News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Benefits of Economic Expansions Are Increasingly Goin... by Daishiman on Saturday December 30, 2017 @08:36PM (#16038811)
Oh come on don't make these idiotic arguments that forget that pretty much all Western European nations that have low levels of income inequality have done so through massive taxation and the creation of public goods and benefits that allow them to support a highly developed society.

Free universities, free healthcare, long paternity leaves, environmental protection and subsidies to underdeveloped areas are all factors that are proven to have helped substantially to reduce inequality and increase social mobility.

I seriously can't stop marveling at how people can defend an increasingly unequal world when there is a shrinking middle class and a more fragile position for the most vulnerable.

Re:The Benefits of Economic Expansions Are Increasingly Goin... by rayiner on Saturday December 30, 2017 @09:37PM (#16039027)
For the most part, Western European countries have less redistribution baked into their tax systems than the U.S. Take Germany for example. The top marginal income tax rate in Germany is about 50%. In California, it's over 50%. Corporate tax rates are similar (with Germany's being slightly lower). Capital gains rates are higher in California than in Germany (and similar between Germany and the U.S. on average). If you make $2 million per year, your tax bill is probably a bit less in Germany than in California.

But the tax burden overall, of course, is higher in Germany. That extra money comes from the middle class. Here are the tax brackets for a single person (in Euros):

    0%  up to 7,664
    15% 7,665- 52,153
    42% 52,154 - 250,000
    45% 250,001 and over
Then Germans pay various health insurance and pension contributions that are, like our FICA taxes, subject to wage caps, which puts most of the burden of their healthcare and retirement system on the middle class. They also pay 19% VAT, which again puts most of the burden on the middle class.

If Trump proposed implementing a tax plan that distributed the burden of taxation the way Germany's does, people would be apoplectic.

Re:The Benefits of Economic Expansions Are Increasingly Goin... by refurb on Saturday December 30, 2017 @11:25PM (#16039351)
Indeed. Yes, there are people that have very high incomes. However, there aren't that many of them. The gov't has no choice but to increase the burden on the middle class if they want to raise serious revenue.

It reminds me of an interview with a candidate in the Canadian election back in the 1990's. This was the NDP party (left wing).

The candidate said his platform was to raise taxes for the rich. The intrepid reporter asked "what is rich?". The candidate in a moment of honesty said "A family of four making more than $60K per year".

People went apeshit with that comment.

Re:The Benefits of Economic Expansions Are Increasingly Goin... by tptacek on Sunday December 31, 2017 @01:39AM (#16039663)
It's true to a significant extent in the US as well that to raise significant revenue --- for instance, to create a new entitlement program for health care --- taxes have to be raised from the middle class.
Re:The Benefits of Economic Expansions Are Increasingly Goin... by dnautics on Saturday December 30, 2017 @08:52PM (#16038878)
You think that's sustainable? Ithink you will find that even though all of the countries in Europe have basically free social services, the divide between the rich and poor is not decreasing in all of them. What does correlate with it is institutional corruption and confiscatory monetary policy ( the nordics are not on the euro, which is for now better than the pound). People in the nordics are doing way better than in Europe they in turn are doing better than the British

The funny thing is that the world itself is not increasingly unequal, the global gini coefficient is coming down, mostly due to arbitrage - migration away from countries with corruption and poor, confiscatory monetary policy to ones where the confiscation is slow enough to be generational.

Re:The Benefits of Economic Expansions Are Increasingly Goin... by Daishiman on Saturday December 30, 2017 @09:01PM (#16038907)
The Nordics are doing way better precisely because they have the highest taxation rate and the largest states.

Statoil is a massive mixed enterprise and it's doing just fine, and unlike the rest of the countries where wealth from oil gets funneled overseas or goes to a few corporations, it goes into the largest sovereign fund in the planet to safeguard people's wealth.

The Nordic nations have the proportionally massive states and nobody's saying that they would be better off with fewer public services... because they wouldn't, and it's obvious to anyone who wants to make the debate global.

Re:The Benefits of Economic Expansions Are Increasingly Goin... by Consultant32452 on Saturday December 30, 2017 @09:43PM (#16039054)
I'm genuinely curious about how states with high redistribution rates fair with regard to their impact on the broader world. For example, are the Nordics over or under-represented in Nobel Prizes? Is there some metric that takes into account population, perhaps GDP per capita, and patents filed or scientific papers written?

How about immigration policy, both statutory and real-world. I do know that the Nordics are largely mono-cultures where something like 98% of the people are the same color and religion. If the Nordics are such great places to be, and if they have statutorily open borders (they are in the EU, right?), why are they not flooded with poor people from other nations? Are they socially hostile to immigrants?

Re:The Benefits of Economic Expansions Are Increasingly Goin... by freeone3000 on Saturday December 30, 2017 @11:18PM (#16039330)
Today in Oslo it was -5C and had 6 hours of sunlight. There may be other reasons that the Nordic countries are hostile to outsiders.
Re:The Benefits of Economic Expansions Are Increasingly Goin... by dnautics on Saturday December 30, 2017 @09:08PM (#16038940)
you're neglecting the fact that the nordics have the lowest rate of inflation among all of the countries in europe, in other words, the state steals the least from its (poorest) people.
Re:The Benefits of Economic Expansions Are Increasingly Goin... by AFNobody on Saturday December 30, 2017 @09:42PM (#16039048)
Inflation is not theft.

If you genuinely believe that:

1) Please use a deflationary currency (like bitcoin) for all your transactions.

2) Study the impact of deflation on Japan. Or the deflations in the US that almost always coincided with a depression with one (arguable) exception. Keep in mind, that arguable exception was one of half a dozen such events.

Re:The Benefits of Economic Expansions Are Increasingly Goin... by dnautics on Sunday December 31, 2017 @12:59PM (#16041678)
Correlation is not causation. your arrow of causality is wrong. Of course deflations are correlated with modern economic contractions. In the era of central banking, contractions happen after the social capacity for debt has been stretched to the limit because tptb have tried to goose the economy too hard, and defaults exceed the rate of debt creation, leading to a contraction of the money supply.

I suggest studying the free banking era and the us during the 1800s. How did the country ever survive without inflation??? They even managed to royally screw things up with a civil war and a completely insane bimetallic standard, without implosion.

I suggest you study the effect of inflation on Japan. How's that lost decade going? Well, at least we got a lot of pansocial angst among the < 30 crowd (and some interesting anime) out of it.

Re:The Benefits of Economic Expansions Are Increasingly Goin... by Daishiman on Saturday December 30, 2017 @09:42PM (#16039049)
Inflation as a variable for income inequality is dwarfed by tons of other factors. No serious economist is going to say that it's a terrible thing. A lot of countries have had to deal with inflation rates above 5% and they could still grow and lower inequality.
Re:The Benefits of Economic Expansions Are Increasingly Goin... by dnautics on Sunday December 31, 2017 @01:07PM (#16041737)
I don't understand how you can make that assertion. The effects of inflation are compounding and disproportionately bad for the poor. Have you ever been poor? The price of everyday goods was definitely a cause of worry for me on a daily basis. And you shouldn't take anything from "seroius economists" on the issue, most of them are from the 1% and totally clueless.
Re:The Benefits of Economic Expansions Are Increasingly Goin... by jacobush on Saturday December 30, 2017 @09:39PM (#16039036)
Maybe but I know they are doing the best they can to increase inflation, to little avail.
Re:The Benefits of Economic Expansions Are Increasingly Goin... by skummetmaelk on Saturday December 30, 2017 @09:21PM (#16038987)
>the nordics are not on the euro, which is for now better than the pound.

You have no idea what you are talking about. Finland uses the euro. Denmark is pegged to the euro, a peg which cannot be broken like Switzerland's because it is 100% politically controlled. Norway is not in the EU so why would it use the euro? Iceland is also not in the EU.

Besides being completely wrong, why does the nordics being on the euro even matter for this discussion?

Re:The Benefits of Economic Expansions Are Increasingly Goin... by maoistinquisitr on Saturday December 30, 2017 @09:04PM (#16038923)
Stay tuned over the next five years. Most of the European welfare systems are teetering on the brink. The pension funds are busted, the healthcare systems are having huge budget problems, and yields are shooting up on the municipal and national bonds.

Eventually you run out of other people's money. Remember that Greece looked pretty good ten years ago.

Re:The Benefits of Economic Expansions Are Increasingly Goin... by Daishiman on Saturday December 30, 2017 @09:44PM (#16039059)
This applies to the entire planet (except for countries with growing populations, and that is a substantially worse problem), and European states have much greater safeguards and are in general far more stable than most other places in the world.
Re:The Benefits of Economic Expansions Are Increasingly Goin... by maoistinquisitr on Saturday December 30, 2017 @10:17PM (#16039163)
It really is worse in Europe on the fiscal front. About half of German municipalities have busted pension funds, for example. The problem is also huge in America, but it's an order worse and more imminent in Europe. Ceteris paribus the USA will probably blow up around 2025 or so, but instead hopefully in the wake of Europe's more imminent fiscal crises we can correct course somehow to avoid their fate.
Re:The Benefits of Economic Expansions Are Increasingly Goin... by carterehsmith on Sunday December 31, 2017 @12:55AM (#16039559)
Oh, we've been hearing the same (German pension funds are underfunded, Germany is about to collapse) things for the last 2 decades at least. Did Germany collapse? Oh no, but sure will in two years... or whatever.

Same with US. By now it should have turned to 1997 with Curt Russell being president &c, but it did not really happen.

BTW same with any stock that someone on the internet has bought or shorted. Sure it's going down... about to collapse!!! Going up... buy now!!

Re:The Benefits of Economic Expansions Are Increasingly Goin... by QAPereo on Sunday December 31, 2017 @09:53PM (#16044396)
To be fair, Detroit more or less conformed to the hype, a la Robocop, at least for a while. Cali is doomed long term with the water situation (Caddilac Desert is a great read), the future of Louisiana is unclear, and so on. The predictions have been off as to timing, but the trajectory seems accurate.
Re:The Benefits of Economic Expansions Are Increasingly Goin... by carterehsmith on Saturday December 30, 2017 @11:53PM (#16039413)
>> Most of the European welfare systems are teetering on the brink.

Thanks. I love getting some hot macroeconomic advice from a random person on an internet forum. Especially if it does not provide any sort of backing analysis, that is just the best way to do it.