News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How do plutonium-powered pacemakers work? by saagarjha on Sunday January 14, 2018 @08:38PM (#16147813)
How long to these pacemakers last? Have people had to get the plutonium "batteries" replaced?
Re:How do plutonium-powered pacemakers work? by Kelbit on Sunday January 14, 2018 @09:35PM (#16148069)
Easier to replace the whole pacemaker than the battery, for a couple of reasons:

* Pacemakers are hermetically sealed, usually laser-welded in a titanium case. Adding a replaceable battery with seals would complicate this arrangement.

* By the time the battery winds down, there may be a newer, better pacemaker on the market that fits the patient's needs.

* Since a battery replacement necessitates surgery, you might as well replace the whole unit and get all new parts rather than put an old one back in that may be reaching MTTF.

As for how long the cells last, modern Lithium Thionyl Chloride cells last 5-10 years depending on the pacemaker. They probably actually last longer, manufacturers are pretty conservative with lifetime estimates.

As for plutonium supplies like those in the article, they don't really die since they're thermoelectric. The amount of current you can draw will be proportional to the amount of heat generated by the isotope and the temperature gradient. Since the heat is related to the amount of isotope remaining, the power available will follow an exponential decay. The half-life of Pu-238 is about 88 years, so the battery will last a very long time. The exact lifetime depends on how much current the pacemaker takes to operate.

Most people had these devices replaced with more modern versions, but there are still a few people who have the old plutonium devices which were implanted decades ago.

Re:How do plutonium-powered pacemakers work? by perlgeek on Monday January 15, 2018 @01:09AM (#16148835)
Somebody in my family has a pacemaker, and is fully dependent on it. I can confirm this part:

> Easier to replace the whole pacemaker than the battery

unfortunately, this statement:

> As for how long the cells last, modern Lithium Thionyl Chloride cells last 5-10 years depending on the pacemaker. They probably actually last longer, manufacturers are pretty conservative with lifetime estimates.

only partially applies in this case. That pacemaker has a lot of work to do (stimulate every single heart beat), and depending on the quality of the electrodes on the heart, and the cables that lead to them, some needed to be replaced after two or three years. If one lasts 7 years, that is a very welcome respite, but quite the exception.

That said, pacemakers have come a long way. The first on that this person had implanted had a fixed beat. The current generation has sensors for oxygen saturation and movement, and be configured and maintained through a wireless interface, they log unusual events etc.

Re:How do plutonium-powered pacemakers work? by ctdonath on Monday January 15, 2018 @11:25AM (#16151428)
I have one. 100% dependent, dynamic rate, wireless interface, logging, runs about 7 years. "Battery low" state is addressed with progressively more annoying behavior (fixed 60 bpm, beat skipping, etc) that both saves power and urges patient to doctor. Whole unit indeed gets replaced (yes, the hard way), no point in fiddling with maintaining old tech and increased point-of-failure interfaces.

And with it, I'm likely healthier than without it & the underlying issue.

Re:How do plutonium-powered pacemakers work? by bigiain on Monday January 15, 2018 @01:07AM (#16148828)
> The exact lifetime depends on how much current the pacemaker takes to operate.

Not so sure. I don't think the plutonium decay is affected by the current drawn via the thermocouple - it'll just keep putting out the same power (well, the same decaying power curve anyway) no matter how much current you try and draw. I suspect the thermocouple's voltage will just sag so the maximum drawn power will be the thermal output less the efficiency of the conversion (which, I guess, might be non-linear with current?).

But I'm pretty sure whether you draw zero Amps or short circuit the output, you'll still have precisely 50% of your plutonium left after 88 years, right?

Re:How do plutonium-powered pacemakers work? by perlgeek on Monday January 15, 2018 @01:13AM (#16148847)
> But I'm pretty sure whether you draw zero Amps or short circuit the output, you'll still have precisely 50% of your plutonium left after 88 years, right?

True.

The power requirements can still vary between patients (due to varying quality of the electrical contacts, which tends to deteriorate over time), so there is an individual component, it's just not based on the power drawn from the battery.

Re:How do plutonium-powered pacemakers work? by Kelbit on Monday January 15, 2018 @11:39AM (#16151531)
Correct, the decay is not affected by the amount of charge you've pulled out of the cell.

What I meant (and should have expressed more clearly) is that the pacemaker will have some minimum current it needs to be able to draw from the TEG to operate, and after the plutonium has decayed to a certain point it won't be able to source enough current to operate, so the pacemaker will brown out.

Re:How do plutonium-powered pacemakers work? by rplnt on Monday January 15, 2018 @05:03AM (#16149623)
Wouldn't wireless charging pad work well for this? Or is it unnecessary complicated considering how long batteries last?
Re:How do plutonium-powered pacemakers work? by ianhowson on Monday January 15, 2018 @07:34AM (#16150099)
Chest cavities aren't especially space-constrained, and another commenter mentioned that electrodes wear out fairly quickly (single-digit years), so it appears that a fixed non-rechargeable battery has enough capacity to last the lifetime of the device.

Wireless charging (for a pacemaker) has the issue that you've got to push the energy through quite a lot of flesh, with consequent efficiency and heat issues.

Wireless charging is absolutely an option for other devices implanted closer to the skin, though.

Re:How do plutonium-powered pacemakers work? by ctdonath on Monday January 15, 2018 @11:33AM (#16151484)
The issue being rather close to my heart, I'd rather have a single-use 7-year battery + full modern replacement of unit, than have to fiddle with periodic recharging just to prolong use of aging technology. Nobody much wants their life relying on >10 year old computers. (Remember: it's already "old technology" when you first get it implanted.)
Re:How do plutonium-powered pacemakers work? by Kelbit on Monday January 15, 2018 @11:36AM (#16151508)
Rumor is Medtronic pacemakers still use 6502 processors (albeit on modernized custom silicon) with code written in the 80s. Big medical OEMs are loathe to change.
Re:How do plutonium-powered pacemakers work? by toomuchtodo on Monday January 15, 2018 @10:08PM (#16155480)
You don’t fix what isn’t broken when it’s a life critical system.
Re:How do plutonium-powered pacemakers work? by joshschreuder on Monday January 15, 2018 @06:52AM (#16149956)
I think the main problem is the giant meat sack sitting between the charging pad and battery :)
Re:How do plutonium-powered pacemakers work? by rplnt on Monday January 15, 2018 @07:06AM (#16149997)
The main problem might be patents :)

Samsung includes charging of medical device[1] in their wireless charging patent. Although the patent[2] seems to focus on the charging method/devices, rather than where they are located.

1. http://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/US20140084858A1/U...

2. http://www.google.com/patents/US20140084858

Re:How do plutonium-powered pacemakers work? by nukeop on Monday January 15, 2018 @05:31AM (#16149714)
I'm sure that in 1985, plutonium is available in every corner drugstore, but in 1955, it's a little hard to come by.
Re:How do plutonium-powered pacemakers work? by acidburnNSA on Sunday January 14, 2018 @09:15PM (#16147970)
The half-life of Pu-238 (the isotope used in these) is 87.7 years [1]. So they pretty much last a lifetime. For the same reason, Voyager 1 is still kicking even though it's out of the solar system [2].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plutonium-238

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voyager_1

Re:How do plutonium-powered pacemakers work? by perlgeek on Monday January 15, 2018 @01:16AM (#16148861)
Still, Voyager 1 is slowly shutting down its scientific instruments due to decreased power supply.

I highly recommend this podcast episode with one of the Voyager project managers: https://www.listentospacepod.com/episodes/2016/8/5/episode-5... (about 20 minutes long, iirc)

(In fact, I'd highly recommend the whole podcast, not just this episode, but this one actually talks about power consumption and battery life of Voyager).

Re:How do plutonium-powered pacemakers work? by effie on Monday January 15, 2018 @06:32AM (#16149891)
The project manager Suzy Dodd talks a lot about shutting down instruments in order to save the power. But the power output of radioisotope thermoelectric generator does not depend on how much power is drawn. Is there a conventional electric battery on the Voyagers that the instruments draw their power from instead?
Re:How do plutonium-powered pacemakers work? by c3833174 on Monday January 15, 2018 @07:41AM (#16150122)
By saving power she means leaving enough margin to keep the supply voltage stable, running the machine near the limit could cause voltage sag when another device like the tape drive is turned on.

Just like apple limits power draw of it's devices to avoid possible reboots when too much current is demanded from an old battery.

Re:How do plutonium-powered pacemakers work? by effie on Tuesday January 16, 2018 @09:47AM (#16158506)
That makes sense. I still wonder if there is battery that would be recharged by the RTG. Seem like it could save some useful energy for the future time when it is needed.
Re:How do plutonium-powered pacemakers work? by perlgeek on Wednesday January 17, 2018 @11:25AM (#16169177)
I don't know, but it wouldn't surprise me if no such battery was on the spacecraft.

You have to remember that Voyager is way past its originally planned mission life span, and that the nuclear battery was more than fine for the planned life span.

Batteries tend to be heavy, not operate well at very low temperatures, and wear down quicker than the 40+ years since construction of the space craft.

From the perspective of the original mission design, even with incredible foresight, it seems to be not worth the trade-offs.

Re:How do plutonium-powered pacemakers work? by QAPereo on Sunday January 14, 2018 @08:55PM (#16147867)
http://www.prutchi.com/pdf/implantable/nuclear_pacemakers.pd...

Last paragraph on page 2... quite a long damned time; by 35 years it was still going strong.