News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rents dropping significantly across the Seattle area afte... by refurb on Monday January 15, 2018 @10:11AM (#16150944)
Just because rent is decreasing on the high end doesnt mean it’s decreasing on the low end apartments.

There is a knock-on effect although depending on the spread it might be small.

Ontario (Canada) just raised minimum wage by 20%+ in one shot to $15/hr. Lots of drama happening now as business owners try to adjust.

What I found interesting is that workers who were making $15/hr before the increase are now asking for a raise. It was a restaurant where the front-end made $15 and the dish washers $12. Now the front end says "I should be making more than the dish washers" and it goes all the way up the chain.

Re:Rents dropping significantly across the Seattle area afte... by dvanduzer on Monday January 15, 2018 @10:57AM (#16151233)
The psychology of relative status garners a lot of attention to understand inequality. Of course there is backlash to front-of-house folks seeing their relative status decrease, despite the fact that nothing has changed for them. A difficult, but crucial adaptation needs to happen in a wide variety of industries: The people working the less glamorous, less visible, but equally crucial roles in operating these businesses should have been treated as peers / relative equals all along.

The converse is also true in software engineering. Questions like whether programming is "more difficult" than graphic design are largely irrelevant. Humans will always be playing status games, but denigrating labor based on some perceived skill level is a habit we should actively be trying to get rid of. Meanwhile...

> There is a knock-on effect although depending on the spread it might be small.

Can you provide more specific detail where knock-on effects like this have been observed? It's nearly guaranteed that a decrease on low end rents will be vanishingly small. Margins can only go so low, which is why developers are attracted to luxury projects in the first place.

(Likewise, a million dollar paycut from a CEO can only raise 480 person-hour-dollars in wages. But those margins matter a hell of a lot more for the line worker's lifestyle than upper management's.)

Re:Rents dropping significantly across the Seattle area afte... by zeveb on Monday January 15, 2018 @11:08AM (#16151314)
> Of course there is backlash to front-of-house folks seeing their relative status decrease, despite the fact that nothing has changed for them.

Well, their purchasing power is about to go down because when they go out to eat they're going to be paying for $15/hr dishwashers instead of $12/hr dishwashers.

> A difficult, but crucial adaptation needs to happen in a wide variety of industries: The people working the less glamorous, less visible, but equally crucial roles in operating these businesses should have been treated as peers / relative equals all along.

But they're not really. A dishwasher needs to be able to scrub dishes, load & unload a mechanical dishwasher, show up more-or-less on time, not get into fights with the other employees — that's about it (incidentally, I know whereof I speak: my first job was washing dishes).

The front-of-house staff need to speak the local language, be polite & friendly to customers, have good memories, have attention to detail, be able to manage relatively complex situations, be reliable &c. It's a very different — and rarer — skillset.

You don't even really need to have a functional IQ to be a successful dishwasher; you need to be reasonably sociable & quick on your feet to be a successful waiter or maître d'hôtel.

It's eminently reasonable and fair that a job anyone can do will pay less than a job fewer people can do.

Re:Rents dropping significantly across the Seattle area afte... by ggg9990 on Monday January 15, 2018 @11:52AM (#16151626)
> It's eminently reasonable and fair that a job anyone can do will pay less than a job fewer people can do.

That’s strongly a matter of opinion. Almost anyone is physically capable of being a home health care aide for a dying child, and almost nobody is physically capable of being an NFL quarterback — but I don’t really find it “fair” that the latter is paid a thousand times the salary.

Re:Rents dropping significantly across the Seattle area afte... by dvanduzer on Monday January 15, 2018 @11:27AM (#16151437)
> It's eminently reasonable and fair that a job anyone can do will pay less than a job fewer people can do.

No, it isn't.

You don't have to agree in any substantial way with anything else Marx says, to recognize that "from each according to his abilities, to each according to his needs" is eminently reasonable and fair.

Everything you're saying to glorify front-of-house roles is also true of back-of-house roles. True, the best possible server in a restaurant can improve the bottom line X% more than the best possible dishwasher can. But comparing the worst possible dishwasher with the worst possible server is also important. Can you say with any confidence which "problem employee" will have a larger negative effect on the bottom line? Probably not.

What if it's just a slightly below average dishwasher? What if the server is "only" sexually harassing coworkers a little bit? Gauging the range of human performance by the wages they use for sustenance is stupid, but apparently necessary.

> Well, their purchasing power is about to go down because when they go out to eat they're going to be paying for $15/hr dishwashers instead of $12/hr dishwashers.

Again, a claim missing some crucial substance. How much is their purchasing power going to go down? Will the price of a hamburger or an apron really go up more than a couple of pennies?

Re:Rents dropping significantly across the Seattle area afte... by Clanan on Monday January 15, 2018 @12:56PM (#16152125)
That's a whole lot of stretching to justify the communist approach. Are you really arguing that a dishwasher is worth just as much as a server? I don't think any businessperson will agree with you.

You might be more successful by just arguing that value shouldn't be tied to wages (which is what your quote is really pushing.)

Re:Rents dropping significantly across the Seattle area afte... by dvanduzer on Monday January 15, 2018 @02:50PM (#16152890)
It is interesting that you are gauging my "success" on whether my comment is changing minds about economic theory. Please consider that I explicitly excluded anything else Marx wrote from assent, to reduce the likelihood that anyone would mistake my argument for Fully Automated Luxury Communism or whatever the kids are calling it these days.

I am explicitly arguing that value and wages are not tied to each other, today, with examples.

Generally speaking, we treat the value of labor in accord with the cost of developing a skill. Whether by correlation or accident, this seems to mean we dramatically undervalue softer skills involved in working with other people. (NB: This is related to, but very different than the customer service face front-of-house puts on.) There are kitchens where the entire morale of the restaurant staff rests on the good natured attitude of the dishwasher. That person leaves, and soon afterwards, everybody hates working there, and nobody can figure out why.

I think any sane businessperson knows this, and does agree with me. Most businesspersons also know that everyone in a restaurant is completely replaceable. Right?

Re:Rents dropping significantly across the Seattle area afte... by MR4D on Monday January 15, 2018 @11:54PM (#16155928)
Respectfully, I believe you are wrong about value of labor.

It seems to be much more based on supply & demand.

If everyone could do it, and there were no demand, the value would be low.

A quick way to check this is to look at expensive college programs where people come out making much less than the cost of their education. If you were correct, then such situation would not occur.

(And yes, I’m aware you said “generally”, because must even generally I think it’s incorrect. )

Re:Rents dropping significantly across the Seattle area afte... by dvanduzer on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @10:45PM (#16165301)
How does anything I typed conflict with the basic macroeconomic pressures of supply and demand? Labor markets have those tensions, and the useful thing to understand are the factors influencing supply & demand.

Applying market theory to labor/employer relations, says that wages should tend to go up, if the demand (job openings) for a particular kind of labor exceeds the supply (pool of people who can & will do those jobs). But talking about how labor gets priced by markets doesn't explain anything about why governments choose the minimum wage (if any) that they do. Minimum wage is an explicitly moral consideration where we compel the demand side to observe a floor on the price of your time.

> If everyone could do it, and there were no demand, the value would be low.

That just muddles the separate mechanisms. If everyone has the skill for a job, the potential labor pool is as large as it possibly can be, so supply pressure is naturally higher. You are correct to say that demand pressure is what then drives a negotiated wage. But that's just table stakes to understand what an economy is actually composed of. Does this region have a highly skilled workforce, with demand outpacing the supply of workers, thus driving wages up? Congratulations! This means your region has a proportionally lower supply of low skilled workers, which creates upward market pressure on wages. Using the lens of supply and demand means you now need to look for explanations when the demand for unskilled labor doesn't go down, which is what it would take to keep wages constant.

And the value a supplier (worker) assigns to their own time? Demand pressure only indirectly influences a person's perception of value. People get born into a variety of different financial circumstances that alter their negotiating position.

> A quick way to check this is to look at expensive college programs where people come out making much less than the cost of their education. If you were correct, then such situation would not occur.

As respectfully as possible: this is nonsense. There are all sorts of externalities involved in paying for an education that would never be captured by the labor market model. If somebody is paying a lot of money to develop some skill that has low ROI in the labor market, the only thing that signals is that the person getting the "useless" degree must value having that skill for non-monetary reasons. This kind of thing is always a problem when talking about economics as the science of rational agents. Even if the market demand for a particular skill is zero, some people will use money to develop that skill anyway. This observed fact does not remotely invalidate anything I've said.

Re:Rents dropping significantly across the Seattle area afte... by MR4D on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @03:33PM (#16171528)
In answer to your first question, I keyed in on this comment that you made in the OP: "Generally speaking, we treat the value of labor in accord with the cost of developing a skill."

Physics degrees are awfully hard to get, and yet for every physicist, there are surely many more sales people who get paid more.

So this is what I disagreed with.

Re:Rents dropping significantly across the Seattle area afte... by DaiPlusPlus on Monday January 15, 2018 @10:50AM (#16151185)
But can those restaurant workers now comfortably (<33% of take-home) afford their rent?