News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jakarta Is Sinking So Fast, It Could End Up Underwater by rainbowmverse on Saturday December 23, 2017 @04:43PM (#15996414)
You used a lot of words to hide the lack of any support for your argument.
Re:Jakarta Is Sinking So Fast, It Could End Up Underwater by oldandtired on Saturday December 23, 2017 @05:43PM (#15996681)
Do the simple calculations yourself and see what they need to explain.
Re:Jakarta Is Sinking So Fast, It Could End Up Underwater by mikestew on Saturday December 23, 2017 @06:14PM (#15996850)
You’ll go a lot further in convincing me of your argument by not assigning me math homework. That, and experience says that almost any time someone says something like “do the research/math yourself” and I do, turns out they’re full of shit, thereby explaining why they didn’t just answer a straight question.

So no, I won’t be doing any simple calculations.

Re:Jakarta Is Sinking So Fast, It Could End Up Underwater by idle_processor on Saturday December 23, 2017 @07:05PM (#15997084)
Kind of a violation of the burden of proof.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burden_of_proof_(law)

Re:Jakarta Is Sinking So Fast, It Could End Up Underwater by DonHopkins on Saturday December 23, 2017 @07:50PM (#15997252)
It seems like you made a big mistake when you did the simple calculations yourself, so we'd like to see YOUR work. Because if you actually did the simple calculations correctly, and if you actually did get the results you claim, then you should be to quite happy show your work to us. Or did the dog eat your homework? Are you suddenly so indignant about being asked for proof because you're just blustering, and demanding that other people do simple calculations you were too lazy and insincere to do yourself just to divert the argument?

How about instead of throwing the term "politically correct" around three times in the same post, you show us something "mathematically correct"?

Re:Jakarta Is Sinking So Fast, It Could End Up Underwater by oldandtired on Saturday December 23, 2017 @08:44PM (#15997418)
See the starting point below. It will take you five minutes to do the calculations. Then you make up your mind if "politically correct" is an appropriate label.
Re:Jakarta Is Sinking So Fast, It Could End Up Underwater by DonHopkins on Saturday December 23, 2017 @10:33PM (#15997755)
Starting point? I though they were "simple calculations" that you had already easily performed and completely finished correctly, that anyone else should easily be able to do, which proved your point beyond a doubt. Why are you changing the goalposts? Take the five minutes and finish your own homework yourself instead of telling me to do it for you.

"Politically Correct" describes the Trump Administration's politically motivated denial of science. "Scientifically Correct" describes the vast body of consistent peer reviewed evidence that you and the Trump Administration are denying, on which an overwhelming majority of scientists agree.

The burden of proof and obligation to take at least five minutes citing evidence and crunching the numbers lies in your court, since you're the one calling everyone a liar then changing the goalposts. So start responding to people's questions and stop stonewalling and deflecting.

The fact that you agree with Donald Trump and parrot his blustering insincere persuasion techniques instead of citing scientific evidence should be a clue that you're wrong.

What else do you agree with him on? Do you also agree with Donald Trump that teaching evolution and allowing gay marriage is "political correctness", too? And what about all those women who accused him and Roy Moore of sexual assault, is each and every one of them a liar too, just like all of those scientists?

Re:Jakarta Is Sinking So Fast, It Could End Up Underwater by oldandtired on Sunday December 24, 2017 @12:12AM (#15998074)
The starting point is the figures given so for those who cannot or are not able to look up the figures for themselves can do the calculations. It appears that some people are incapable of doing even the easiest of searches for freely available information.

IT is obvious that you are thinking that when someone supplies you with the starting point and then encourages you to take the next step that you consider that they are unable to do so themselves.

"Politically correct" is no less a label to be applied to any of the political arena's (such as the Trump administration or the failed attempt by the Clinton Team) than it is to be applied to many areas in Science, Medicine and other supposedly logical disciplines. When dogma takes over and fights against systematic investigation of a subject then "political correctness" is on the march.

If you fail to see this happening, mayhaps, you should do a systematic study of history with regards to science and technology. People are people and all of us have biases. It takes work to not allow those biases to get in the road of systematic investigation.

If the Emperor's New Clothes are unseen then one has the opportunity to say such. In this particular case, the Emperor's New Clothes are the 1 to 10 metre ocean level rise scenarios.

You have the opportunity to call me any thing you like. I don't agree with Mr Trump. The US had a choice between two disagreeable teams, Trump who is an Isolationist and Clinton who is a Globalist. Neither was going to be useful to the future of the US.

The "burden of proof" lies with the anthropogenic climate change (ACC) community. Answering simple questions like "where the energy processes are" in a forthright manner instead of the essentially sensationalist manner that has been their habit for decades, would go a long way to be credible.

If someone says to you that it is storming outside, do you just believe them or do you actually look outside and do your own investigation? I have given you the base information and if you cannot be proactive enough to spend five minutes doing your calculations then what expectation should I have of you actually spending five minutes looking at any detailed figures I give you?

Since you bring up evolution, no I don't believe in the evolutionary theory (or theories) being promulgated. My reason is because I spent a lot of time reading the experimental evidence that was done and noting that the conclusions derived by those experimenters was different to the evidence that they found. Since, at that time, I was a believer in evolution, this made no sense to me and challenged me to look at it further. My considered opinion is that evolution as promulgated is dogma and has no basis in reality. I consider the various theories of evolution and the attendant alternatives in intelligent design to be philosophical and religious in nature and not science.

It is unfortunate that all sorts of people engage in the sexual harassment and sexual domination of others. This is inappropriate at any time, no matter whether it is a man doing it to a woman or to another man or a woman doing it to a man or another woman. The interesting thing is that some of those victims will be liars and others will be deeply hurt victims. The question is determining the truth of the matter.

However, that is a social matter that is not relevant to the discussion of whether or not climate science is full of dogma. Bringing up such is simply saying that you are so caught up in your dogma that you cannot afford to listen and discuss with someone else an idea that is opposed to your world view and that you are willing to attack the man instead of the statement.

I have robust discussions with various people and those of us who partake are expected to defend our stand points, with the expectation that those disagreeing will also actively contribute.

The emperor is naked and it is time for people to stand and say so.

Re:Jakarta Is Sinking So Fast, It Could End Up Underwater by mistermann on Sunday December 24, 2017 @01:27PM (#16000600)
> The starting point is the figures given so for those who cannot or are not able to look up the figures for themselves can do the calculations. It appears that some people are incapable of doing even the easiest of searches for freely available information.

The figures given where? What's this energy equation or calculation you talk about as if it's common knowledge?

Re:Jakarta Is Sinking So Fast, It Could End Up Underwater by DonHopkins on Sunday December 24, 2017 @04:54PM (#16001479)
Several people asked him repeatedly to post his numbers and links to his sources, but he continues to stonewall and deflect. He can't answer those questions so he won't, which proves my point that he's not arguing in good faith. That's just how people who subscribe to conspiracy theories predictably behave.
Re:Jakarta Is Sinking So Fast, It Could End Up Underwater by rainbowmverse on Saturday December 23, 2017 @06:05PM (#15996810)
These simple calculations and the data needed for them would be a great thing for you to provide to support your claims.
Re:Jakarta Is Sinking So Fast, It Could End Up Underwater by oldandtired on Saturday December 23, 2017 @08:28PM (#15997371)
I have provided this information in detail in the past and those who have challenged me to do so haven't even bothered to check it or respond. The information is freely available in all sort of resources. The bits you need are the surface area of the earth and the surface area of the oceans, the volume of land based ice required to melt to fill the appropriate surface area to whatever level you require (in my case 1 metre), the amount of energy required to do the phase change of 1 kg of solid H2O to liquid H2O (which is approx equivalent raising 1 Kg of liquid H2O from 0 degrees Celsius to 84-85 degrees Celsius) and viola you have your results. This give an approximation to the energy required and even if you were 20% out in any of your figures, the amount is of such a magnitude that those errors are fundamentally insignificant for the planetary effects that such an amount of energy would do.

That amount of energy on the lower bounds would have caused all life to become extinct before we would see the oceans rise by any significant amount.

Many years ago, I gave these calculations to a senior climate scientist and he noted at the time that the results were interesting and he would get back to me after he had analysed those figures. That was what 15 or more years ago and I have never heard anything back since those discussions.

I have provided such figures in detail to various climate scientists asking for their analysis and basically no response. Not even to the extent of saying that the calculations were flawed.

So when ever any fool climate scientist or their supporters promulgate any scenario that says we should expect any significant ocean level rises inside of 100 years (significant being anything above 0.5 metre - especially those who promulgate 1 to 10 metres) due to human activity then the onus is on them to demonstrate where the energy processes are occurring. They have not done so to date and based on their dogma, I suspect that they cannot.

The problem with all of this politically correct dogma is that they (the climate scientists en bulk) are not doing any science.

I have said it in the past - there are no stupid questions. It seems to be today that funding is the driver to follow the crowd and to not do actual science.

We need to know what is happening in our climate. This is irrespective of any ideological standpoint you may hold. If you challenge the anthropogenic climate change (ACC) dogma then you are anathema. Even if you believe in climate change, if you do not follow the party line then you are an infidel that needs to be destroyed. Jihad not only occurs in extreme Islam but is alive and well in Climate Science as well.

This whole matter is simple enough for a fifth grader to solve, let alone an adult who should be able to do this in 20 minutes (including looking up the information).

Scepticism has its place and we need a few more sceptics when it comes to the lack of rigour that is being used by those who promulgate such scenarios. If you want to follow a fool where he leads without at least a cursory look at the base of what they are saying then you are free to do so. When someone says that you need to look at what they are saying, you don't need to listen, you can just follow blindly.

end rant.

Re:Jakarta Is Sinking So Fast, It Could End Up Underwater by DonHopkins on Saturday December 23, 2017 @10:55PM (#15997840)
Now that your rant has ended, have you ever considered the possibility that there are other reasons you're an anathema and nobody takes you seriously, other than a well organized worldwide conspiracy against you? That would be the scientific thing to do.

First it was 5 minutes. Now it's 20 minutes. Why do you keep missing your own deadlines and changing the goalposts more often than you post any citations to scientific evidence or convincing mathematical proofs like you claim to have and everyone keeps asking you for? You keep throwing out numbers and mentioning "studies done" but never name your sources or link to any of them. Why not? You've been admittedly ranting for a lot longer than you said it would take to actually do the math, and you obviously have enough time on your hands, so get started.

You keep saying how quick and easy it would be for an adult to prove it, yet you never do that yourself. Am I correct to conclude that you're not actually an adult?

Re:Jakarta Is Sinking So Fast, It Could End Up Underwater by oldandtired on Sunday December 24, 2017 @12:23AM (#15998109)
Now I get it why there was a comment on another thread about a cross thread commenting war with you. This is funny.

But let's say, that 20 minutes if you look up the information yourself and you are slow about it, 5 minutes if given the starting point. Of course if you cannot use a calculation device other than pencil/pen and paper (or blackboard and chalk) then it might take you longer.

I have the calculations sitting in spreadsheet on my machine and I have emails to various people with those calculations, but as you are unable to spend 5 minutes doing, I can't expect you to spend 5 minutes reading.

[dead]
Re:Jakarta Is Sinking So Fast, It Could End Up Underwater by sctb on Sunday December 24, 2017 @07:19PM (#16001987)
Come on, would you please stop being so personally thorny? You know that we're here for better than this.
Re:Jakarta Is Sinking So Fast, It Could End Up Underwater by oldandtired on Saturday December 23, 2017 @08:41PM (#15997411)
To make things real simple for those who can't use a search engine, try the following

earth surface area: 510072000 sq km

ocean surface area: 361132000 sq km

latent heat of melting (ice to water): 334 kJ/kg

From these you can calculate the amount (volume) of land based ice required for whatever ocean level rise you need and the amount of energy required to melt said ice.

Note that since only a portion of energy will enter ice, the total energy that would be needed to get the required energy transfer in the ice would be approximately 20 times required energy. This is based on studies done that indicate that it is about 5% of energy absorbed by the planetary system that transfers into the ice portion of the planet.

Re:Jakarta Is Sinking So Fast, It Could End Up Underwater by yorwba on Sunday December 24, 2017 @01:13AM (#15998259)

  from sympy.physics.units import *
  import sympy
  pi = float(sympy.pi)

  earth_surface_area = 510072000 * kilometer**2

  ocean_surface_area = 361132000 * kilometer**2

  latent_heat_of_melting = 334 *(kilo*joule)/kilogram

  volume_for_1_meter_rise = (1*meter) * ocean_surface_area

  # https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_(data_page)
  density_of_water_at_0_deg_celsius = 0.9998395 * gram / centimeter**3

  mass_of_ice = density_of_water_at_0_deg_celsius * volume_for_1_meter_rise

  energy_for_melting = latent_heat_of_melting*mass_of_ice

  convert_to(energy_for_melting, joule) # 1.20598728796876e+23*joule
Is that a lot? Compare to the amount of energy received from the sun.

  # https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunlight#Total_solar_irradiance_(TSI)_and_spectral_solar_irradiance_(SSI)_upon_Earth
  solar_irradiance = 1.361 * (kilo*watt)/(meter**2)

  # https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earth
  earth_radius = 6371 * kilometer

  earth_cross_section = pi * earth_radius**2

  total_solar_irradiance = solar_irradiance * earth_cross_section

  time_for_melting = energy_for_melting / total_solar_irradiance
  
  convert_to(time_for_melting, years) # 0.0220203816289806*tropical_year
What is your fudge factor for how much of that energy gets dumped into melting ice? 1000? 10000? Even then you get quite a few centimeters on the scale of decades or centuries.
Re:Jakarta Is Sinking So Fast, It Could End Up Underwater by openasocket on Saturday December 23, 2017 @09:46PM (#15997601)
Surface area? Don't you need volume to compute the thermal expansion of the ocean? And you also need the volume of land ice to compute how much might melt... if you want to convince people, you need to do more than just provide four statistics and walk away, you need to show how you use those to compute the level of expansion. Which you haven't done, and I'm 99% sure you can't with just those four numbers.
Re:Jakarta Is Sinking So Fast, It Could End Up Underwater by oldandtired on Sunday December 24, 2017 @12:18AM (#15998092)
Surface area by height (1 to 10 metres) is volume. Of course, if one doesn't know that specific idea then one might be stuck. The volume of land ice can be assumed to be sufficient by the scenarios given. As far as ice expansion is concerned, not really relevant for a first approximation for the energy required as it is relatively small.
Re:Jakarta Is Sinking So Fast, It Could End Up Underwater by averagewall on Sunday December 24, 2017 @02:59AM (#15998541)
I find that when you're talking about technical things on the internet, it's best to assume the other person knows common knowledge and only doesn't know the idea you're trying to express. It's almost impossible that the GP didn't know V=A*h so pointing it out is more of an insult than anything useful.
Re:Jakarta Is Sinking So Fast, It Could End Up Underwater by openasocket on Sunday December 24, 2017 @01:23AM (#15998298)
I mean you need to know the volume of all the water in the ocean. Because as the temperature rises the water expands, which leads to rising sea levels, in addition to the land ice melting.
Re:Jakarta Is Sinking So Fast, It Could End Up Underwater by yorwba on Sunday December 24, 2017 @02:19AM (#15998434)
To compute the total energy requirements, you don't really need to know the ocean volume, if you are willing to linearly approximate the thermal expansion. If you have less water, the same amount of energy will heat it up to a proportionally higher temperature and correspondingly expand it more, resulting in approximately the same sea level rise.

Obviously this breaks down if you want a more accurate figure, but in that case you also have to account for water shrinking with increasing temperature between 0 °C and 4 °C and so on.

In any case, melting a bunch of ice is a much more energy-efficient way of increasing the volume of liquid water than heating already molten water. The energy required for melting ice is roughly the same as that for heating the water to 80 °C, and 80 °C is not twice as voluminous as 0 °C water.

Re:Jakarta Is Sinking So Fast, It Could End Up Underwater by shripadk on Saturday December 23, 2017 @09:12PM (#15997501)
Pray tell me: where in your calculations are you calculating the one variable that matters the most: "Mean Sea Level".
Re:Jakarta Is Sinking So Fast, It Could End Up Underwater by oldandtired on Saturday December 23, 2017 @09:26PM (#15997538)
Shripadk, mean sea level is actually irrelevant as far as these calculation are concerned. Really irrelevant. The climate scientists throw around their 1 to 10 metre or more scenarios and so all we need concern ourselves with is the gross minimum volume of ice required to melt.

Since the planet is an oblate sphere with a non-uniform land distribution and we have a large moon orbiting the planet, any prediction of what we would expect to see as an ocean level rise will depend critically on where on the planet you are stationed as well as the effects of tides.

In addition, any rises of the magnitudes predicted will require more ice to be melted not less as there will be inundation effects that will, in effect, increase the amount of surface area attributed to the oceans.

Hence, all calculations are a minimum not a maximum. If you want to seriously model tidal and inundation effects, then the amount of energy will greater and hence more unexplained by these very climate scientists.

If they cannot give an explanation of the energy requirements for a minimum then they will most certainly be unable to explain for any situation requiring tidal and inundation effects to be accounted for.

So mean ocean level is irrelevant.

Re:Jakarta Is Sinking So Fast, It Could End Up Underwater by shripadk on Sunday December 24, 2017 @01:06AM (#15998234)
How is mean sea level irrelevant? Global warming directly affects the mean sea level. You don't need to go around measuring surface area/volume of ocean,ice and land and what not! All you need is to calculate the mean sea level and compare it with historical data.

And your theory on tidal effects of the moon falls flat because mean sea level takes all those factors into consideration! How? The name itself suggests that it's a "mean" over all variations in the sea levels due to tidal or inundation effects. Unless the gravitational pull of the moon dramatically increased or the moon got closer to the Earth your theory makes some sense. But the effects are pretty uniform. So mean sea level is the only meaningful statistic here. It's real and measurable. Everything else is bogus claims by climate change deniers!

Re:Jakarta Is Sinking So Fast, It Could End Up Underwater by DonHopkins on Saturday December 23, 2017 @11:12PM (#15997891)
Again, we keep asking you for proof and citations and links to your sources, and you keep calling people liars and deflecting from answering the questions. Until you post links to sources that actually prove what you say, instead of reciting anecdotes about how some mean old scientist ignored you 15 years ago, there's no reason for anyone to take you seriously, and there's a lot of evidence explaining why you're treated like an anathema.
Re:Jakarta Is Sinking So Fast, It Could End Up Underwater by traek on Saturday December 23, 2017 @06:54PM (#15997036)
My new favorite form of argument.

“Do the math yourself. QED.”