News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by Feniks on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @09:43AM (#16061320)
The whole POINT of Echo is to always listen and direct your consumer pattern to Amazon and other approved affiliates.

To me it represents pure evil and I don't see how you could defend against it. Except for not buying into this stupid shit.

Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by mikeash on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @10:48AM (#16061917)
The whole point of my Echo is to play music and set timers and pre-heat my car in the morning and such. There’s no avenue for any consumer anything unless you allow it by using the device to shop. I don’t entirely understand why people are surprised that using an Amazon device to shop on Amazon might result in biases toward what Amazon sees as beneficial. Buying stuff with a voice assistant is antithetical to the sort of comparison shopping you need to do to have a hope of retaining some agency in what you decide to buy.
Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by pwinnski on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @11:36AM (#16062425)
That's not why Amazon sold you an echo, though.

Cortana or Siri exist without obvious nefarious purpose. Alex and Google are clearly trying to push advertising. I know which I would prefer to set timers and play music for me.

Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by addicted on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @11:45AM (#16062532)
It’s a massive failure of the tech industry that the vast majority of the world doesn’t even realize this, and therefore places very little, if any, price premium on the “does not snoop on you” feature.
Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by mnm1 on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @02:43PM (#16064354)
That's exactly why Amazon sold you an echo. To buy stuff from them. Warming up the car and playing music are just little features to get you to put it into your home--they are not the main features. Please don't tell me this isn't obvious in 2018.
Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by propogandist on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @09:52PM (#16067626)
I got a amazon firestick recently. Installed Netguard on it (free android firewall) and pevented a few installed apps from phoning home. My firestick then refused to work. I left some of the apps disabled and my device is stuck in bootloop.

Now imagine the data they're collecting from their suite of amazon devices, where you can't control the data-mining.

Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by pbhjpbhj on Thursday January 04, 2018 @11:50AM (#16071792)
It's not necessarily "to buy stuff from Amazon" I thought the direction was more meta than that - isn't it "to monitor the activities of people like you so that those activities can be influenced by people who pay for the data and/or analysis".

That could be look at what $politicalPartyAffiliates in your area consider important enough to change allegiance, so that a party that's marginal can present themselves as good for $socialGrouping in order to sway the vote. It's not necessarily just about purchasing.

It also allows analysis of other aspects of life, like, say, people who search for drug paraphenalia -- or a step further away, music that's associated [by someone] with people who take drugs -- which festivals are they going to this Summer ...

Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by mikeash on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @04:52PM (#16065583)
What determines “the main features”? The ones I listed certainly are the main ones for me. I’m sure Amazon wants me to use the ones that make them more money, but if I don’t....
Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by blacksmith_tb on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @03:10PM (#16064578)
Well, call it a good bet - I haven't ever bought anything with my Echo Dot, but the chances that I will, having it sitting there turning on the lights etc., are greater than if it wasn't sitting there.
Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by pbhjpbhj on Thursday January 04, 2018 @11:57AM (#16071854)
You've still given away commercially useful information though that Amazon can trade - for example, the companies you're using for your lights and any other automation hardware. If that's associated with your Amazon account then companies can track you through the payment details and use that to target you with advertising in that podcast you paid for, or in the advert in your coffee company email you get when they wish you Happy New Year, or whatever.

That targetted selling may have no direct effect through the Echo itself, but the potential is there to increase the influence on you in other channels.

There may be other info, we have 3 kids who use our FireTV: I'd imagine they can estimate the child's age & sex and give targetted advertising in emails/web pages to companies selling toys for those ages. Based on the apps (whatever they call them, skills?), they can probably target that much better.

Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by mikeash on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @11:46AM (#16062552)
Does it matter why they sold it to me if I don't use it that way?
Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by walterbell on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @11:52AM (#16062610)
Yes, because it will likely evolve in ways not optimized for you, vs supporting a product that caters to your use case. Many products co-evolve with users, as the product modifies daily workflows. If you are not the target user, the product can evolve based on requirements that are adversarial to you.
Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by mikeash on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @11:56AM (#16062635)
For $30, if I get a year or two of use out of it before Amazon evolves away my use cases, it was still nice to have while it lasted.
Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by rhizome on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @01:21PM (#16063498)
And then what, throw it in the trash like the non-biodegradable toxic-metals container that it is?
Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by mikeash on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @01:50PM (#16063828)
Take it to the county’s electronics recycling location. I doubt it’ll become useless so quickly though.
Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by coldtea on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @02:38PM (#16064297)
Yes, because its overall societal effect and role is more important that how some specific people use it if it's unrepresentative.
Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by pbhjpbhj on Thursday January 04, 2018 @11:44AM (#16071725)
>Cortana or Siri exist without obvious nefarious purpose. //

It's not nefarious, but what happens if you ask a question like "open a website where I can buy music" or "find me a powerful new computer", or whatever. Is there no bias in Cortana/Siri towards MS/Apple? How about if you ask "is Siri or Cortana a better voice assistant?" ...

Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by reaperducer on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @03:48PM (#16064960)
Alexa: "Your car does not seem to want to start this morning. Would you like me to order you an Uber [instead of a Lyft] and e-mail you brochures for the newest Plymouths?"

The fact that you interact with it each morning is more powerful than any print, broadcast, or web ad Amazon can buy. They're gotten into your brain. Even if you never see the device (which is now a visual billboard in your home), when you think about it, you're thinking about Amazon. You've already been commoditized and you don't even realize it.

Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by mikeash on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @04:00PM (#16065085)
How is that different from any other product I use regularly?
Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by acct1771 on Thursday January 04, 2018 @03:49AM (#16068860)
Your shoes won't eventually be pushed an OTA update that tells you to buy the same brand of socks....?

Do you really not see the inherent problems with these devices, or is the remote start just that nice? =D

Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by mikeash on Thursday January 04, 2018 @11:22AM (#16071523)
I really don't see the problems. It looks to me that people have an emotional dislike of these devices, and then try to rationalize arguments against them.

For example, by far the most common argument against these devices is that they could be spying on you by listening to your conversations 24/7. This is true, they could be. However, it's also true of cell phones, which 99% of the complainers have had near them 24/7 for the past 10 or 20 years. If you think the Echo is a terrible device because it could spy on you but you keep a cell phone in your pocket all day, you're trying to justify a negative emotional response to the Echo, not rationally analyzing the situation.

The comment I replied to above, by reaperducer, attempts to argue that the Echo is implicitly commoditizing me every day because I interact with it. This may be true, but does that also mean I'm being commoditized by Whirlpool and Moen and Philips and Tesla and Trader Joe's? If yes, then what does that even mean, and how am I meant to avoid it?

You then jump in with a vague hypothetical about a future update making the device start trying to sell me socks. I'm pretty sure Amazon isn't going to start putting ads in with my music or weather reports. If they do, I'll stop using the device. It only cost me $30. I've spent far more on devices that now sit on a shelf unused. That's just the nature of consumer electronics.

If you want to convince me that these devices are inherently bad or have massive inherent problems, it's really simple. All you have to do is tell me what problem they cause me that could be eliminated by getting rid of the device. So far, everyone who's attempted to do this has either stated a problem that wouldn't be eliminated (e.g. the spying potential or the daily interaction getting the brand into my brain) or a problem I don't suffer (e.g. getting ads).

Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by criddell on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @02:36PM (#16064288)
Pure evil? Really? I think you are being a little hyperbolic.

I have an Echo and it is helping Amazon get better at selling me stuff. When I try to list the probable or even possible harms from this, I can't come up with a lot.

Compare that to something like driving my car. 100 people every day are killed in their car. Even so, I still drive because the expected utility of getting to point B is much greater than the expected harm from doing so.

Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by 45h34jh53k4j on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @02:55PM (#16064459)
the echo is pure evil -- in the same way the 1984 Telescreen is evil. It exists to control, manipulate and spy on you. If you dont see this, I am truly sorry my friend, but it is too late.
Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by criddell on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @03:24PM (#16064708)
Assuming that you aren't just suffering from paranoid delusions, care to share the likely harms from me using an Echo?

I use a car and the worst case scenario is death or permanent disability, right? People die in their cars every day.

So what's the worst case scenario for using an Echo? How many people a day does that happen to?

Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by sgarman on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @04:17PM (#16065242)
Being locked in a room for your entire life sure is safer then driving a car so that can't be bad for you right? I think ops point is it's dangerous to your mind and lively hood as well as society as a whole - not to your physical body like your car example.
Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by criddell on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @04:54PM (#16065604)
But the potential harm from driving is very clear. The worst case scenario hits more than 30,000 people every year in the US. Smart people can calculate a dollar cost to that damage.

What's the worst case scenario from having an Echo? How many people does it affect each year? What's the dollar cost of that damage?

Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by ThrowawaysOnly on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @09:19PM (#16067458)
I personally am not a fan of these types of devices, but I am also not as doom and gloom about them as GP.

IMO, it isn't an imminent threat. It's not going to kill you. It's not going to cause you any physical harm. It's the slow erosion of privacy which is a detriment to everyone.

I'm going to avoid the cliche Orwellian arguments and the normalizing surveillance arguments. Both of these have been addressed ad nauseaum. I'm going to go a different route and see if it resonates with you at all.

It is incredibly easy for humans to be manipulated. This only gets easier as we have treasure troves of data about individuals. Amazon has many of the smartest people in the world working to manipulate you to do things in their best interest. Sometimes their interests lineup with your best interests and things are great. Other times, their interests will be negative to your life.

It is in their best interest for you to not be content with what you have. It probably is your best interest to be content with what you have. It's not wrong to want things, but things will never fulfill you.

I'm not saying capitalism is evil, Amazon is bad, or that we aren't living in one of the best times in human history. I am saying that putting a marketing device (which is also a privacy concern) in my home is not something I am interested in. Especially when I can do the 90% with my phone in 5 thumb presses.

Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by criddell on Thursday January 04, 2018 @07:03AM (#16069697)
All of that I can agree with. However, what gets left out of the equation is that the devices do provide some utility. All I'm really saying is that calling it pure evil is as silly as saying the device has no downsides.

I like the driving analogy because even though the worst case scenario is about as bad as it gets, it's not all that likely. I think people, even here, have a hard time separating possibility and probability.

A connected speaker has real and immediate benefits for some people. People that use it to buy stuff (I do all the time) aren't going to see ads for associated products like website shoppers do. Frankly, if the Echo scares you, https://amazon.com should scare you even more. I bet they collect a lot more data in a 10 minute browsing session than they do with months of Echo use.

Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by jenscow on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @08:01PM (#16067071)
It might incorrectly tell you the weather is hot, so you walk out with just a t-shirt, then freeze to death.
Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by deeth_starr_v on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @10:28AM (#16061729)
>> "always listen"

This is somewhat correct but misleading. It's always listening for the "wake word" -- alexa or echo -- and then it processes your request. But it's not sending all conversations up to amazon. Just your alexa requests.

Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by ocdtrekkie on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @11:14AM (#16062190)
I feel like statements like this miss the point. Most of us are fully aware of this. But that doesn't change that the device is deciding when to send audio or not... something they can change at any time, presumably even without telling customers.
Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by albertzeyer on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @11:31AM (#16062366)
Just like any other device, such as your phone, or computer, maybe also TV, etc.
Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by Retric on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @02:44PM (#16064370)
My TV has no way to revive updates. So, normally you do have some control.

However, this is a device that requires internet to function and is managed by them giving you zero control beyond unplugging it.

Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by viridian on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @01:06PM (#16063337)
How can my phone have updates pushed to it without my consent? Does LineageOS have some sort of backdoor that you know of?
Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by ocdtrekkie on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @04:42PM (#16065483)
Do you have Google Play Services on your LineageOS device? It's amazing what Google can push via that these days. ;)

As a note, for non-rooted users, it's common for Android vendors to push mandatory updates. Both my last Android phone and tablet before I left the platform were pending 'mandatory' updates where I had to kill a process after booting to prevent them from executing.

Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by cantrip on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @10:42AM (#16061874)
Not yet at least. Once attitudes towards privacy change further towards continual surveillance they'll be the first to flip the switch and turn it on.
Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by rando444 on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @10:51AM (#16061953)
Well currently they'd have to completely rebuild the hardware.

This person gave a very good explanation here:

https://np.reddit.com/r/Showerthoughts/comments/7m91u9/if_go...

Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by pavlov on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @11:26AM (#16062308)
These devices will get replaced every few years anyway. Having to send out new hardware to customers is absolutely no problem for Amazon.
Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by woolvalley on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @02:00PM (#16063936)
Then by that point privacy as a selling point apple will have the homepod for sale?

I have a bunch, and you only really use them for about 5 things, with the most useful thing being music.

Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by deeth_starr_v on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @11:29AM (#16062336)
I've used the microphone hardware that Echo uses and it doesn't stream audio until the wake word is received.
Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by emodendroket on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @10:54AM (#16061982)
Might be pretty expensive to do that.
Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by mediocrejoker on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @11:46AM (#16062548)
Anecdotal but I have had an echo dot for only about 2 weeks and already it has "woken" when nobody was talking to it. It's very disconcerting, as you don't realize that it's listening as it parses some conversation that was never meant for it and then suddenly interjects with some non-sequitur.

Once was when an actual person was speaking and another time was when the TV show 'The Sopranos' was playing in the room. In the latter case, I rewound the show several times and it triggered on the same phrase multiple times (and the character was not saying anything that sounded like Alexa, at least to me)

Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by Willamin on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @01:39PM (#16063698)
Any chance you remember what the phrase was? or the episode?
Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by Feniks on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @01:24PM (#16063535)
Allow me a little prediction: in the future there will be a push to have AI assistants listen to and report things like domestic disturbances.
Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by reaperducer on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @03:55PM (#16065020)
It's for your own good, citizen. Don't you feel safer now?

Think of the children!

Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by blacksmith_tb on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @03:12PM (#16064606)
Then they'd better also require that they not have mute switches like the Echo and gHome do...
Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by Feniks on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @04:34PM (#16065416)
Oh don't worry those of us who don't have an Echo will get on a special watchlist. You'll give up your freedom soon enough if you can't get child custody or keep getting turned down at job interviews.
Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by tyfon on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @10:02AM (#16061475)
I agree, the correct defense for this (and many other things) is to not buy it.

It should however come with a severe warning about what it is doing in a way that my mother would understand. Otherwise she would just see it as a nice thing to tell her what to do.

Re:Yes, Amazon Echo Is an Ad Machine by flukus on Wednesday January 03, 2018 @09:30PM (#16067507)
It should at least tell you that your voice input is being sent to amazon for processing, that's not immediately obvious and many would probably assume it's only required for certain functions.