News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by Jtsummers on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @06:11PM (#16163732)
Well, there is actual forex investing (speculating). For instance, the value of the USD versus the Argentine Peso (ARS) is something I track (my girlfriend lives there and long term I would consider moving there, current plan is for her to move here). The USD to ARS conversion is increasingly favorable for the USD, the buying power of ARS hasn't dropped significantly (in country) but the USD is worth more ARS now than 1.5 years ago (1USD:15ARS then versus 1USD:18ARS today). Someone who had currency in ARS at the time, and converted it to the USD, could see significant returns on that investment (assuming reasonable exchange fees). Almost 20% gains, that matches the US stock increases over this past year.

It is speculation, however, as you generally don't have the same sort of insight into currency movements as you will into stock movements and commodities in general. Someone watching the Brexit vote in summer 2016 would have made a decent return on ARS had they moved it to the USD before the vote and back after (changed from 1USD:13ARS to 1USD:15ARS practically overnight). But that is speculation and requires watching global and national scale events to predict.

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by slyzmud on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @06:49AM (#16167162)
I live in Argentina. I want to add that we don't invest in dollars, we save in dollars. We don't expect to have more money after some time, we just expect not to loose money by inflation.

Although it might seem that buying dollars have a return of 20% or more in a year, by the time you sell it everything cost more in ARS because most prices are tied to US dollars. So you end up having the same. If you have saved in ARS, with the same money you could buy a lot less things

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by reacharavindh on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @03:17AM (#16166328)
Out of curiosity, did you check the inflation rate of Argentina? May be you could get same value in Argentina with 20% more Argentinian currency after a year?

I found this thinking about my home land - India..

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by philipov on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @07:06PM (#16164160)
I believe strongly that the word 'invest' should be used to distinguish one's activities from speculation, rather than be a superclass of it. Discourse is poisoned when people promote semantic overlap and create ambiguity, rather than using words to create meaningful distinctions.

Investing is what you do when you're not merely speculating on short-term returns, but are instead focused on long-term value creation. It is right to call it currency speculation, because instead of investing capital to create sustainable growth in something, you're just skimming the fluctuations using massive leverage.

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by lsaferite on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @07:34PM (#16164372)
Unless you are part of an IPO or are buying newly issued stock you are also speculating on stocks when you buy them.

Note: Not a finance person, just a personal opinion.

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by philipov on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @07:45PM (#16164464)
In practice, it may not be possible to neatly classify any particular financial decision as being purely investment or purely speculation. This only increases the need to have these words mean clearly different things so that we may use them to analyze the different aspects of the ambiguous world in which we find ourselves. Blurring the meaning of the words effectively robs people of the ability to reason about their circumstances, and it is no wonder that many people feel invested in creating such confusion.
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by brucephillips on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @07:48PM (#16164478)
The impossibility of separating the two concepts necessitates two different words for those concepts?

That's a contradiction.

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by philipov on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @07:50PM (#16164493)
The concepts are easy to separate: Investment is symbiotic, Speculation is parasitic. Having clear concepts is more important when the real-world examples are complicated.
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by mythrwy on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @10:10PM (#16165157)
Speculation isn't necessarily parasitic at all. For example it can function in assuming risk.
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by brucephillips on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @07:51PM (#16164495)
How is speculation parasitic?
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by philipov on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @08:04PM (#16164562)
Speculators seek to extract alpha without regard to the overall health of the instrument. Shorting is just as good as going long, so far as you make a profit.
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by brucephillips on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @08:06PM (#16164570)
That doesn't mean they're parasitic. To show they're parasitic, you'd have to describe how they hurt the company.

Regardless, what defines speculation is not parasitism, it's uncertainty. And there's uncertainty in any investment as well. That's why there's no clear line between the two.

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by philipov on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @08:14PM (#16164614)
I disagree. I have made a clear delineation in the semantic content of my definitions, while you continue to attempt to confuse the issue.
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by brucephillips on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @08:17PM (#16164637)
I mean, the definitions aren't yours to make. These words exist in the dictionary.
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by philipov on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @08:23PM (#16164672)
Writers of dictionaries are archaeologists of language. They do not prescribe the meaning of words like a programmer or mathematician. Their definitions are posterior to language. The definitions are in fact mine to make, provided they result in successful communication with people who have adopted similar definitions.

Go read my original post again. I am advocating against ambiguity in language, as this serves to obscure analysis. You are clearly happy to obliterate distinction, however, and have made no attempt at a positive argument why it is beneficial to discourse.

Language is a constant negotiation about the meaning of words, and I have made my position clear.

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by brucephillips on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @08:27PM (#16164693)
I'll bow out here, but I'll just point out that this is a great example of how one's adherence to their ideas makes rational conversation impossible.

We can only communicate to the extent that we agree on the definitions of words, so for you to invent your own definitions, which contradict how other people use the word, as codified in dictionaries, then there's zero hope of reaching shared understanding.

It would be absurd for me to claim that "the sky is brown", the later argue that I was right all along because I'm defining "brown" to be "blue".

Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by philipov on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @08:35PM (#16164725)
I will simply point out that at every opportunity, I have been upfront about what definitions I am adopting and the distinctions I am attempting to make, while you have done nothing but dissemble and create ambiguity, without offering a positive program of your own. I will leave it up to other readers to make their own conclusions.
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by brucephillips on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @08:43PM (#16164758)
If I say "the sky is brown", am I being up front that I'm defining "brown" to be the color of the sky?
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by bduerst on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @09:25PM (#16164954)
This comment thread has been one of the weirdest internet arguments on the semantics of a word that I've seen in a while.
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by imcoconut on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @01:51AM (#16165998)
only on HN.
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by zodiac on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @04:02AM (#16166510)
Would you say that all short selling is parasitic?
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by eloff on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @07:44PM (#16164457)
It depends I guess on how you do your homework and how long you hold the stocks for. Warren Buffett style long-term value based investing vs speculative day trading for example.
Re:Bitcoin Fall Extends to 25% as Fears of Crackdown Linger by brucephillips on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @07:48PM (#16164482)
Speculation relates to uncertainty, not timing.