Re:To Serve Man, with Software
by christophilus on Sunday December 31, 2017 @04:13PM
(#16043018)
I've been thinking about this lately, as my current software platform is sometimes used for purposes I really don't like. And I've been considering moving to work on some Etherium applications, since I strongly believe in a decentralized web. But the decentralized web will certainly enable unsavory characters to do evil things.
In the end, we build things for the purpose of serving others, but can't really beat ourselves up when those things are misused. If I was an automotive engineer, I wouldn't like the fact that creeps were using my cars to kidnap people or as getaway vehicles or the like, but it doesn't mean that I'm complicit in those things. I think software-- for the most part-- is a lot like that.
By the same token if you specialized in armored cars that could outrun police and were invisible to radar, you’d have no right to be shocked by who ends up using it. You’d protect diplomats and people in dangerous parts of the world... and cartel kingpins, dictators, etc.
Re:To Serve Man, with Software
by ForHackernews on Sunday December 31, 2017 @08:05PM
(#16044001)
I think this is a cop-out.
As a developer, your software makes it easier to do certain things and harder to do other things. Not all use cases are equally well supported.
Software is categorically different from something dumb like a hammer. Telling yourself you're just making hammers is a dodge to salve your conscience.
People recognize evil in, say, Isis, Nazis, or a school shooter, but usually accompanied with that recognition is a distancing from the act - a way of saying "I'm not like them".
And I'm not saying you are. But evil is insidious and pervasive. It affects everything we do. And that definitely includes software.
I worked for a company that had a help chat room, where users could ask a support person questions about the product. It was publicly accessible from a link on the website, basically a slack room. One day we notice two teenagers had hijacked the room in the middle of the night and were using it for an erotic conversation. That's fairly mundane, but what if they weren't teenagers? What if one of them was underage, and we had accidentally facilitated a child molester?
And this happens everywhere.
I heard about a kid who got cyberbullied with scratch (scratch.mit.edu) because it allows you to share content with other users? Do you think the makers of scratch ever imagined that they'd play a hand in some middle-schooler committing suicide? (fyi, they actually police this stuff)
I've built financial research sites, ad optimization software, phone calling apps, operational and monitoring tools. I think all that software has been mostly helpful for people, but I also recognize that it played a part in nefarious ends as well.
Everyone's hands are dirty.