Their finding was that the board of directors is a difficult thing to change from the outside -- in typical corporate bylaws, the board typically approves who's on or not on the ballot. It seems likely, given the number of people on multiple boards, that there's a mutual back-scratching system in place.
And even if it's just one board a retired accountant serves on, the salary averages around $250k. It sounds like a cushy gig, and anyone who rocks the boat risks the CEO voting their shares (and the company's) to fire that director.
Other functions they serve is to protect the organization from unwanted influence. The board ultimately votes on things like, when and who to sell the company to. By weighting the board with people you know will vote a certain way, you protect against things like hostile takeovers. (This along with other rules that many companies have, like only being able to replace 2 board members per term).
In large companies, if you say own 10% of the shares, you really have a massive amount of voting power with a fraction of the shares, because all the with say 5 shares of a stock, aren't going to bother to send in their ballot when voting on board members etc. By weighting the board with insiders etc., you are helping to ensure that a rival or some other organization isn't buying shares through subsidiaries and then making a play before anyone notices.
Pretty sure that's actually a George Carlin line, from a relatively famous routine of his. Many, many clips, but here's a random one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cKUaqFzZLxU
Which explains why companies are like they are -- if the board had a fiduciary responsibility to employees first and shareholders second, maybe workers would be better off.
Oh look, it’s New York City’s MTA [1] and NYPD.
Our society puts consumers first, shareholders second and workers like fiftieth. Moving workers up seems reasonable. Skipping them ahead of shareholders or consumers has, historically, been a predictable failure.
[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metropolitan_Transportation_...
If the workers were by definition the shareholders, you wouldn't have to worry about which came first.
There are plenty of employee-owned companies. Lots. I mean, they're not all that successful, mostly, but that's hardly relevant.
Which said laws were preventing this?
OTOH, if it's a desirable social norm, then it's perhaps insufficient for law to fail to prevent it; it may be desirable for law to encourage or even require it as a precondition for the protections associated with the corporate form.
People abandoned them, first in small numbers, and then of course the left no longer wanted anything to do with them, and they started getting sabotaged by (leftist) governments ...
And of course, now half of them are referred to as those settlers. It's not the same thing of course, but because of land prices they pretty much have to be, unless they're "historical".
TLDR: most of the existing ones failed and because of that everybody hates the new ones.
Let's not go there. Let's just skip it this time around, ok ?
The board in this case should have a fiduciary responsibility to the two employees over the investors? Really?
50 people aren’t going to get together to dream up a two person shop.
I'm under the impression that in Germany, which has a highly productive economy, workers have seats on the board.
This points to a problem with due diligence and/or how board members of Fortune 500 companies are chosen. Can anyone elaborate on how this happens?
I get the impression from looking at corporate websites that many board members include former officers of the company, investors, and experienced leaders from adjacent (but not competing) industries. It sounds kind of insidery, which can lead to all kinds of problems and conflicts.