News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My Thoughts on Oracle v Google by delackner on Monday August 16, 2010 @10:32PM (#1610041)
Taking some patented "idea" from a GPL'd piece of code and re-implementing it in your own separately licensed code is not something that the GPL gives you the right to do.

Your definition of open-platform requires that the code not be covered by any patents. Anyway, the best thing that can come out of all of this is more deep-pocketed players angry with the software patent system.

Re:My Thoughts on Oracle v Google by bad_user on Tuesday August 17, 2010 @05:16AM (#1610652)
But my point isn't about what the GPL gives you the right to do.

I don't see the Linux kernel devs getting sued or suing the *BSD kernel devs, although they share ideas all the time.

Also, people scale/modify the Linux/BSD kernel to fit their needs all the time. The Java patent grant only applies if you're not building a subset/superset of Java or if you're extending OpenJDK. But these aren't enough ... some people do not want GPL.

That's what I mean by "the spirit of open-source" ... it's a collaboration effort from which everyone benefits.

And as of this recent announcement, OpenJDK is open-source only by license ... if that wasn't clear already.