My target was inappropriate. The snark should have been directed at the author of the submarine PR advertisement, not the marketing executive. I believe articles like this, which are barely more than corporate press releases, are more damaging to the community than the loose language I employed.
The real problem with this piece is that it doesn’t say anything interesting about the successful CSR marketing campaign, and instead positions it as:
1) Chase REALLY listens to its customers! Isn’t that great? Especially you millennials!
2) Look at these CRAZY deals! What a bargain! You’re nuts not to get in on this!
This piece is thus uninteresting, and deserves the snark. The exec mentioned within it does not. (At least not yet — let’s see what happens with churn over the next 5 years).
The trouble with what you've said here is that even if you're right about the article, it's easy to make your points without doing damage to HN. It simply takes a will to do it and a willingness to wait a little, to make it past the reflexive phase where the snark enzymes kick in.
That aside, there's another problem with your argument: if it's right, it's too right, because the same observation applies to nearly all media pieces. This sucks, but it is a cost of doing business on the internet (probably literally). If we focus on these annoyances, we only deprive ourselves of curious discussion. I'd say the guideline to apply here is the following one, translated to the article level:
Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize.
In other words, please respond to the most interesting things in an article, not less interesting things that are easier to criticize. If there are no interesting things, that's different, but then you should flag the submission.
I can't see what is different about this card, so I think their complaint stands. This looks like a puff piece.
Even when an article is a puff piece, though, that doesn't make damaging this community ok.
Meanwhile, for the CSR, travel (for both the category bonus and the credit) is travel. There are very few restrictions. It offers the same Global Entry credit, the same Priority Pass membership, the same primary rental car insurance, and the same rental car benefits. It also offers things like trip delay insurance that the AmEx does not. Additionally, it offers United as a transfer partner and United still has the most flights out of my airport. If one were based out of a Delta hub, the math changes since the AmEx has delta as a transfer partner and offers Delta Lounge access.
tldr: The restrictions on the AmEx make it hard to use and justify the annual fee vs a no AF card like Citi Double Cash. The CSR's lack of restrictions make it easy to get more value than the AF.
It gets tiring however, and that kind of attitude gets you edged out of many companies - rightfully so!
Certainly it is a major concern, one we spend a lot of time on. But every public internet community of any size is at least this bad, no? and there are also many good qualities here. Let's not make the mistake of failing to take care of what we have because of its bad qualities.
The odds are that a hasty internet dismissal is missing something, and even if it isn't, it damages the conversation culture to snark this way. The kind of comment we want on HN comes from reflection, not reflex.