Maybe the best economic option is to build a huge ship, that could be a captured asteroid, and place it in an permanent elliptic orbit near Earth's orbit in its perihelion and near Mars' orbit in its aphelion.
If you get to Mars in 3 months versus 9 months, your radiation dose during transit is just a third. And that also means you may be able to reuse the ship every synod (26 months) instead of every 2 synods.
That's the plan for SpaceX's BFR/ITS.
It seems more like a trade-off. A bulkier slower ship could offer better protection even for longer trips. Also you only need to power an elliptic orbiter once.
Cyclers need periodic re-alignment and are so slow that you'd need multiples in order to have one for each window. Also, you still have to catch up to one. Overall, not a fantastic trade.
Eventually we'll have faster transits, and Aldrin Cyclers, and the problem will become even more minute.
(from this paper: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/252405981_OLTARIS_A... )
What you want is low atomic mass elements for galactic cosmic rays. Hydrogen is best, so you want fuel or plastic (polyethylene/polypropylene is the best plastic for radiation shielding). Water is also pretty good. As a zeroth order estimate, you look at the average atomic mass of the material to determine how well it shields galactic cosmic rays. So composites work better than aluminum.