News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by tomxor on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @06:36AM (#16014179)
> The next dozen years will drain less than 1 percent of the reserves in the ground

That's actually an extremely large portion for such a short length of time (this is the entire planet we are talking about). That projection doesn't paint a very sustainable future compared to oil (yes I hate oil), I hope it's efficiently recycled or replaced with better tech.

Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by thecabinet on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @07:03AM (#16014273)
Assuming lithium reserves work anything like oil reserves, the quantity of reserves depends on market process. When oil sells for $20/bb, oil that costs more than that to extract doesn't count towards the reserves. As the price goes up, the reserves increase, because you can extract oil from more challenging circumstances. This is why we've had 20-30 years of oil reserves for the last 50 years.
Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by tomxor on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @08:21AM (#16014588)
That is a big assumption but yes, I understand that "reserves" != "all", and you rightly describe the interrelationship between price and what is considered "extractable".

Even so, as an initial "world reserves" estimate, it's absolutely puny. Take into consideration that past the first "dozen years" demand will increase massively, at full adoption lithium will likely be short lived as a primary material to base batteries on. We don't know the extraction potential for whatever the "remaining" and "unknown" reserves are but thankfully EVs aren't intrinsically tied to lithium like ICE is to oil, so if lithium becomes overmined we are more likely to switch to other materials than go to extremes to extract more of it.

Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by monort on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @07:37AM (#16014402)
Oil alarmism existed as early as 1919: http://papers.sae.org/190011/
Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by sgift on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:16AM (#16015168)
So, it took almost 100 years until the mainstream understood what should have been blatantly obvious to anyone who thinks about it: Oh right. Oil is limited.

I mean, sure, if we search long and hard enough we will probably almost always be able to find/produce something, but I don't think asking 1 million per liter of gas would be such a great idea.

Hoping that there will always be a scientific breakthrough just "right in time" to solve our resource problems is great. I love optimism. It's also extremely irresponsible to depend on it.

Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by coldtea on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:18AM (#16015178)
You mean "oil cautionism" based on the very well established fact that reserves are limited (and it took the billions of years to be created)?
Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by Roboprog on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @02:43PM (#16017414)
Or perhaps “only” 200 million years or so

But yah, a one time thing for us.

Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by srtjstjsj on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @11:16AM (#16015586)
That means that "oil reserves" is a short-term financial concept that has no bearing on long-term planning discussions.
Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by keymone on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @07:27AM (#16014350)
Is any lithium actually lost in the lifecycle of battery? It’s not like oil that we burn and it’s gone.
Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by disnsj on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @07:54AM (#16014473)
True but it depends how expensive it is to recycle, a question o haven’t seen a clear answer to.

I mean, technically, oil can be recycled too! Just cut some trees (I.e. sequester CO2) and make syngas.

Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by neolefty on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @09:22AM (#16014865)
Lithium ore is often < 1%. I'm no miner, but I'd bet an old battery beats that!
Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by disnsj on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @09:44AM (#16014989)
Concentration isn’t the whole story though. Plastic is 100% plastic, but it’s still hard and expensive to recycle.

Lithium batteries need to be removed from their device. Then removed from their casing. Both these steps are for things made tamper proof to some degree.

Add transportation, labor and environmental [1] costs.

In general recycling of mtls used in electronic devices is dirty and expensive.

Now a car with a big battery will change a lot of these numbers. But the problem remains: we look for tech solution (i.e. e-cars) to our social problems (bad cities, “weak” ppl [2])

[1] the Chinese are increasingly reluctant to import the worlds trash.

[2] as a kid my wife used newspaper for toilet paper at an outhouse, no one owned cars and her grandparents village was a three hour walk (no roads). That’s strong. My mom drove me to school. That’s weak

Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by hackeraccount on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @12:51PM (#16016474)
[2] That's nothing. When I was kid I walked 5 miles each way to school. Needless to say - uphill both ways.
Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by jessriedel on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @03:46PM (#16017877)
We’ll have 1200 years to think about it.
Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by thomasahle on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:59AM (#16015478)
1 percent for a dozen years, that's 120 years left. That's more than double of oil: https://www.seeker.com/how-much-oil-is-left-on-earth-1792718...
Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by tomxor on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @11:17AM (#16015593)
Do you really think the consumption rate is linear?

...I didn't realise we were already at full EV adoption.

Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by WJW on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @11:15AM (#16015584)
100 * 12 is actually 1200? :)
Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by srtjstjsj on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @11:14AM (#16015575)
1200 years
Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by api on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:47AM (#16015382)
Reserves means currently known. There has been little serious exploration until recently. Lithium is more common in the crust than lead, and we currently mine more lead. I'm not concerned.

I'm totally blown away by how much oil and gas we have found and those are not recyclable.

Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by mtgx on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @09:15AM (#16014829)
Unlike oil, lithium can be recycled in extremely high percentage.

By the time this will be a problem in 100 years, we'll have long moved to something else, like graphene or whatever.

I don't know why people are freaking out about it so much. My guess is it has to do something with oil propaganda. After all, the best myths are those that have a "seed of truth" in them. So once the oil industry started its anti-lithium propaganda, a lot of people must be thinking "well, it does ring kind of true, doesn't it?", even though their "facts" are 99% misleading.

Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by coldtea on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @10:20AM (#16015192)
>By the time this will be a problem in 100 years, we'll have long moved to something else, like graphene or whatever.

You know, that's not inevitable, it's more of a religious viewpoint. There's no contract humanity signed to guarantee timely delivery of scientific breakthroughs.

Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by valuearb on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @11:00AM (#16015482)
No, there is a thing called the market price which does that for us.

When oil reaches $300 per barrel, demand will drop substantially. When it reaches $1,000 a barrel, demand will be drop to only a tiny fraction.

As prices rise, complements get more attractive. Other sources of energy, from solar, wind, to nuclear become far more attractive.

And that’s without inventing new complements. Which will happen, and likely be as cheap or cheaper than oil ever was.

Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by srtjstjsj on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @11:18AM (#16015605)
We can't simply buy new inventions.
Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by valuearb on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @12:20PM (#16016235)
We don’t have to, we already have complements to replace any natural resources we run low on. Inventing better ones just makes the transitions easier.
Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by traek on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @04:26PM (#16018171)
Substitutes, not complements, but yes.
Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by oreo81 on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @09:38AM (#16014963)
>By the time this will be a problem in 100 years, we'll have long moved to something else, like graphene or whatever.

That is a big assumption, and honestly irresponsible.

Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by wetpaws on Thursday December 28, 2017 @01:52AM (#16020745)
Why is it irresponsible? Stone age did not end because of the stone shortage.
Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by oreo81 on Thursday December 28, 2017 @12:58PM (#16023611)
Because you're blindly assuming we'll have a break through in battery technology in the next 100 years. Shrugging off a shortage of lithium as a non issue because we'll just come up with something better is irresponsible.
Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by wetpaws on Thursday December 28, 2017 @07:00PM (#16026279)
In the history of humanity was never a case when technological advancement was doomed by a lack of a resource. Aluminium was extremely limited and valuable and no one was givinf damn and for a good reason - it does barely cost anything due to the massive technological paradigm shift. In fact, if people think about it more then five seconds, then pretty much every particle on this planet is limited and can be a potential bottleneck. Breaking news, let's all just die to protect our previous mother Earth.

I don't care about doomsday scenarios, because I kept hearing them every day, if there is anything more irresponsible then it's blind alarmism.

Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by monkeypizza on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @12:05PM (#16016066)
Numbers like 0.5% or 0.01% qualify as "Less than 1%", so this thread is invalid.
Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by tomxor on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @02:28PM (#16017251)
With a stat like "less than 1%" the order of magnitude is at least 1/10 of 1% otherwise it's an invalid format for a statistic, it's also most likely >= 0.5 because of rounding... 0 is also less than 1 so with your logic the statistic is meaningless.
Re:We’re Going to Need More Lithium by monkeypizza on Thursday December 28, 2017 @09:17PM (#16027011)
Yes, all "X is less than Y" statistics are meaningless unless there the convention you mention is strongly held by journalists when they interpret studies - which is unlikely.

i.e. it'd be very easy for a study to say "we have shown that it's likely that the effect size is less than 1%" and then a journalist to interpret that as <1%, and then for a reader to incorrectly think "they wouldn't have said this if it were actually 0.1% or lower".