News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by yummyfajitas on Thursday August 19, 2010 @05:08PM (#1618663)
Where did you get the idea that Galt/etc went on strike because they felt underappreciated? They left because they don't want to support a system they believed to be immoral - compare to conscientious objectors to military service.

Any CEO who wants to "go galt" can go right ahead -- they'll be replaced easily enough.

Rand is well aware of this point. You seem unaware that the fundamental conflict in the novel is between strikers (Galt, Wyatt) and scabs (Dagny, Reardon). For the strike to be a complete success, it is necessary for most/all of the high value scabs to go on strike so as to make replacing strikers difficult.

As for whether you owe society anything, I recognize that your moral principles are different from those of Rand. I'm just curious whether your criticisms of her go beyond simple disagreement.

Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by jbooth on Thursday August 19, 2010 @05:27PM (#1618721)
Thanks for the reasonable response regarding the morals.

As far as "beyond simple disagreement", I guess "strenuous disagreement"?

The fans of Rand philosophy seem to hate the idea of union employees striking for dental care for their kids but have no problem attempting to shake down the system if you're already rich. I totally do not understand this.

Similarly, I think the whole "everyone's replaceable" thing is a fundamental part of reality that anyone over the age of 14 should have figured out. I find it ironic when I get told that if I were older and less idealistic, I'd come around to Rand's viewpoint. Seems to me she's the idealist, except it's bizzaro idealism that fetishises selfishness.

Finally, as I said elsewhere in the thread, the novel's viewpoint on leadership clashes pretty strongly with my own viewpoint on leadership. Leadership's not about what's in it for you, it's about what's in it for the group, or else you're a bad leader.

Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by yummyfajitas on Thursday August 19, 2010 @05:53PM (#1618788)
Which "fans of Rand philosophy" are you describing? What you said certainly doesn't apply to Nathaniel Branden, who was her biggest fan [1].

"Needless to say, men have a right to organize into unions, provided they do so voluntarily, that is, provided no one is forced to join."

http://www.nathanielbranden.com/catalog/articles_essays/labo...

Presumably she agreed with him, since she published it in the Objectivist Newsletter.

And yes, you are quite correct that Rand's novels tend to be idealistic and fairly unrealistic. They are merely parables designed to explain/promote her philosophy.

[1] He was her biggest fan when he wrote that. He got kicked out of the cult a few years later, when Rand found out he was banging someone besides her and his wife.

Re:Atlas Shrugged film to be released in 2011 by dk on Thursday August 19, 2010 @05:54PM (#1618790)
Rand actually said at one point (sorry I don't remember where) that striking was a legitimate way for workers to correct a situation where they're being paid below market rate -- as long as it was done voluntarily. What Rand opposed was pro-union legislation that coercively stacks the decks in the unions' favor.