News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SF engineer came to money and now wants wife to sign a po... by methodover on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @03:08PM (#16010659)
Could someone help explain this to me? I don't understand why the wife shouldn't sign. As far as I can tell from the post, she didn't help create any aspect of the apps that her husband made which made them rich. I don't understand why she would be entitled to half given that she did not contribute half.
Re:SF engineer came to money and now wants wife to sign a po... by gaius on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @03:16PM (#16010719)
I can't tell if you are serious or not but... Nothing happens in a vacuum. Would he have had the time or opportunity to work on side projects without his wife handling some aspect of their domestic situation, for example? But the bigger picture is that a married couple is a single entity legally speaking as far as property and finances are concerned. Judges in many jurisdictions completely ignore pre-nups for this very reason.
Re:SF engineer came to money and now wants wife to sign a po... by methodover on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @04:43PM (#16011233)
Was serious. Thanks for the response. My parents always kept separate bank accounts, always seemed to have clearly defined separations between who owned what. Separate cars, separate car payments. Separate careers, separate everything. I always got the sense that my parents were two separate individuals in a partnership. I don't think either of them would have a problem signing a postnup solidifying that.
Re:SF engineer came to money and now wants wife to sign a po... by gaius on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @06:08AM (#16014105)
My parents did it like this: my father’s salary went into their joint account and my mother’s salary went into her own account. Huh.
Re:SF engineer came to money and now wants wife to sign a po... by gspetr on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @03:03AM (#16013533)
Would he have not if he had been single?

If he was single, should the cleaning service get a cut of his company?

Should the Domino's get a cut of his company for keeping him fed during those midnight coding sessions?

What about the washing machine manufacturer?

Re:SF engineer came to money and now wants wife to sign a po... by gaius on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @05:01AM (#16013888)
Was he paying his wife a salary? You have a very odd idea of marriage.
Re:SF engineer came to money and now wants wife to sign a po... by gspetr on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @05:15AM (#16013931)
There are quite a few countries where it's A-OK to give your entire salary to your wife, so it's more like not paying her your salary, but her giving you a fraction of yours.
Re:SF engineer came to money and now wants wife to sign a po... by qsymmachus on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @03:19PM (#16010736)
> I don't understand why she would be entitled to half given that she did not contribute half

Under California law, all assets acquired after marriage are considered "community property". This means that regardless of who "actually" earned the assets, they are owned by each spouse equally (50/50).

Not all states have this regime, and there are good arguments both for and against the concept. I believe that the strongest argument in favor is that community property prevents power imbalances from developing within a marriage. It is sadly common for a spouse to be trapped in an abusive or unhappy marriage, but who cannot practically escape the relationship because they do not have independent means of support. Community property provides a guarantee of financial support should a marriage dissolve.

Re:SF engineer came to money and now wants wife to sign a po... by remir on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @03:22PM (#16010761)
It's not that she feels entitled to his wealth, it's that the prenup makes her feel like her husband doesn't trust her 100% to NOT go after his wealth in the case of a divorce.

Notice she said she would never hurt her husband even if the relationship ended. From her perspective, the prenup is not necessary, but she feels like her husband thinks differently and may not trust her completely.

Re:SF engineer came to money and now wants wife to sign a po... by wolfgke on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @03:27PM (#16010799)
> It's not that she feels entitled to his wealth, it's that the prenup makes her feel like her husband doesn't trust her 100% to NOT go after his wealth in the case of a divorce.

Even the legal possibility of her doing this is a strong liability for the business. So her not signing means sabotaging his business venture, which only leaves him divorce as option to save his business.

Re:SF engineer came to money and now wants wife to sign a po... by s73ver_ on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @03:42PM (#16010893)
I'm sorry, but this line of thinking is abso-fucking-lutely bonkers. If he, or any of you honestly feel that someone would do that, then why are you marrying them?

Her not signing is in no way, shape, or form sabotaging the business venture. Not in the slightest. And if he does divorce because of that, then he deserves whatever he gets, because he shouldn't have married her in the first place, and he didn't love her.

Re:SF engineer came to money and now wants wife to sign a po... by Nadya on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @04:07PM (#16011037)
From the business perspective (which means completely disregard any personal perspectives/issues that arise) there are four scenarios.

Agree + Stay together ; Agree + Divorce ; Disagree + Stay Together ; Disagree + Divorce

Only one of these has potential risk to the business and it falls under the "Disagree" options. So for the business, agreement is necessary to prevent that risk and some business partners that otherwise might be on board would refuse due to that risk.

Coming into or marrying into money, divorcing for 50%, and "finding a better partner" is not something completely unheard of and it is common enough that people seek protection against it which is why these sort of agreements exist in the first place. If the marriage "isn't about money" then pre/post nups only solidify that fact by putting it into writing: it isn't about the money and won't ever be about the money.

There are two possible perspectives to take here:

A) They would only ask for it in writing if they didn't trust them at their word (people with this perspective will likely side with the wife)

b) They would only refuse to put it in writing if they don't intend to honor their word (people with this perspective will likely side with the husband)

Re:SF engineer came to money and now wants wife to sign a po... by s73ver_ on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @04:34PM (#16011184)
"From the business perspective (which means completely disregard any personal perspectives/issues that arise"

No. Those other perspectives are just as valid, if not more.

"So for the business, agreement is necessary to prevent that risk and some business partners that otherwise might be on board would refuse due to that risk."

Given that millions of businesses are started while one party is married, and don't have this problem, I don't consider it to be a valid concern.

"Coming into or marrying into money, divorcing for 50%, and "finding a better partner" is not something completely unheard of and it is common enough that people seek protection against it"

And what's the wife's protection in that case?

"If the marriage "isn't about money" then pre/post nups only solidify that fact by putting it into writing: it isn't about the money and won't ever be about the money."

Except now, there are no consequences for the husband being unfaithful.

Re:SF engineer came to money and now wants wife to sign a po... by Nadya on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @05:36PM (#16011483)
>No. Those other perspectives are just as valid, if not more.

As far as the business is concerned - not really. To the individuals? Well... this is why there is such a divide depending which perspective someone takes... it's a "clear cut" answer depending what kind of perspective you have and whether or not you're assuming "in good faith" or not.

>Given that millions of businesses are started while one party is married, and don't have this problem, I don't consider it to be a valid concern.

Millions of businesses have or don't have rules against dating. Some allow dating, others don't allow dating vertically, others don't allow dating vertically in one's department, and others don't allow dating period.

Just because some businesses take a risk doesn't mean it isn't a risk. It's a matter of how you attempt to mitigate that risk. As others have mentioned - buyback stocks under certain circumstances such as divorce are the "usual way" of mitigating this kind of risk.

>And what's the wife's protection in that case?

I didn't say she gets any - or that she should even sign. Just that asking her to sign is not some sort of one-sided trust breaking unless you're assuming it's only being done in bad faith. (ie. so he can cheat on her and if she leaves him because of it she's left out in the cold)

>Except now, there are no consequences for the husband being unfaithful.

Except losing his wife. Sure - it's less of a consequence than losing his wife and half his money... but if the consequence of losing her isn't enough to ensure faithfulness then that should be enough reason for her to leave.

Re:SF engineer came to money and now wants wife to sign a po... by s73ver_ on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @09:03PM (#16012336)
"As far as the business is concerned - not really."

Right, but we're not just talking about a business. We're also talking about a marriage. Which would probably say that the business perspective is even less relevant.

Re:SF engineer came to money and now wants wife to sign a po... by wolfgke on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @04:41PM (#16011222)
> Given that millions of businesses are started while one party is married, and don't have this problem, I don't consider it to be a valid concern.

Given that lots of BASE jumpers survived their jumps, BASE jumping cannot be a really dangerous sport.

Re:SF engineer came to money and now wants wife to sign a po... by wolfgke on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @03:48PM (#16010924)
> I'm sorry, but this line of thinking is abso-fucking-lutely bonkers. If he, or any of you honestly feel that someone would do that, then why are you marrying them?

Trust, but verify (Доверяй, но проверяй).

Re:SF engineer came to money and now wants wife to sign a po... by hkmurakami on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @03:28PM (#16010804)
Her support etc enables that kind of work to be done in the first place.
Re:SF engineer came to money and now wants wife to sign a po... by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @05:15PM (#16011390)
Yup. I've had side projects (none of them ever turned into big money), and I know the price my wife paid for me to have them.

Off topic, but worth stating: Knowing that, I try to be supportive of stuff that she wants to take on.

Re:SF engineer came to money and now wants wife to sign a po... by anigbrowl on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @03:18PM (#16010733)
When you're married, it's a partnership. You don't exist independently of other and go on more regular dates, you live together and are practically and emotionally committed to each other. For all we know he was only able to write those apps because of the emotional and/or financial security she brought to the relationship.
Re:SF engineer came to money and now wants wife to sign a po... by gspetr on Wednesday December 27, 2017 @03:09AM (#16013551)
The very existence of open marriages defies your argument.
Re:SF engineer came to money and now wants wife to sign a po... by andymoe on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @03:18PM (#16010734)
She’s entitled to half because that’s the contract they entered into when they got married.
Re:SF engineer came to money and now wants wife to sign a po... by nasmorn on Tuesday December 26, 2017 @04:01PM (#16010995)
It is funny how you got downvotes for stating a fact. Like when you start a business and someone has vested shares but they don’t do anything much anymore while you are the CEO. Guess what they still own those shares. The unfairness is about the unidirectionality of time. The question is not if it looks fair ex post, but if you deemed it fair ex ante.