> I'm sure I'm sitting on the wrong side of countless user studies that say to the contrary
This is completely off topic, but I was a UX study participant last year, it was an interesting experience. They told me to do as I usually do when surfing the web, and to verbalize my thought process.
I opened the website, and a huge nonmodal advertisement to win some $15 piece of garbage pops up. On pure instinct I click ctrl-w to close the tab, and state "what an obnoxious advertisement, I am boycotting this site".
It went downhill from there.
The sad thing is that if you were the sort of person that would click on that ad - you’d probably be gullible enough to pay for whats sitting on the end of that link. So making it obnoxious is actually giving the advertisers a useful filter. And since the gullible types are where they get their money from they optimise for that. Tech folk are just unwanted noise in their statistics.
Re:The art of the error message
by iamphilrae on Monday January 08, 2018 @07:04AM
(#16096169)
You’re still providing excellent usability test data. You’ve proved that their client’s blatant user-unfriendliness advertising strategy doesn’t work on you. Unfortunately 90% of their other test subjects probably clicked the advert so they went with it anyway.
Probably, but this just because studies include non-tech people too. For them a useless help message is ... well not useful. But at least it doesn't confuse them with tech words.
For tech people it is also useless, so I don't know who those error messages should help.
I also dislike the first person error messages. "We are sending ...", "Let me fix this" when you are clearly 'talking' to a computer.
I'm sure I'm sitting on the wrong side of countless user studies that say to the contrary, but when an exception or problem occurs, I really dislike the feeling of helplessness. Something isn't working the way it is supposed to, and often times I can only rely on myself to fix it; this is particularly relevant for companies with non-existent support services, like Google, where you're basically at the mercy of what other more adventurous and capable users are able to fix on their own. To me, tossing up a "funny" error message when there is no support channel is incredibly frustrating, because not only is there no one I can ask for assistance, I can't even do research myself because I have nothing to go on except for a caricature of the WebDevs or a Frowny-Face and the steps leading up to the problem.
Again, I'm sure I'm on the wrong side of countless studies here, but I can't figure out how this is better than at least some sort of error message.