress.

What I found remarkable about the book was that it's a pure novel of ideas. One can only imagine (while drooling) how amazing it would be if all the world's great thinkers had written a few books of quality fiction to help illustrate their ideas. So in my opinion Rand should get points added for the fiction work, not points subtracted.

Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by jbooth on Thursday August 19, 2010 @05:18PM (#1618690)
I'm not taking it out of context. I'm pointing out how unbelievably stupid the context is.

Is the book in the fantasy section? Does it have a disclaimer "this context is nothing like the real world so don't apply any of these philosophies"? As I understand it, the book is attempting to make a point about the real world.

I'm saying that point is totally ignorant of how the real world works, particularly how leadership works.

Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by grandalf on Thursday August 19, 2010 @05:32PM (#1618739)
I don't think it's fair to make that criticism if you haven't read the book.

The book is a novel of ideas and is, as such, an abstraction. You should not try to interpret it as a prescription for how society should work.

I think what you're looking for is some sort of political treatise or pamphlet. Atlas Shrugged is an argument about the morality of capitalism. If you are looking for more than that in it you'll be disappointed.

I do recommend you take my advice and read it though... I generally have a policy of reimbursing people in beer for the amount they spend on a paperback version. I'm sure that I or someone else would happily extend that offer :)

Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by Tycho on Thursday August 19, 2010 @10:55PM (#1619383)
The tycoons in Atlas Shrugged went on strike because it was no longer moral for them to continue - which in Rand's context means it was no longer in their interest to conduct their business with the American public.

On other occasions Rand explicitly said the strike in AS was a 'if, and only if' situation and not applicable to the present world (ie. not justified. ie. not in anyone's interest). The point was that socialism/altruism had taken such a firm grip of the nation (and the rest of the world) that any grand enterprise that still existed merely prolonged the agony by feeding the ruling parasites. Once the protagonists finally realized this, they went on strike.

The strike worked because society had reached a point where those producers genuinely were irreplaceable, in that their likes were no longer being bred/trained by the industries. The book (and history) is littered with examples of the types of laws/systems responsible for this talent drought, and the young people who find themselves on the resulting scrapheap.

Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by grandalf on Thursday August 19, 2010 @04:01PM (#1618422)
Not sure where you're getting that.

Atlas Shrugged addresses the morality of capitalism. If you want to criticize it, you should be clear what you're criticizing. You seem to have an axe to grind with some subset of Americans, but I'm not sure how that relates to Atlas Shrugged.

In my opinion, legitimate criticism would take the form of an argument against capitalism or an argument that shows how some other economic system is actually far better from a moral standpoint (not just in intention but in results).

Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by jbooth on Thursday August 19, 2010 @04:09PM (#1618444)
It addresses the morality of crybabies. The major theme of the book is that these titans of industry were such a bunch of whiners who didn't get enough respect and love from people, so they peaced out to show the world who was really important.

Guess what? If you do that, I'll just take your job. 4 weeks of transition and we'll be rolling again.

That's called being the boss. You're accountable and the people who are smaller than you can snipe, you can be bigger than that or you can be one of them.

I find it hard to believe that anybody who's actually had any responsibility in their life would ever get behind taking your ball and going home to spite people.

Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by grandalf on Thursday August 19, 2010 @04:32PM (#1618538)
You seem to think that someone whose passion is business (in the case of Atlas Shrugged mechanical engineering) should somehow feel a strong obligation to create on behalf of others.

Nobody expects this of painters, poets, or writers because it is understood that their creative acts are done with love and personal importance.

But creation is creation, whether it's an alloy or a painting or a poem. Rand's point was that it is the same driving force that moves humanity forward.

The question is whether you think of it as something that should be coveted and respected (like, say, the musings of a Poet) or if you simply look at the distribution of wealth and declare that all that is unimportant, that the creative person should care more about helping others than about pursuing his/her work.

The point of the book was not to suggest that people leave, but to show how the morality described in the book could stand alone as first principles of an improved society. The book is a novel of ideas and not (as you seem to have taken it) as a literal prescription for how individuals in society should act.

Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by brg on Thursday August 19, 2010 @04:30PM (#1618530)
You missed or ignore a good portion of the book. No hero of the book was a crybaby; no one whined to their parents, friends, or authorities to get their way. Every hero of the book took it upon them self to better their own situation at the expense of no one else. They saw it was full of crybabies, and removed themselves by their own volition.

I can't see why anyone has a problem with someone else just asking to be left alone.

Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by mhd on Thursday August 19, 2010 @03:51PM (#1618386)
> where a man works really hard to provide for a bunch of people who think he's not doing enough

Isn't that the plot of every Charles Dickens novel ever?

Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by aaronbrethorst on Friday August 20, 2010 @02:44AM (#1619716)
That and Arrested Development.
Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by LargeWu on Thursday August 19, 2010 @05:11PM (#1618671)
If that's all you took from her philosophy - being an individual is good, working hard is good, etc. - then you missed a lot of the detail.

To Rand, the ultimate measure of one's self worth is how much money you are making vs. how much you could be making. Building a company up, then offshoring all of your labor to China is more moral than keeping your operations local, because it will lower your costs, and therefore increase profits. And profits, to Rand, is the only thing that matters, as long as you aren't stealing from somebody else.

Similarly, in Rand's book it would be moral for, say, hedge fund managers to make risky bets on bad mortgage-backed securities, even if such a house of cards would eventually cause huge harm to the world economy, as long as the hedge fund managers make money doing so.

In Rand's world, there are no such things as externalities. There is only black and white, good and evil. It is a fairy tale land where everybody is always capable of making rational decisions with perfect information. Markets are always perfectly efficient.

Within the context of her writings, her philosophy works because she gets to define the axioms. But it all falls apart when one realizes that the world is far more complex than she imagines it to be.

Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by dk on Thursday August 19, 2010 @05:51PM (#1618782)
It never ceases to amaze me the certitude with which people demonstrate their ignorance of Rand. This is complete nonsense. Rand never said making money is the highest value nor that it should be the sole standard of any value, dropping all other context.

A moments thought, if you know anything of Rands works, would demonstrate this to you. If you read The Foundtainhead, then you know that Roark gave up work for years because he had higher values in life than simply to maximize his income. And Atlas Shrugged was about a man who did the same, and took a bunch of others with him -- not because they thought this was the best way to optimize their long-term money making potential, but because the rest of the world had come to regard them, being creative and productive individuals, as chattel. (You might also recall that while there were a number of titans of industry, one was a composer, another was a professor, another an train engineer, etc.)

I don't know what it is about Rand that makes people think they're entitled to sling nonsense about her views around without the slightest effort at substantiation. You say Rand's is a "fairy tale land where everybody is always capable of making rational decisions with perfect information" and "Markets are always perfectly efficient". This is your fairy tale about Rand's views. I studied all of Rand's works quite extensively from about the age of 17 to 27, and I'm confident you cannot demonstrate that Rand held such views.

Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by yummyfajitas on Thursday August 19, 2010 @05:31PM (#1618733)
To Rand, the ultimate measure of one's self worth is how much money you are making vs. how much you could be making.

Rand gave up $0.07/copy in royalties to make sure Galt's speech was included in the book.

http://www.nationalreview.com/corner/189415/word-count/nicol...

Roark, in the Fountainhead, also turns down money (and shuts down his company) to preserve his artistic vision.

I really don't know where you got this idea from.

Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by mone on Thursday August 19, 2010 @05:41PM (#1618757)
Well, she did say - "Money is the barometer of society's virtue".
Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by yummyfajitas on Thursday August 19, 2010 @06:00PM (#1618802)
Enough of the quote to get the actual point across: "Money is the barometer of society's virtue[...]when you see that men get rich more easily by graft than by work[...]your society is doomed."

http://www.silverbearcafe.com/private/aynrand.html

The quote has nothing whatsoever to do with maximizing profits. It's about watching the flow of money to determine what kind of society you live in.

Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by mone on Friday August 20, 2010 @03:09PM (#1621261)
The point was, in the ideal society, money is the barometer of society's virtue. Presuming that all money is _earned_, more of it is an indication of the society's success. So, the motive is indeed to maximize profit, earned profit.

Where did I get it wrong?

Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by davidw on Thursday August 19, 2010 @05:21PM (#1618703)
> It is a fairy tale land where everybody is always capable of making rational decisions with perfect information. Markets are always perfectly efficient.

Well, just as the Marx fairy tail is studied, I think the Rand fairy tail (and it is) is good for thought too.