News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Digital Advertising Duopoly by herodotus on Thursday December 28, 2017 @04:28PM (#16025038)
The problem with subscriptions is not the cost, its the sheer number of them - and some come up almost accidentally. I pay a lot to my ISP every month. I would like to see a company that charges me monthly to eliminate all adware by micro-paying the participating websites for my actual page visits. In fact, if my ISP added such a service for a fee, I would sign up.
Re:The Digital Advertising Duopoly by majani on Friday December 29, 2017 @01:26AM (#16028002)
The only company that could manage these subscriptions effectively is one that owns either:

1. The browser 2. The app store or 3. The OS

Oh, wait...

Re:The Digital Advertising Duopoly by manigandham on Thursday December 28, 2017 @08:17PM (#16026705)
We tried this - there's a lot of political and business issues that basically mean you can't pull it off unless you're a major player (like Verizon or Google) already. Selling the data (of which one of the uses is advertising) is more lucrative than letting users pay direct, and that's before overcoming the hurdle of most consumers who think that they already pay for "the internet" including all the content.

Google's has the Google Contributor option [1], but that only applies for ads via their ad network and not other potential sources. There's also Flattr which is not as automated but it's now owned by AdBlockPlus crew and has raised rates so it's not such a transparent and clean system anymore.

1. https://contributor.google.com/v/beta

2. https://flattr.com/

Re:The Digital Advertising Duopoly by rhizome on Thursday December 28, 2017 @10:06PM (#16027196)
Forgive me if this is naïve, but how does Joe Random site owner participate in the selling of data? My impression is that that's an area of commerce with a pretty closed membership.

I'm not asking in order to do something like this, just that I think it's an interesting question about exactly who is able to profit from activities that are somewhat assumed to be occurring everywhere, and not by and within the ad networks that everybody is using.

Re:The Digital Advertising Duopoly by manigandham on Friday December 29, 2017 @09:34AM (#16029611)
I was talking about the companies that would be in the position to do subscription bundle handling, and they're more interested in the current situation.

Publishers can participate in selling user logins and analytics data through various data companies, they're always interested in more data and especially anything unique that your site adds. You should have a certain scale though for the contract to be worth it, otherwise if its just a personal blog then you're probably just limited to run adding some ads from the typical ad networks.

Re:The Digital Advertising Duopoly by hatmagic456 on Friday December 29, 2017 @02:14AM (#16028168)
The only places that buy and sell user data are spammy mailing lists. That's it.

Browser history predicts almost nothing, anyway. There is no market where user data is bought and sold, except for spammy mailing lists to other spammy mailing lists.

Re:The Digital Advertising Duopoly by manigandham on Friday December 29, 2017 @08:57AM (#16029470)
That is completely wrong.

There is a vast market for consumer data (which is more than just browsing history) with everything from credit agencies like Equifax to data brokers like Axciom to traditional analytics companies like Nielsen and Comscore to top tech companies like Google, Adobe, Oracle, Salesforce, and others that have marketing clouds with DMP platforms. It's a massive industry.

Re:The Digital Advertising Duopoly by rhizome on Saturday December 30, 2017 @01:51PM (#16036720)
Have you ever heard of "the entire market research industry?" It's about 100 years old.
Re:The Digital Advertising Duopoly by harshreality on Thursday December 28, 2017 @05:05PM (#16025346)
You want your ISP to [be able to] spy on, and track, your browsing habits? For unencrypted pages, that would probably take the form of DPI and injected javascript. For encrypted (SSL) web traffic, all your ISP has access to are 1) the ip of the website, 2) SNI hostname, if any, in the SSL helo, and 3) how long the TCP stream stays alive, which is probably not representative of your interaction with the site. They have no page-level information.

There's already a service that is probably capable of doing what you ask. It's called google analytics. Google's in the payment business, and google's in the tracking business. If only all publishers could agree to use analytics.js, and petition google to implement micropayments with some agreed upon fee structure.

Re:The Digital Advertising Duopoly by herodotus on Thursday December 28, 2017 @05:33PM (#16025615)
I am sure there are ways to design such a system that precludes tracking. For example, suppose I have a browser that includes an extension that does this: I want to visit U (some url). My browser sends a request to the no ad service to see if U has signed up. If it has, then it sends me a once-only token. I send this as proof of status to U, and they send it to the no ad service to claim their micro payment. The only parties who know I have visited U are (a) my ISP - I assume all requests probably go through them; (b) the no ad service (actually, all they really know is that I asked for a token); and (c) U, of course - although all U knows is my IP address, nothing else.

Anyway, that is roughly how such a service might work. I am sure that even better safeguards could be designed into it.

Re:The Digital Advertising Duopoly by jacques_chester on Friday December 29, 2017 @03:57AM (#16028473)
> I would like to see a company that charges me monthly to eliminate all adware by micro-paying the participating websites for my actual page visits.

I (and others) am working on this; I call it microsubscription. It's a common idea: I've seen maybe a dozen closely-related variations on it since hitting on it.

In typical techie fashion I became obsessed with the technical problem of preventing publishers from inflating their figures while also preserving user privacy. I solved it, was granted a relevant patent two days ago and I guess we'll see what happens in 2018.

Re:The Digital Advertising Duopoly by sah2ed on Friday December 29, 2017 @04:32AM (#16028576)
> I solved it, was granted a relevant patent two days ago and I guess we'll see what happens in 2018.

Patent link?

Re:The Digital Advertising Duopoly by jacques_chester on Friday December 29, 2017 @09:27AM (#16029577)
#9,853,964. Google have the application in their search index: https://patents.google.com/patent/US20160285861A1/.
Re:The Digital Advertising Duopoly by andschwa on Thursday December 28, 2017 @05:02PM (#16025309)
That's kind of the idea behind ORCHID: https://orchidprotocol.com/.
Re:The Digital Advertising Duopoly by herodotus on Thursday December 28, 2017 @05:35PM (#16025629)
Thanks for the link. Orchid looks interesting.
Re:The Digital Advertising Duopoly by rhizome on Thursday December 28, 2017 @10:08PM (#16027206)
It looks interesting, but that list of investors reads to me like a timebomb to pivot back toward surveillance.
Re:The Digital Advertising Duopoly by dreamfactored on Thursday December 28, 2017 @06:36PM (#16026094)
Next wave - aggregated subscription bundlers? Would also facilitate cross-marketing