Re:The British Once Built a 1,100-Mile Hedge Through the Mid...
by eadmund on Monday January 15, 2018 @02:50PM
(#16152887)
I'm sure that the labourers had to pay for other taxes too, but man, I'd kill for only 7½% income tax. Right now my total tax burden is about 50%.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The British Once Built a 1,100-Mile Hedge Through the Mid...
by sangnoir on Monday January 15, 2018 @03:24PM
(#16153109)
The 7.5% is not income tax - it's just salt-duty! If we were to add a 7.5% duty for salt alone to your current 50% tax burden, I'm sure you'd be marching too.
Re:The British Once Built a 1,100-Mile Hedge Through the Mid...
by notahacker on Monday January 15, 2018 @04:06PM
(#16153440)
Suspect the average early twentieth century Indian farmer would kill for the OP's state subsidised education, healthcare, unemployment benefits and pension too, never mind his disposable income after tax...
Re:The British Once Built a 1,100-Mile Hedge Through the Mid...
by mikeash on Monday January 15, 2018 @05:24PM
(#16153995)
The impact of taxes depends on how much you have to begin with. Would you kill to have both that laborer's tax rate and that laborer's wages?
Re:The British Once Built a 1,100-Mile Hedge Through the Mid...
by afterburner on Monday January 15, 2018 @03:02PM
(#16152970)
You're probably thinking of just your top marginal rate on income tax?
Re:The British Once Built a 1,100-Mile Hedge Through the Mid...
by eadmund on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @07:37PM
(#16164392)
No, I mean that my income, capital-gains, sales & property taxes, along with fees like those for my car registration, equal roughly half my total income.
Re:The British Once Built a 1,100-Mile Hedge Through the Mid...
by afterburner on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @01:33AM
(#16165935)
Seems highly unlikely unless you're not including the gains from your capital gains in your ratio. Do you know how the marginal rates work?
Re:The British Once Built a 1,100-Mile Hedge Through the Mid...
by eadmund on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @10:12AM
(#16168510)
> Seems highly unlikely unless you're not including the gains from your capital gains in your ratio.
Nope, I am. It's remarkable how high one's tax burden is, once one starts to actually track it. All those sales taxes and fees add up.
> Do you know how the marginal rates work?
Yup. I'm calculating (total government costs)/(total income), for all of my income and all costs-of-government.
Re:The British Once Built a 1,100-Mile Hedge Through the Mid...
by afterburner on Thursday January 18, 2018 @01:08PM
(#16179618)
You're hitting the top marginal rates and seeing sales tax be a large burden? Weird. Are you spending more than you're currently earning?
Re:The British Once Built a 1,100-Mile Hedge Through the Mid...
by eadmund on Sunday January 21, 2018 @12:48PM
(#16199049)
I wouldn't say that sales tax is a large burden, but 8½% adds up over time.
No, I spend less than I earn, and save quite a bit. Some of that savings is tax-advantaged, but overall I pay a huge amount of my income in taxes & fees. I don't mind that taxes exist, really; I don't mind paying for a social safety net. But I think something's wrong when half of my productive labour & investment income is taken from me every year.
Re:The British Once Built a 1,100-Mile Hedge Through the Mid...
by afterburner on Monday January 22, 2018 @04:50PM
(#16208257)
So you have an extremely high income and no investments? The top marginal rate is 40%, and that only applies to what you make over $420,000.
Re:The British Once Built a 1,100-Mile Hedge Through the Mid...
by oblio on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @03:16AM
(#16156580)
Maybe, but your 50% left cover your expenses for food, clothing, shelter, medicine, etc. I doubt that the 93% the average Indian laborer or farmer had covered his basic necessities. And as another posted said, this was just the salt tax.