They're also interested in aggressively optimizing how that capacity is used, and where possible work to reduce power consumption, compute requirements, and other such things. They can alter how their software interfaces with their systems, how many requests it makes, what kind of data they return and how often.
Facebook can also power down systems that aren't needed at their current load.
Bitcoin is the opposite: The more work you put in, the more you stand to benefit. You must run your systems flat out, all the time, no breaks. Apart from more efficient mining hardware, there's no way to optimize how it mines, it's 100% utilization all the time.
> You must run your systems flat out, all the time, no breaks. Apart from more efficient mining hardware, there's no way to optimize how it mines, it's 100% utilization all the time.
Do you have the same problem with other projects such as SETI@Home and Folding@Home? How about serious gamers or people who watch a really big screen TV all night while on their phone hardly watching it?
I also think that you're making assumptions about these large tech companies by thinking they really do care about energy efficiency as an absolute top priority. While I'm sure it's a consideration, it doesn't mean it always gets the front seat. Remember these companies had time to make this a focus just like new coins are making energy efficiency a priority [2].
Crypto currencies are a new technology and need time to evolve,they will become more efficient in the near future.
[1] http://www.ibtimes.co.uk/geothermal-gold-why-bitcoin-mines-a...
[2] https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/bitcoin-alternative...
The problem with bitcoin is not that it costs energy, but that it's specifically designed to waste energy. If it was designed to help SETI and Folding, every conceivable @Home problem would probably have been solved by now.
If I turn off any mining equipment I get nothing. Zero. I'm no longer participating in any meaningful capacity. I have no "vote", I have no upside.
> How about serious gamers or people who watch a really big screen TV all night while on their phone hardly watching it?
Let's not "whatabout" this.
Trying to pass off counterfeit government currency has consequences that involve work by numerous individuals and organizations - and they don't always succeed. Proof of work in a crypto system is effectively successful all of the time, instantly.
The same applies to any form of money and fraudulent activity since the beginning of history. There is always work involved, and the effectiveness of that work has never been greater than with crypto... the consequences of which must be kept in mind - just like existing governments and systems, crypto can be used to control its participants.
Every kind of waste I can think of is a proof of some kind of work. That doesn't make it a good thing.
Is anything useful actually being done with all those calculations that are being performed? It seems the only purpose is to prove that you performed this amount of useless work, because the system is built on rewarding new bitcoins to those who waste the most work this way. It's intentionally wasteful just because the system needs something that isn't easily gamed without massive investment of equipment and energy.
Other cryptocurrencies manage to exist without being designed around wasting energy.
Facebook news feeds don't require proof of work in the same sense.
This is going to go on a tangent but I do not see why proof of work has anything to do with trust. Does your trust in me increase somehow if I give you a string whose hash ends in twenty zeros? i.e. if I subsequently told you I had found a number whose hash ended in thirty zeros but didn't give you the number, would you somehow trust me more than someone else who hadn't shown you proof of work for twenty zeros? Not really.
If anything, proof of work is not producing trust, but eliminating it (and the need for it).
I'm not saying it's efficient, but it's worked well so far.
Good explanation here: https://decentralize.today/how-does-proof-of-work-um-work-f4...
The only thing PoW attempts to do is increase the amount of capital wasted via wasting electricity and computational cycles as time progresses.
Ironically if you actually look at the protocol, miners are rewarded less and less yet have to work harder and harder. The vast majority of the supply sits with less than ~100 of the early miners who put in the least amount of work for the most amount of coins.
The proof of work is a potentially valid argument but wouldn't it be better if the work was useful in some way?
What about running Facebook, the tens of thousands of high end servers running globally just to figure out what useless junk to feed people, in a way that is detrimental to their health. I don't hear many people complaining about that side of it personally and it's a way bigger waste of electricity IMO.
The other issue is the fact that electricity is produced using fossil fuels, again, not enough protesting about that issue.