Here is my observation based on my experience as a person who was frequently visiting Shenzhen over the last 10 years.
Shenzhen usually deals with "undesirables" much smarter:
1. Moped taxis - Shenzhen was one of first Chinese cities that made taxi - a taxi business. The moment proper taxi rides became available to general population, moped taxis vanished. Although motorcycles are outlawed in Shenzhen, most people running moped taxis were relying on police being reluctant to chase all and every of them. The moment an economic incentive vanished, so they did too.
2. Street food - mostly vanished when the city started to get more zealous on food safety inspections. When citizens were made to understand that a food safety license in a cafe is more than a piece of paper, they began voting with their valets by choosing food safety attested eateries.
3. Garbage scavengers - vanished without a trace once the city kickstarted legal recycling businesses with minimal subsidies.
4. Garage factories - killed by ferric chloride and other chemical detectors in city savage.
and the list goes on.
Beijing usually goes simply - we don't like you, firing squads will come this afternoon.
I’m hopeful you didn’t intentionally imply slavery was a good thing, but that’s essentially what you wrote.
Noting the degrees of awfulness between various poverty cases does not endorse of any of them. This attack is lazy thinking in the extreme.
If one think that’s “better off” as OP stated, then I guess we will have to agree to disagree.
Agree, thus toned down my reply a bit. After comments like “recalibrate your Bernie Sanders radar” (I’m a registered Republican if that matters, but haven’t voted along party lines in years) and being accused of being lazy and attacking someone (which I certainly didn’t), my tone might’ve caught a bit of unintended edge.
I do find it interesting that all three comments in reply to me added zero to engaging the conversation, yet you replied to me. I guess I’ll take it as a compliment that you saw merit in what I said if only it had a been a bit less on edge.
Yes, Beijing used to be cruel to migrant workers. Other cities in China used to be cruel, too. Being caught without a permit could lead to detention and forced labour until repatriated in early 2000s.
It is not even the fault of the Beijing local residents be to blame for the tragedy today. The cream of economy development was either intentionally or unintentionally hoarded in the metropolises while the second tiers cities never get the chance. People have to migrate and follow the money.