News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GNU/Linux local username triggers Steam VAC ban by dang on Tuesday January 02, 2018 @11:03AM (#16052618)
I wasn't talking about that and am not taking any kind of side. If you think there's abuse going on, emailing [email protected] is the thing to do, and then we can take a closer look.

My point is the orthogonal one that it's incongruent to snarkily diss HN when you're as much a part of the community as anyone else is. It makes no more sense to say "HN got trolled" than "HN debunked getting trolled". People don't do this to be informative, but rather to superciliously position themselves above others. That degrades the spirit of the community here, which is already so fragile. That's why I reply to such comments the way I did.

Re:GNU/Linux local username triggers Steam VAC ban by hitekker on Tuesday January 02, 2018 @12:14PM (#16053298)
We may each be a part of HN but that doesn't mean we can't criticize what we perceive to be the gestalt of HN.

It's like saying "<Insert Community / Country / Organization Name>, goddammit!"

I personally don't mean that I'm better than everyone in said community, but that I'm disappointed with the prevailing sentiment, and so feel the need to signal my separation on the issue.

It's shorthand "I don't identify with <Community> on <Issue X>".

People do indeed abuse this rhetoric to feel superior to others, e.g., "Reddit is a hivemind!". But on issues where the community clearly falls prey to its biases, a little snark now should remind us to avoid those collective pitfalls in the future.