News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by danieltillett on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @04:52AM (#16113721)
The thing I really, really, really don't like about the GDPR is how the EU thinks it can impose it on companies that have no presence in the EU. While the GDPR requirements might be reasonable, this is a very slippery slope that will only end in disaster.
Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by _petronius on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @05:15AM (#16113826)
> companies that have no presence in the EU

Just because you don't have a business presence (in the form of an office and employees) doesn't mean you don't have a presence: collecting data from, and making a profit on, users and customers in the EU is a presence. The alternative would be to surrender the obligation to regulate business practice and the protection of citizens to other countries, with no political accountability.

Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by danieltillett on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @07:58AM (#16114581)
No political accountability is what the EU is doing right now. As a non-citizen of an EU country I have no say in this regulation or its enforcement, but somehow I am supposed to abide by it because the EU says so.

The EU is trying to imposing a huge regulatory burden on companies over which it has no authority. Why do I or any other non-EU company have to put up with this? What happens when the laws in my country conflict with the laws the EU imposes on me from afar?

Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by TeMPOraL on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @08:15AM (#16114663)
> Why do I or any other non-EU company have to put up with this?

You don't have to. Just don't do business in the EU / with EU citizens.

> What happens when the laws in my country conflict with the laws the EU imposes on me from afar?

You have a choice - either break the laws or your country, or... just don't do business in the EU.

(I do hope GDPR doesn't affect your company much; it seems to be doing God's good work, unlike most of the companies GDPR is targeted at.)

Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by wav-part on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @08:30AM (#16114746)
> "don't do business in the EU"

This does not make sense on web.

EU resident streaming a movie from netflix. Is netflix doing business in EU ? Or Is it the customer doing business in USA ? For example, it can be argued that its as if the customer went to USA, bought the dvd.

Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by jen20 on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @09:02AM (#16114927)
https://jobs.netflix.com/locations/london-united-kingdom

Yes. Furthermore they have licensed content for this purpose.

Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by wav-part on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @09:17AM (#16115017)
Ah did not know that. Replace netflix with a company with no EU establishment.
Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by PeterisP on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @09:54AM (#16115278)
Yes, if you're streaming data to EU and getting money for that from a customer in EU, then you are exporting goods to EU. It's not "as if the customer went to USA, bought the dvd" (in which case it's a local sale and a customer imports their own personal stuff when coming back), it's an international export sale, you bring that "DVD" to Europe. It's as when you ship physical goods through customs, and both the goods and the money flowing through them are subject to EU rules.

If you have zero establishment in EU whatsoever, fines could be taken from all your EU sales revenue (i.e. any funds en route from EU customers to you), and it could be expected that (after they smooth out the process) they also might get a local (e.g. USA) court ruling to enforce that debt on you, there's a lot of international cooperation between the authorities in regards to enforcing trade law. That will take time, though, so until that you're safe unless you want to take money from EU customers or sell the user/advertisement information to EU (or compliant) businesses - in which case, you'll rather want to be compliant.

Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by majewsky on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @09:39AM (#16115167)
As a company with a website, there is no obligation for you to serve customers from around the world. Just restrict yourself to customers within a certain region (e.g. by checking where their credit card is registered, or geoblocking based on IP if you don't take payments) that does not include the EU and you don't have to care about EU law.
Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by Feniks on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @12:08PM (#16116665)
Exactly. As a European I can't get access to Hulu or Funimation.
Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by TeMPOraL on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @08:46AM (#16114843)
I wrote "don't do business in the EU / with EU citizens".

> For example, it can be argued that its as if the customer went to USA, bought the dvd.

A DVD does not collect your personal information and send them to the producer for processing.

Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by wav-part on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @08:52AM (#16114874)
> I wrote "don't do business in the EU / with EU citizens".

Are you saying if I sell to EU tourists visiting USA, I have to follow EU laws ?

> A DVD does not collect your personal information and send them to the producer for processing.

Thats come after when we determine whos doing business where. Or replace dvd with a survilliance device disguised as a toy.

Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by majewsky on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @09:41AM (#16115183)
The GDPR (AFAIK, IANAL) applies to people inside the EU. An EU tourist traveling abroad would be subject to local laws.
Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by danieltillett on Thursday January 11, 2018 @07:34AM (#16123269)
Actually nobody know who it applies to. Anyway what are you supposed to do if some visiting outside the EU returns to the EU and then demands their data is forgotten?
Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by robin_reala on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @09:05AM (#16114943)
Netflix are doing business in the EU. I subscribe to the UK Netflix, which is a Dutch company under the name of Netflix International B.V.‬ The films stream from European servers.
Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by danieltillett on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @08:30AM (#16114743)
I don't think we are collecting any data that is covered by the GDRP as personal information is not of any use to us. I am more just outraged by the EU applying its laws on us like this.

As for not doing any business with EU citizens this is impossible to comply with even if it was an option as there is no way of knowing if a person is an EU citizen or not.

Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by guitarbill on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @01:03PM (#16117235)
Unlike the US, who would never think of applying US law outside of the US to e.g. get emails off a server located in another country or trying to extradite somebody who has never set foot in the US? Right...

Besides, this situation only came about because companies did nothing, especially US companies w.r.t. EU data protection laws. It's a bit like the loot box thing, they thought they could get away with it, pushed it too far, and now they're dealing with the backlash of being huge, amoral scumbags.

Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by danieltillett on Thursday January 11, 2018 @07:02AM (#16123107)
I am not happy about the US’s actions either in applying their laws on everyone.

Anyway this is the sort of argument children use - “john did it too”.

Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by sgift on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @06:04AM (#16114059)
The EU has jurisdiction over EU citizens and business you do with them. Don't want GDPR to apply to you? Don't do business with people living in the EU. Simple as that.
Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by danieltillett on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @07:54AM (#16114565)
Apart from the practical problem of I have no way of knowing if someone who I do business with is covered by this law, why do I have to follow it?

Do you think it is fine for countries to apply their laws as they want on people outside of their country? What would happen if Fiji (just picking a random country here) applied a 10% income tax on all citizens of the EU. Would you think this was reasonable?

Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by TeMPOraL on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @08:16AM (#16114673)
It's the issue of data ownership. You seem to believe the data about your users, including those from the EU, belongs to you. The EU believes otherwise - and from that point of view, it's you who voluntarily subjects himself to EU laws by virtue of taking EU citizens' data.
Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by danieltillett on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @08:42AM (#16114812)
I am not voluntarily subjecting myself to EU laws. If I wanted to do this I would establish a legal presence in the EU. I want nothing to do with the EU.
Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by cinquemb on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @10:30AM (#16115603)
I am also of the same mind. I had a project with a friend where we collected data that would fall under this. We were once told that we had to comply with some "order" from CNIL to stop collection, which we just laughed and ignored.

It's a joke that the same government will go ahead and collect info for "protect the public from terrorists" purposes, yet try to constrain a company outside of their jurisdiction from collecting simmilar information with no real mechanism of enforcement.

People really think these technologies are just going to crawl in a ditch somewhere because some eurocrats (and those who've accepted the bread and circus they provide to the public) want to put pen to paper and act as if these are laws of phyisics... next we'll hear madates that all companies around the world must offer affordable privacy in a can™ for the EU chattel.

The more deep packet inspection/filtering of non complient sites, the more resilient the web will become, so I look forward to the continued escalation.

Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by bjl on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @08:46AM (#16114837)
Then don't do business with EU citizens/residents.
Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by danieltillett on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @09:10AM (#16114965)
And how exactly am I supposed to determine if someone is a EU citizen or not?
Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by calcifer on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @10:55AM (#16115832)
... ask them? Many businesses ask for one or more of address/official ID/credit card info.
Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by danieltillett on Thursday January 11, 2018 @07:06AM (#16123129)
so I have to ask for data that I don’t collect from anyone to allow some European to be able to ask me to remove it. Only someone in the EU could come up with something as stupid as this.

Anyway it is not the data collection, or even removing data that I don’t even collect that I am concerned about, but the the EU applying its laws on me even though I am not in the EU and have no connection with the EU beyond visiting the place a few times.

Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by sgift on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @08:16AM (#16114670)
False equivalency. 'Income tax to all citizens of the EU that want to do business in Fiji' is the equivalent. And then it is the same thing: Do you want to do business in Fiji? Then you have to follow their laws.
Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by danieltillett on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @08:35AM (#16114775)
So what if Fiji just imposed the tax on EU citizens that happened to visit a website hosted in Fiji? Would that make it OK?
Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by pjc50 on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @05:30AM (#16113914)
Global jurisdiction isn't great, but this is not its first appearance and global application of US copyright and patent law has been a problem for a while.

I suspect that without global jurisdiction we would end up with data laundering jurisdictions, just as we have tax laundering ones today.

Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by danieltillett on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @07:47AM (#16114527)
The US forces it laws on other countries by getting them to change their laws. If the EU wants to convince my country to change our laws then so be it, but why do I have to abide by a law that have I have no say in writing and have no way of changing it.
Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by pjc50 on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @08:49AM (#16114854)
You could geoblock the EU?

If we think of this as import/export it suddenly becomes more obvious - when importing or exporting physical goods from the EU, you have to follow EU law even if you're a non-national with no say in it.

(The example of US extraterritorialism I have is the other way round: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Elcom_Ltd. ; as it says there, "it involved an individual being prosecuted for activities that were fully legal in the country where they occurred")

Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by wav-part on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @09:10AM (#16114976)
IP and location have no legal relationship. They barely have actual relationship. I used UK vpn on google.com but it thinks I am from HK. If google cannot get a correct ipdb what chances do others have ?

And why would I block EU ? Connection is intiated by user. So its user importing/exporting data from/to server jurisdiction. Why does not EU force their own citizens to not do business with those companies ?

Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by pjc50 on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @09:16AM (#16115006)
> Connection is intiated by user. So its user importing/exporting data from/to server jurisdiction

This line of reasoning didn't work for the poker companies: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Scheinberg

The US very definitely started the idea that it has global jurisdiction over the internet; why should it be the only such country?

Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by danieltillett on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @09:21AM (#16115046)
You do know that two wrongs do not make a right.
Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by _o_ on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @08:27AM (#16114731)
There are internationally signed agreements about punishing the companies and persons breaking other country laws. The USA has signed a lot of them with EU (for example) and it is in mutual interest to use them for both parties. Does it work? Decide for yourself: https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/eu-announces-record-27-...

And GDPR is not about the laws. It is about crooked people breaking basic human rights for their profit, every normal person should be glad that he has a straight (well almost :) ) directions how to respect and show respect for his customers. The attitude of "you cant force me" is fundamentally wrong.

One more thing, as a non european cityzen, I would be carefully monitor what the sites are doing with basic human rights (as now it will become evident) and protect myself from those who show their disrespect by not using their sites, services etc. Whole world will profit from this legislation and you can bet a lot of other countries will adopt it.

Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by danieltillett on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @08:39AM (#16114795)
Do you not see this is such a slippery slope? It is basically a "think of the children" justification. What happens when a country decides to imposes its laws on the EU and demand that data in the EU is removed or blocked that it doesn't like. The idea of the GDPR is good, it just is being implemented in a terrible way.
Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by majewsky on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @09:44AM (#16115204)
> What happens when a country decides to imposes its laws on the EU and demand that data in the EU is removed or blocked that it doesn't like.

I suspect that has happened before. The tool to resolve these disputes is called diplomacy.

Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by danieltillett on Thursday January 11, 2018 @07:08AM (#16123137)
Not much diplomacy going on with the EU, more "this is our law and we apply and we will fine you if you don’t follow".
Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by tripa on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @08:26AM (#16114720)
Reminds me of the US imposing FATCA on the entire world.
Re:GDPR consent design: how granular must adtech opt-ins be? by danieltillett on Wednesday January 10, 2018 @08:43AM (#16114816)
Yes it does and I am not happy about this either. Two wrongs do not make a right.