News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by jlgosse on Sunday August 15, 2010 @12:13AM (#1604578)
I mostly agree with Phil, but I still wouldn't call Microsoft an underdog. I mean, I recently fell in love with OSX, but my opinion still stands that Windows 7 is f'ing amazing, and still outsells (or is at least on more machines than) OSX by an IMMENSELY large proportion.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by sjs on Sunday August 15, 2010 @02:10AM (#1604691)
There are more than a few of us who don't consider a machine suitable for real work unless it ships with a derivative of the bourne shell and makes it easy to run the same software we use on our servers.

My process to get up and running on a new machine is to change the keyboard layout to dvorak and run `wget -qO - bit.ly/newbox | sh`. On Windows I have to do everything in a Linux VM anyway, because I hate messing around with cygwin, coLinux, etc.

I know a lot of people will disagree with this, but to me a Windows box is a glorified Xbox with a web browser. Sure people work with them but unless you're using VS I don't really see the point of using Windows for development.

edit: I know I'm not representative of the larger population but I think there are more people switching away from Windows than to it these days.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by mambodog on Sunday August 15, 2010 @06:40AM (#1604912)
Thing is, for a lot of people, a computer for 'work' purely means one on which they have first class Office (docx, xlsx, pptx) compatibility at the lowest possible price. Even Office:Mac is pricey, and not 100% identical (and no MS Access).
Re:Welcome to the new decade by Ben65 on Sunday August 15, 2010 @06:50AM (#1604920)
I know this probably isn't for most people, but I've gone to emacs' org mode for creating documents and spreadsheets. The cost is nothing, it's highly functional, and can be exported to TEX or html if you want to make it pretty.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by semanticist on Sunday August 15, 2010 @08:02AM (#1604983)
emacs isn't suitable for almost all computer users.

Try to imagine telling a non-hacker manager that all their spreadsheet work needs to be done in a command-line text editor/kitchen sink emulator.

It's always easy to forget just how much of a minority hackers actually are - there's far far more computer users out there who aren't hackers than are. Orders of magnitude more.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by fxj on Sunday August 15, 2010 @12:40PM (#1605376)
there was a time when lotus 123 was the de-facto spreadsheet and excel was a pale buggy program.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by semanticist on Sunday August 15, 2010 @03:47PM (#1605761)
That's true, but I don't see the computer accessibility evolution going Lotus 123 -> Microsoft Excel -> emacs org mode.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by listic on Sunday August 15, 2010 @09:20AM (#1605085)
Many people need to also read Office documents, not just write them. If you cannot sign or edit a crucial contract for your company because you are using some Open Source word processor (and all of your partners use MS Word) your decision to move from MS suddenly starts to look very, very stupid.

Also, I heard from a writer that Microsoft Office is superior to any word processor (a.k.a computer program you use to write a novel) to the point that he writes novels in Microsoft Word under Wine.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by lsc on Monday August 16, 2010 @05:36AM (#1607283)
>Also, I heard from a writer that Microsoft Office is superior to any word processor (a.k.a computer program you use to write a novel) to the point that he writes novels in Microsoft Word under Wine.

published author here[1] who was talked into using OpenOffice to write a book. It was... pretty bad, worse, even than ms office, which (and yes, I tried) is pretty bad when you start passing back and fourth a monstrosity with a bunch of marked changes. But even with the little incompatibilities fixed, god damn, word processors were just not meant to deal with something that big.

You will find few people writing their second book using a word processor. Word processors are pretty great for short documents that need to be made to look nice quickly, and that have limited collaboration. (yes, modern word processors have really basic revision control functionality, but it sucks compared to using a revision control system.) But yeah, next time? some sort of TeX derivative, or I do the book in text and the publisher can do formatting after it's done.

[1]http://nostarch.com/xen.htm

Re:Welcome to the new decade by swombat on Sunday August 15, 2010 @12:03PM (#1605313)
Also, I heard from a writer that Microsoft Office is superior to any word processor (a.k.a computer program you use to write a novel) to the point that he writes novels in Microsoft Word under Wine.

That's insane. Word is a horrible writing environment. It's a passable document editing environment, but to write novels or stories there are a number of infinitely better tools, such as Scrivener or Writeroom (for mac - but there are equivalents on Winblows) on the minimalist side, or some others whose names escape me right now on the "let's have lots of tools to help someone write a novel" side.

Word sucks for writing.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by archangel_one on Sunday August 15, 2010 @05:53PM (#1606065)
I seem to recall hearing that George R.R. Martin writes in Wordstar on DOS. That doesn't make it the best word processor though - you can probably find one fan of nearly any piece of software.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by lsc on Monday August 16, 2010 @10:15PM (#1610011)
'joe' on *NIX is the tool you want if you like the wordstar keybindings. It was my $EDITOR for a long time because I was used to the wordstar key bindings as used in turbo pascal 3.0. I talk a lot of shit about how useless school was... but I learned a lot in that pascal class in high school.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by lsc on Monday August 16, 2010 @05:39AM (#1607293)
'joe' on *NIX is the tool you want if you like the wordstar keybindings. It was my $EDITOR for a long time because I was used to the wordstar key bindings as used in turbo pascal 3.0. I talk a lot of shit about how useless school was... but I learned a lot in that pascal class in high school.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by jmcnevin on Sunday August 15, 2010 @03:41PM (#1605751)
Oh really? I heard from a writer that emacs is the best word processor.

http://artlung.com/smorgasborg/C_R_Y_P_T_O_N_O_M_I_C_O_N.sht...

Re:Welcome to the new decade by zaphar on Monday August 16, 2010 @11:58AM (#1608153)
Thats odd because from a couple of friends in the publishing industry They prefer all the manuscripts to be plain text. The first step after they receive the manuscript is to remove all formatting so they can get it into their typesetting program with the least effort.

Why an author would prefer word or even open office over notepad is beyond me. Word count maybe? It gives almost no benefit and requires extra work when it's time to hand off the manuscript to the publisher.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by listic on Thursday August 19, 2010 @03:21AM (#1616748)
Word count, definitely; maybe other features like that? Open Office is sluggish.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by Splines on Tuesday August 17, 2010 @01:22PM (#1611779)
The cost isn't nothing - learning emacs and org-mode, while rewarding, isn't trivial.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by nkassis on Sunday August 15, 2010 @03:28AM (#1604758)
I pretty much just install emacs and I'm ready to go on any unix box(Until I get to emacs I can use Vi, useful for things like Arch linux)
Re:Welcome to the new decade by kenjackson on Sunday August 15, 2010 @01:05PM (#1605429)
Windows and Mac worldwide marketshare is basically flat over the past year. You'd think that everyone is switching to MacOS reading HN. But you'd think that Linux had taken over for the past 10 years reading Slashdot. Get out of the bubble and see the world.

See http://arstechnica.com/microsoft/news/2010/08/windows-7-over...

Re:Welcome to the new decade by sjs on Monday August 16, 2010 @01:47AM (#1606969)
Outside of our world of geekery I see the odd person switching to a Mac. Even more rarely I see people switch to Linux, but it happens.

What I don't see are people switching from Linux or Macs to Windows. Geek or otherwise. Not one.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by kenjackson on Monday August 16, 2010 @03:05AM (#1607087)
I'm in the world of geekery and I switched from Linux to PC (coming from Amiga prior to that).

I've met a good number of people who have gone from PC to Mac and back to PC. Relatively few, if any, Mac to PC converts who have Mac users for 10+ years.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by jodrellblank on Sunday August 15, 2010 @04:15PM (#1605828)
What about people who are targeting Windows desktops?
Re:Welcome to the new decade by sjs on Monday August 16, 2010 @01:48AM (#1606971)
I figured that anyone doing Windows dev is using VS. Consider my VS comment to include everyone who deploys on Windows.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by houseabsolute on Sunday August 15, 2010 @12:26AM (#1604595)
And apple can't even remotely be called a monopoly, unless you are referring to their monopoly on products sold by apple.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by fxj on Sunday August 15, 2010 @12:38PM (#1605374)
apple has the monopoly on iphones. and every geek wants an iphone. so apple has a monopoly in the geek world.

microsoft has the monopoly on windows. and every pc in the world is sold with windows.this is what i call an effective monopoly. add that to the wannabe bing monopoly and you know why microsoft is not an underdog at all!

Re:Welcome to the new decade by houseabsolute on Sunday August 15, 2010 @03:39PM (#1605747)
Just selling a single popular product in a sector does not make you a monopoly. Brushing up on the definition of the term might help you understand.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by usaar333 on Sunday August 15, 2010 @06:30PM (#1606136)
Every geek? I'm a geek and don't own/want any Apple product. There are many geeks out there like me - a minority for sure - but enough that Apple lacks a monopoly over geeks.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by cookiecaper on Sunday August 15, 2010 @12:52PM (#1605394)
I don't want an iPhone or any other Apple product really. I may reluctantly update my MacBook Pro in a few years just to have something not-slow that can run OS X natively and properly, but I don't really _want_ to do that, just feel like it's a smart investment so that when a client asks if I can use some Mac-only software, I can reasonably and compatibly do so. That is the only Apple product I want. iPhones are immensely overrated and Android is a far superior platform for hackers.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by fxj on Sunday August 15, 2010 @01:26PM (#1605482)
yes you are totally right. but why is apple selling so many iphones? yes android is catching up (and for me it is a no-brainer that android is the superior platform) but still the iphone4 is the holy grail in the press. there was a time when i really wanted a macbook because it was the better os (wrt linux, not windows) but apple lost its credibility by no longer fixing bugs and selling them as features now. (think about the finder or the shitty keyboard).
Re:Welcome to the new decade by hasenj on Sunday August 15, 2010 @05:58AM (#1604876)
Apple is a monopoly in the sense that I can't drag and drop mp3 files into my iphone.

They impose strict control on how you can use your device.

They control the app store.

and they seem to moving towards more control; not less.

I was considering getting a Mac at the beginning of this year. I got an iPhone, and decided never to buy any iThing ever again.

I like good design and visual appeal, but not to the point of sacrificing substance for form.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by sokoloff on Sunday August 15, 2010 @08:35AM (#1605020)
I got an iPhone, and decided never to buy any iThing ever again.

So, I assume that you'll be buying competing devices from other vendors for your future computing, mobile phone and portable media consumption needs?

If you answered yes, THAT is what makes Apple a non-monopoly.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by ra88it on Sunday August 15, 2010 @07:19AM (#1604938)
> Apple is a monopoly in the sense that I can't drag and drop mp3 files into my iphone.

Having a hard time with this one. Can you please explain how this makes Apple a monopoly?

Re:Welcome to the new decade by Gibbon on Sunday August 15, 2010 @11:10AM (#1605236)
I've got an alias in my downloads folder that auto adds mp3s to iTunes and iTunes auto-syncs to my ipod when I plug it in.

I don't even have to think about dragging and dropping anything.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by raganwald on Sunday August 15, 2010 @07:55AM (#1604979)
This is like saying that Kim Il Jong is a monopoly on the World Stage. If you want hyperbole, Apple is a Dictator ruling mercilessly over its subjects. But not a monopoly.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by hasenj on Sunday August 15, 2010 @05:55PM (#1606070)
hm I think I can't edit my posts?

I suppose monopoly in English only refers to market control (my bad).

In certain other languages, the word for monopoly is the same word for "complete control".

I was assuming the word monopoly in English has evolved to capture that meaning as well -.-

All Apple devices are closed and restricted, it is as if when you buy an iPhone, you don't own it; you're merely getting permission (from Apple) to use it.

Five years ago, one would've imagined that only Microsoft can do something as evil as that.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by bbuffone on Sunday August 15, 2010 @07:37AM (#1604956)
I completely agree, Windows 7 is amazing. After being forced to use OSX for the last two months, I can't wait to get back. The windowing system is better in Windows 7, multi-monitor is easier (Windows have their own menus), task bar works better, battery life is better, look and feel is better.

I will throw in Zune as the best portable media player as well. After having an iphone and using itunes. Zune is far better then the lastest generation ipods. Super slick and easy ui, better integrated store, also the zune desktop app is better. Subscription service is definitely the way to go. I pay my $13 a month music tax and can have any song I want, I haven't listened to this much music ever.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by illumin8 on Sunday August 15, 2010 @08:16AM (#1604998)
Are you kidding me? The single biggest fault with the Windows UI is that any event can pop up and take focus from the current task. Do you know how many times I've accidentally rebooted a computer during a critical task because Windows popped up and told me updates were installed and Windows needed to restart just as I hit enter?

This is just horrible, horrible UI design. A system notification or request to reboot should NEVER, EVER take focus. This is one of the many way that Windows punishes users every day.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by matrix on Sunday August 15, 2010 @10:24AM (#1605173)
To me, the single biggest fault -- one that very nearly made me just get up and go the the nearest Apple store, right then and there -- is the fact that Windows STILL will force a reboot of your machine while unattended (I did figure out how to turn that off, but your average user would not be able to do it). Whoever decided to make it default to forcing a reboot is unforgivably stupid.

Not to mention: why is it, that in 2010, we have an OS that still requires reboots at least 3 times a week?

Re:Welcome to the new decade by usaar333 on Sunday August 15, 2010 @06:35PM (#1606147)
The other design flaw is why it needs to reboot on every system update.

One of the things that I love about Linux is what you only need to reboot to use a new kernel. 95+% of system updates will activate without reboot.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by kenjackson on Sunday August 15, 2010 @01:11PM (#1605445)
Why do you reboot three times a week? What are you doing? I've never seen anyone have that problem.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by what on Sunday August 15, 2010 @01:20PM (#1605464)
I would guess automatic updates are on and they require a reboot?
Re:Welcome to the new decade by kenjackson on Sunday August 15, 2010 @01:30PM (#1605491)
I don't think so. I have auto updates and I don't get three updates per week.

I _believe_ the only updates that will automatically reboot are critical updates.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by kenjackson on Monday August 16, 2010 @03:04AM (#1607085)
I've verified that this should only happen with critical updates. But you can stop auto-reboots on automatic update with a registry setting. See: http://www.winsupersite.com/win7/totw/au.asp
Re:Welcome to the new decade by bbuffone on Sunday August 15, 2010 @09:32AM (#1605108)
You list one thing that happens to you that doesn't make the OS or windowing bad.

OSX has the following UI issues:

Scrollbars are hard to use

Window Max & Min buttons randomly work depending on the application

file dialog can't do any of the things the window file can do (Create folders, manage files)

Finders is pretty basic

I won't mention right clicking

accelerator keys are not as easy

*System monitor is pretty non-helpful most times

OSX shell is good, Windows 7 is the far better operating system. The hardware is also better but microsoft can force people to build awesome hardware

Re:Welcome to the new decade by apgwoz on Sunday August 15, 2010 @10:40AM (#1605199)
> Scrollbars are hard to use

I can't tell you the last time I used a scrollbar at all. Wheels are a far better scrollbar interface, and come on 99% of new mice. Oh, and 2 finger scrolling on a touchpad is even better.

> file dialog can't do any of the things the window file can do (Create folders, manage files)

It can create folders, and it can also be configured (by the software) to have more functionality. I'd think that allowing all file management functionality from a "Save as..." dialog is a bad idea. New Folder and navigation should be all that's required. You shouldn't be able to decide to cleanup "My Documents" when your main goal is to save a file.

> I won't mention right clicking

I will. Right clicking is confusing in Windows because many a software hides some functionality in the Right-click context menu, but it never shows up in the "File Edit View" main menus. By eliminating right click on the Mac for novice users, and insisting in the HCI Guidelines that all functionality be accessible from the Main Menu, novice users can more easily discover the functionality they're looking for.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by Glide on Sunday August 15, 2010 @11:29AM (#1605263)
As both a windows and mac user I have to agree with all of your points but the last one is probably the most important.

The software ecosystem on os x is much nicer overall because of the guidelines that apple publishes. Most OS X applications look and feel in a similar way. It's also why iOS apps tend to behave the same way as well.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by nileshk on Sunday August 15, 2010 @01:07PM (#1605433)
> Window Max & Min buttons randomly work depending on the application

In OS X I rarely use these buttons. "Minimize" is very rarely useful. If I want to get an app out of the way I use Hide (CMD-H). Hide Others (CMD-Option-H) is also useful for making the current app the only one visible.

Minimize is only useful to me when I want to get a window out of the way within an application (but not get the application out of the way). For example, lets say I had multiple Terminal windows open, and there was one that I knew I wasn't going to use for a while, and I didn't want it to show up when I cycle through windows when I hit CMD-`, then I would hit CMD-M to minimize. (This is hypothetical, though, I don't use Terminal that way.)

I admit the "Zoom" button (what you expect to be Maximize, but isn't) is rather inconsistent due to apps having different opinions on its usage (iTunes being one of the worst). If you want Windows-style maximize, you can use something like shiftit ( http://code.google.com/p/shiftit/ ) which gives you a keyboard shortcut for it. It also gives you Windows 7 style tiling and more tiling features. I have a fork of this open source project where I'm experimenting with being able to resize windows to percentages of the screen size using keyboard shortcuts: http://github.com/nileshk/shiftit

Also, checkout this company's non-free products: http://irradiatedsoftware.com/

Going back to your previous post, I think Windows 7's taskbar misses the point (assuming it's trying to copy OS X). What is nice in OS X is the whole app switching model. In OS X, when you click on an app in the dock, you are switch to that app bringing up all the app's non-minimized windows, whereas in Windows you are always switching to a specific window but not to the app as a whole.

While I use OS X's dock, I use QuickSilver to switch to apps even more, which gives me a more precise keyboard-based way of navigating to the app that I want, where I can literally switch to an app that I want without looking at the screen (more that I don't have to study the screen in this process, which makes it faster for me). Spotlight can be used similarly, though it doesn't handle Finder the same way as Quicksilver (can't switch to Finder with Spotlight). I don't use Expose because I find it takes to much time to find and pick out the window I am looking for.

Honestly, it took me 2 years of owning a Mac before I preferred it over my previous preference (Linux). I think it's a mix of the fact that it is a UNIX and the polish and little details of OS X (there is a lot to both it's form and function). It takes time to appreciate, because it is significantly different than other popular environments.

I'd like to know what is so great about Windows 7, but my experience with it so far has made me think it is just another Windows with some eye-candy (which is not to my taste) and some decent Window tiling features. But I have not been able to give it an honest chance, because one of the .Net projects I maintain requires XP.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by lsb on Sunday August 15, 2010 @10:38AM (#1605193)
Scrollbars being hard to use is mostly because most users have an easy time scrolling (laptops use the two-fingered scroll, mice all have buttons or touch-sensitive surfaces), and scrolling requires only mouseover not focus (try it! scroll the window behind you!). I've almost never used a scrollbar as an input mechanism, only output to see where in a document I am.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by jonknee on Sunday August 15, 2010 @03:25PM (#1605712)
The scrollbars were bad well before Apple shipped a mouse with scrolling functionality.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by ptomato on Sunday August 15, 2010 @11:56AM (#1605305)
"Window Max & Min buttons randomly work depending on the application"

That's because what the button with the plus on it (Zoom) is doing is not supposed to be making the window the size of the screen, but rather making the window the size that will display the most content from the current window with the minimum of scrolling. Some applications ignore this and just use the standard Windows behavior, hence the inconsistency.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by moultano on Sunday August 15, 2010 @08:40PM (#1606393)
In practice it seems that everyone loathes this behavior, hence the need for sites like http://maximizechrome.com/
Re:Welcome to the new decade by ptomato on Sunday August 15, 2010 @10:35PM (#1606625)
I prefer it for most things, actually, web browsers being one of the few exceptions depending on monitor size. There's usually absolutely no point in maximizing something to full screen on a 27" 2560x1440px display, for example. But for the times when I do want to I use Cinch (http://www.irradiatedsoftware.com/cinch/) which steals my favorite Windows 7 feature.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by ajaimk on Sunday August 15, 2010 @01:49PM (#1605532)
Scrollbars are hard to use

2 finger scrolling on trackpads is much more intuitive and also, whats wrong with the scrollbar? I'm sitting here fiddling with the one on safari and still can't figure out anything wrong with it.

Window Max & Min buttons randomly work depending on the application

Window Max maximizes the screen to the maximum amount of space "needed". Though this might not feel great on a 13" macbook, move onto a 27" screen and you will understand WHY firefox taking up the entire screen is a plain simple waste of space.

I won't mention right clicking

You better not mention it, cause you do realize that on the mac it is called 2-finger-clicking. It exists. So, you mentioning it won't make much of a difference.

The hardware is also better but microsoft can force people to build awesome hardware.

People who love great software make their own hardware. Google did it for their servers. I used to use a dell laptop. Bought in 2007. Trashed in 2008. Replace by a mac. Its still on Warranty. Why you ask. 1 year and 4 months = 7th Motherboard, 2rd Screen, 5th Keyboard, 3rd hard drive.

And my macbook pro, 1 year and 4 months later: NOTHING.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by Locke1689 on Sunday August 15, 2010 @09:39PM (#1606506)
Let's just keep it down to taste, OK? Saying that one OS is clearly better than another is just begging for a flame war. From a technical perspective I can tell you that you are wrong in many cases. For background, I use OS X as my primary system, develop for Linux and the kernel, and work for Microsoft.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by jsz0 on Sunday August 15, 2010 @01:19PM (#1605462)
Right clicking? I can quad and penta click on my Magic TrackPad. I think that argument can die now.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by mclin on Sunday August 15, 2010 @11:50AM (#1605293)
Can only resize windows from the bottom corner

no alt to access menu

no double click window header toggles maximize

That switch icon they use for 'option' confused me because it's not on the keyboard anywhere

Overall it's pretty good, but I agree, I miss the little things

Re:Welcome to the new decade by blasdel on Sunday August 15, 2010 @12:29PM (#1605356)
> no alt to access menu

Hit Command-? (command-shift-/), start typing, and use the arrow keys to highlight the search results. You'll be surprised what happens. It's been there since 10.5

Re:Welcome to the new decade by carussell on Sunday August 15, 2010 @01:25PM (#1605477)
That doesn't even come close to as fast as Alt+accesskey, menu item accesskey.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by nileshk on Sunday August 15, 2010 @01:18PM (#1605460)
Strangely, in Firefox, this brings up a new tab with a Firefox help page.

Another option for getting to the menu is the "Move focus to the menu bar" keyboard shortcut which defaults to CTRL-F2, but is assignable. Neither of these methods are as direct as the Windows way, as you have to use cursor keys to move to where you want, but it works.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by Pistos2 on Sunday August 15, 2010 @01:47PM (#1605528)
In my opinion, nothing should pop up without explicit user action (keypress, mouse click). Every would-be pop-up should be pop-under, with some cue (visual or otherwise) to inform the user that something may deserve attention (e.g. flashing taskbar entry or tray icon).

Note also that this is a general problem not restricted to Windows.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by jlgosse on Sunday August 15, 2010 @08:23AM (#1605003)
[In reply to illumini8] Doesn't the iPhone push a non-modal (or maybe it's modal) dialog EVERY time you get a text message? Or is this an option most users have enabled? Not only that, but there is no notion of "focus" on iPhone, so it's even worse. Maybe that's just me being kooky though.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by Glide on Sunday August 15, 2010 @11:32AM (#1605269)
No you're not being kooky. I think the notification system on the iOS needs work. IMO it's the weakest part of the UI.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by ajaimk on Sunday August 15, 2010 @01:52PM (#1605537)
Proof that I am not an Apple Fanboy ;-)

The iPhone's notification system is f#$%ed up. Please fix it apple.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by illumin8 on Sunday August 15, 2010 @08:11AM (#1604992)
To be forward looking regarding OS marketshare, you need to look at what college students are running. When I went to college in the 90s, it was overwhelmingly Microsoft. We ran DOS, then Windows 3.11, then Windows 95. Microsoft got us hooked with mostly free (pirated) software and by the time we got to the workforce, a Microsoft monopoly was a foregone conclusion.

Apple is overwhelmingly capturing college marketshare. At some universities they are more than 50% of the market now. The workers of tomorrow will be comfortable in a Mac environment, not a PC one. By 2020 I fully expect Mac dominance of the corporate market as well. The retraining costs would be too high otherwise.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by jff on Monday August 16, 2010 @09:18AM (#1607682)
Among us engineers, it's not Mac but Linux that is taking the lead. Maybe more of us would use Macs if they weren't already what those dirty art kids use...
Re:Welcome to the new decade by usaar333 on Sunday August 15, 2010 @06:28PM (#1606127)
I have no idea what will happen in 10 years, but I don't see training costs as an issue. When 99% of work is done in a web browser and one or two desktop applications, switching OS's is pretty trivial.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by Aaronontheweb on Sunday August 15, 2010 @04:08PM (#1605816)
Apple's cradle-to-the-grave strategy hasn't carried over to the workforce the same way Microsoft did decades earlier - you can thank the depth of Microsoft's ecosystem today for that.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by kmfrk on Sunday August 15, 2010 @07:19AM (#1604939)
They may not be an underdog, but my image of them is Sideshow Bob walking around surrounded by rakes. Some of their products have launched with a reverberating thud, and their marketing campaigns make me cringe.

They are screwing up a lot, and they don't come across as great innovators (nor as people adapting to the world they're in) rather than a company who is still relying on the same core platforms they did a handful of years, if not a decade, ago. Granted, their corporate structure is different than, say, Apple's, and I don't want another Apple, but they feel gridlocked.

I don't know which term is the most apt for this, but it's not a gratuitous one.

I'm a Windows user myself, but I can't help but feel that I am putting my eggs in the wrong basket sometimes.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by jomohke on Sunday August 15, 2010 @12:26AM (#1604596)
He's not talking about desktops: Apple still has tiny (but growing) market share there.

He's talking about mobile platforms. Microsoft is very much the underdog after ignoring the platform for so long. Apple had a monopoly over good smartphones by beating everyone to market by such a large margin, though it's hard to call them a monopoly now that Android has been selling so well.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by spoondan on Sunday August 15, 2010 @12:42AM (#1604614)
Winning a particular market segment does not a monopoly make.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by _delirium on Sunday August 15, 2010 @04:23AM (#1604808)
I thought that was the definition of a monopoly? I mean, Standard Oil didn't own the coal market, but they were still a monopoly, because they did own the oil market.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by semanticist on Sunday August 15, 2010 @08:06AM (#1604989)
Apple could only have a monopoly in the mobile market if I couldn't walk into a shop and buy a competing product.

In fact, if I walk into a mobile phone shop, I've overwhelmed with competing products and can hardly see the iPhone.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by gloob on Sunday August 15, 2010 @10:59AM (#1605221)
Even at the height of Microsoft's reign, you could still walk into a shop and buy a Mac. Just sayin'.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by semanticist on Sunday August 15, 2010 @11:22AM (#1605257)
Apple don't have a majority of the smartphone market, let alone the mobile phone market in general. Windows had a market share of over 90%.

Five years ago you could have made an argument for Symbian being the Evil Monopoly in this market, but Apple/iOS has never been anything like a monopoly. People seem to confuse control over one device with an actual monopoly. They're not even remotely the same thing.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by Gibbon on Sunday August 15, 2010 @11:55AM (#1605304)
Apple doesn't even lead the smartphone market (yet), RIM does. I'm sure they will catch up quick but RIM had 40% of the market last time I checked and Apple had 25%.

They have 90% of the mp3 market and 75% of the mp3 player market but that's still not a monopoly.

The only thing they could be accused of is a monopoly on non-crappy web apps. Pretty amusing.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by semanticist on Sunday August 15, 2010 @03:20PM (#1605700)
Those figures might be true only for the US/North America, but worldwide Symbian has almost 45%, RIM a little under 20%, iPhone just over 15%, and Android just under 10%.

(As of Q1, 2010, pre-iPhone 4, source: http://www.gartner.com/it/page.jsp?id=1372013)

No one seems to mind their MP3 player monopoly because the iPod was so much better than the alternatives.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by Gibbon on Sunday August 15, 2010 @06:46PM (#1606167)
Yeah I was referring to the smartphone market rather than the mobile market.

Smartphones aren't expected to reach 50% mobile market share until Q3 2011.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by semanticist on Monday August 16, 2010 @06:25AM (#1607348)
The numbers I mentioned are specifically for the smartphone market - 'Worldwide Smartphone Sales to End Users by Operating System in 1Q10 (Thousands of Units)'.

Most people on HN have a really poor understanding of the global market. The US leaders are not the world leaders in the mobile space.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by spoondan on Tuesday August 17, 2010 @09:42PM (#1613005)
Belatedly: While "owning a market" is a serviceable definition of a monopoly, it's not what I wrote about and it has no relationship to Apple's position in the smartphone market (or, really, any other market). A "market segment" is not a "market", and "winning" is not "owning".
Re:Welcome to the new decade by CapitalistCartr on Sunday August 15, 2010 @09:54AM (#1605130)
A monopoly is when a company actively prevents other companies from entering "their" market. Such as by buying them all up, or using their deep pockets to force them out. Not by producing a better product.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by kenjackson on Sunday August 15, 2010 @01:17PM (#1605458)
Wrong. A monopoly is when a company has such market control that they can dictate the terms of the market. What you're describing is abuse of a monopoly.

Example, iTunes is nearing monopoly status in that they can largely tell the industry, "I don't like your DRM proposal, and we're so big that even if every other company wants to do it one way, you can't. You have to listen to us".

Now remember monopolies are not illegal. But actions of monopolists can be.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by blantonl on Sunday August 15, 2010 @01:09AM (#1604644)
unless that particular market segment is making a market.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by guywithabike on Sunday August 15, 2010 @12:37AM (#1604610)
Agreed. A better assertion might be that Apple has a monopoly on revenues in the mobile space.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by houseabsolute on Sunday August 15, 2010 @04:07AM (#1604794)
But that would still be a terrible assertion since many other companies are generating a lot of revenue in the space. You might more properly be able to say that they have a monopoly on profits in the space, but that would be an ill-formed claim because "profits in a sector" are not a valid parameter for monopoly, except in the colloquial sense.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by altano on Sunday August 15, 2010 @08:44AM (#1605030)
Actually OSX's market share peaked with the debut of Win7 and has been declining since.

Your point stands, though.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by altano on Monday August 16, 2010 @09:23AM (#1607691)
Eek, I see several people don't believe me. Here are a bunch of sources:

http://www.google.com/m/search?oe=UTF-8&client=safari...

Re:Welcome to the new decade by senki on Sunday August 15, 2010 @02:45AM (#1604717)
Don't forget that 2010 is the year of the Linux desktop!
Re:Welcome to the new decade by wazoox on Sunday August 15, 2010 @06:34AM (#1604906)
Well, there may be no "year of the Linux desktop", but someday the "desktop" will become a thing of the past, and whatever comes next may be running Linux.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by senki on Sunday August 15, 2010 @07:14AM (#1604936)
Hey, I meant to be sarcastic, but actually you are right! The smartphones and tablets are already here, lots of them running Android, and Microsoft really is an underdog.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by melling on Sunday August 15, 2010 @09:48AM (#1605122)
2010 is the Year of Linux on the Phone.

Linux is outselling Apple and Microsoft.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by blasdel on Sunday August 15, 2010 @12:49PM (#1605389)
Android is not recognizably Linux and you know it. It's using the Linux kernel about as minimally as they could get away with, they patch it to expose all kinds of things directly to userland through hacked-together APIs. The userland bears no resemblance to POSIX, and developers don't get to write for it (Dalvik or JNI only). It's even less Linux than a TiVO.

Compare Android: http://mjg59.livejournal.com/100221.html with WebOS: http://mjg59.livejournal.com/111453.html from a linux kernel developer's perspective

Re:Welcome to the new decade by cookiecaper on Sunday August 15, 2010 @01:15PM (#1605454)
I wouldn't call Android even less Linux than a TiVO just from the links you gave. The guy says that he is disappointed that the power management is jacked up, especially when Linux already provides normal interfaces for that kind of thing, but other than that I didn't see anything hugely awful. As the author of those posts says, the other stuff has no prospect of going upstream anyway so it doesn't really matter. There's certainly still a lot of Linux running under the covers there.

The userspace is different, but if you want Gnome on your phone get Maemo/Meego.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by melling on Sunday August 15, 2010 @01:27PM (#1605483)
Google is using the 2.6 kernel. Yes, a lot of user land stuff is missing, probably to keep the footprint small. Google will be contributing their changes back to the Linux kernel. They are feeding the Linux ecosystem.

http://developer.android.com/guide/basics/what-is-android.ht...

And you're right, WebOS and Nokia(Meego) have Linux phones too. Linux is the the future of smartphones is one form or another.

Throw in the iPhone and we can say Unix, the past, has become the future of smartphones.

Re:Welcome to the new decade by lsc on Monday August 16, 2010 @05:48AM (#1607304)
my understanding is that while Google is following the letter of the GPL and giving back their changes to the GPL'd code, they are not putting fourth the effort to get those changes integrated with the rest of the linux kernel, so practically speaking, you aren't going to be seeing much of the android changes outside of android.

http://www.kroah.com/log/linux/android-kernel-problems.html

Re:Welcome to the new decade by bconway on Sunday August 15, 2010 @11:15AM (#1605244)
Yes, there's no question that Windows 7 is a decent OS, but the desktop is becoming less and less relevant with each passing day. The new decade is about web services, cloud computing, social networks, and mobile platforms. Microsoft has been caught flat-footed on all of these and is playing a big game of catchup.
Re:Welcome to the new decade by mrb on Sunday August 15, 2010 @03:12PM (#1605678)
"2.6x" is hardly what I would call "immensely".

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usage_share_of_operating_system...

(In June 2010, Windows 7's market share was only 2.6 times larger than Mac OS X's, when considering the market of "web clients", which is composed mostly of personal computers)