News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The sorry state of OpenSSL usability by tptacek on Thursday December 28, 2017 @04:13PM (#16024933)
The usability points in this post are very well taken, but I'd push back on "we're told not to roll our own crypto but instead to use OpenSSL", since the first part of that claim is true but the second is emphatically not.
Re:The sorry state of OpenSSL usability by pvg on Thursday December 28, 2017 @07:09PM (#16026330)
The second part is a direct consequence of how malleable and easy to misinterpret the first part is. It's a 'usability' problem of its own.
Re:The sorry state of OpenSSL usability by tptacek on Thursday December 28, 2017 @07:43PM (#16026505)
I see where you're coming from and there's obviously some truth to it, but even an exceptionally well-documented OpenSSL with carefully thought-out command line UX would still be dangerous just by dint of what OpenSSL (as in, the "openssl" CLI) sets out to do, which is to provide an interface to low-level cryptography.
Re:The sorry state of OpenSSL usability by pvg on Thursday December 28, 2017 @08:59PM (#16026924)
would still be dangerous just by dint of what OpenSSL (as in, the "openssl" CLI) sets out to do

Of course. What I'm getting at is "don't roll your own crypto" is one of the things that gives people a false sense of confidence in using the low-level crypto facilities. It might as well not be true for all the good it does the people it's supposed to help. I guess 'emphatically' is what I'm responding to, the 'don't roll' thing is, effectively, not that great either.