News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook Is Not Really That Special by geeky on Thursday April 10, 2008 @10:04PM (#160612)
I'd say that for most people on facebook, it's easier to replace google than to replace facebook. You can always use Yahoo or MSN for search, they might not be as good, but they're good enough. You can use Yahoo maps or Live Earth. And you can use Yahoo email, which is getting really good recently. But it's hard to leave facebook unless all your friends leave with you at the same time to a new social network.
Re:Facebook Is Not Really That Special by mattmaroon on Thursday April 10, 2008 @11:56PM (#160698)
Not to mention that in this country, it's still not even the most popular social network. And even if it becomes that, it did so only because it replaced MySpace. I don't see what is any more irreplaceable about Facebook than MySpace.
Re:Facebook Is Not Really That Special by blader on Friday April 11, 2008 @12:57AM (#160743)
Facebook is different from MySpace for exactly the use case of keeping up with your friends. Facebook is the only social network so far that rigorously enforces real names, identities and relationships through both social design and brute force. MySpace has degenerated in to a social game to rack up more points in the form of 'friends'. They are completely different, which is why Facebook is catching up to MySpace so quickly and MySpace is sinking.
Re:Facebook Is Not Really That Special by yters on Friday April 11, 2008 @09:01PM (#161548)
Right, this is the "aha" one of the parents mentioned. The major problem with the internet is the lack of accountability, accountability is necessary to form trust, and trust is necessary to form good social networks.
Re:Facebook Is Not Really That Special by Mistone on Friday April 11, 2008 @02:07AM (#160801)
v important: "real names, identities and relationships"
Re:Facebook Is Not Really That Special by geeky on Friday April 11, 2008 @01:42AM (#160785)
> I don't see what is any more irreplaceable about Facebook than MySpace.

That's exactly it. You're probably not seeing how they're different. When you used Google you saw that it's different from Yahoo, but I'm sure many people didn't see the difference. After all, they're both search engines. Same here: although they're both social networks, Facebook is very different from MySpace. When I used Facebook the first time, I got that Aha moment you talked about.

Re:Facebook Is Not Really That Special by volida on Friday April 11, 2008 @05:48AM (#160898)
still you don't answer if is irreplaceable and why
Re:Facebook Is Not Really That Special by geeky on Friday April 11, 2008 @10:32PM (#161587)
I thought I did in the first comment. It's hard to get all your friends to move with you at the same time to a new social network. Not that it can't happen, everything is replacable. It's just much harder than replacing google, because with Google I can switch on my own.
Re:Facebook Is Not Really That Special by volida on Thursday April 10, 2008 @10:11PM (#160626)
that's an interesting perspective, but I don't think is really valid. People will easily/hardly change their default social network but really easier than switching from Google which is a point of reference to those who are used to it. Even if you tried to switch from Google, how many are the alternatives? Like you said only two. And whenever I tried them they never make me stick to them.

And this is easier to happen because more people can build a community than a search engine.

Re:Facebook Is Not Really That Special by jonathan on Friday April 11, 2008 @12:05PM (#161094)
I disagree. As months go by, it's going to be even harder for anyone to come up with a social network as big as FB. Why ? FB's critical mass! As it's been said, all that differentiates Facebook for an individual user is the presence of that users friend’s on Facebook — which forces them to use Facebook to connect with them. And this is precisely why FB is not a founding member of the OpenSocial foundation. Facebook is threatened by OpenSocial’s ultimate aim of connecting user profiles and enabling users to easily manage and port their data across any social network.