However, others in my team are very dependent on the part of Slack that is less like XMPP or IRC: the built-in persistence that lets them scroll back or search for stuff that happened while they were away. This is clearly important to some people, who also bodged together persistence for XMPP or IRC using various bots or artfully deployed console clients in screen/tmux sessions on remote servers. I always found it strange, since I expect chat to be ephemeral.
For asynchronous communication, I wish all these folks had learned how to use email or usenet properly, since I think threaded discussion on mailing lists or newsgroups was far superior to what we have now in any of these popular replacements.
I still don't quite understand whether there is a majority opinion that "rooms", "channels", or serialized message boards are somehow a better UX for the average mind, or if it's really just the distortion of rent-seeking businesses always building this form that is easier to control and monetize for some reason.
Have you had issues with your client taking a long time to negotiate a connection over Slack's XMPP gateway? I had that issue with Thunderbird's chat client and ended up having to switch over to the IRC gateway instead.
I'm not saying that an IRC experience comparable to Slack can't be achieved. I'm saying that it is so much work to do so that, for many organizations, just paying Slack a few bucks a user makes a lot more sense than sinking scarce and vastly more expensive engineer time into reinventing that particular wheel.
You mean like communicating with people?
>"relatively rare expertise"
Do you realize that IRC has been around for 30 years and that a lot of open source projects have their own IRC channel?
Plenty of people were able to use IRC in the past without IT help or training. They just installed a client like mIRC and figured it out from there.
"And yet so many people seem to prefer IRC! Why is that, do you think?"
You do realize that IRC is practically synonymous with Hacking/UNIX/FOSS culture no?
Since you don't seem to be big on providing any actual data for your claim, here are some substantial projects in the FOSS community that use IRC:
Debian, Docker, Prometheus, Django, Angular, ReactJS, FreeBSD Node.js, Mozilla, Haskell, Golang, Openstack, Erlang, Ubuntu.
Why do you think that is?
My last comment was pointing out the further absurd and unsubstantiated claim you made that "so many people seem to prefer Slack!" I think it's a pretty good illustration of "so many people" who don't prefer Slack.
Probably, but the OPs case was that they were trying to get work done.
> doing so requires so much relatively rare expertise [..] support investment [..] not cost-effective
"apt-get install ircd"?
That's Debian for, "I'm getting too old for this shit."